Announcement

Collapse

Forum Rules (Everyone Must Read!!!)

1] What you CAN NOT post.

You agree, through your use of this service, that you will not use this forum to post any material which is:
- abusive
- vulgar
- hateful
- harassing
- personal attacks
- obscene

You also may not:
- post images that are too large (max is 500*500px)
- post any copyrighted material unless the copyright is owned by you or cited properly.
- post in UPPER CASE, which is considered yelling
- post messages which insult the Armenians, Armenian culture, traditions, etc
- post racist or other intentionally insensitive material that insults or attacks another culture (including Turks)

The Ankap thread is excluded from the strict rules because that place is more relaxed and you can vent and engage in light insults and humor. Notice it's not a blank ticket, but just a place to vent. If you go into the Ankap thread, you enter at your own risk of being clowned on.
What you PROBABLY SHOULD NOT post...
Do not post information that you will regret putting out in public. This site comes up on Google, is cached, and all of that, so be aware of that as you post. Do not ask the staff to go through and delete things that you regret making available on the web for all to see because we will not do it. Think before you post!


2] Use descriptive subject lines & research your post. This means use the SEARCH.

This reduces the chances of double-posting and it also makes it easier for people to see what they do/don't want to read. Using the search function will identify existing threads on the topic so we do not have multiple threads on the same topic.

3] Keep the focus.

Each forum has a focus on a certain topic. Questions outside the scope of a certain forum will either be moved to the appropriate forum, closed, or simply be deleted. Please post your topic in the most appropriate forum. Users that keep doing this will be warned, then banned.

4] Behave as you would in a public location.

This forum is no different than a public place. Behave yourself and act like a decent human being (i.e. be respectful). If you're unable to do so, you're not welcome here and will be made to leave.

5] Respect the authority of moderators/admins.

Public discussions of moderator/admin actions are not allowed on the forum. It is also prohibited to protest moderator actions in titles, avatars, and signatures. If you don't like something that a moderator did, PM or email the moderator and try your best to resolve the problem or difference in private.

6] Promotion of sites or products is not permitted.

Advertisements are not allowed in this venue. No blatant advertising or solicitations of or for business is prohibited.
This includes, but not limited to, personal resumes and links to products or
services with which the poster is affiliated, whether or not a fee is charged
for the product or service. Spamming, in which a user posts the same message repeatedly, is also prohibited.

7] We retain the right to remove any posts and/or Members for any reason, without prior notice.


- PLEASE READ -

Members are welcome to read posts and though we encourage your active participation in the forum, it is not required. If you do participate by posting, however, we expect that on the whole you contribute something to the forum. This means that the bulk of your posts should not be in "fun" threads (e.g. Ankap, Keep & Kill, This or That, etc.). Further, while occasionally it is appropriate to simply voice your agreement or approval, not all of your posts should be of this variety: "LOL Member213!" "I agree."
If it is evident that a member is simply posting for the sake of posting, they will be removed.


8] These Rules & Guidelines may be amended at any time. (last update September 17, 2009)

If you believe an individual is repeatedly breaking the rules, please report to admin/moderator.
See more
See less

Not an unequivocal image of the Armenian Genocide

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Not an unequivocal image of the Armenian Genocide

    The following caught my eye. The translated version is from groong.com/news

    Collector turns money over to Yerevan Genocide Museum in Solidarity

    A British collector who sold a picture on the Armenian genocide,
    learning that she was destined to Genocide Museum in Yerevan, returned
    the amount of the purchase. Magnificent gesture Armenpress reported
    today by the agency following statements from Hayk Demoyan, director
    of the Genocide Museum. The photo shows Armenians fleeing genocide. On
    the back of the photo is written "Baghdad is one of the centers of
    Armenian survivors escaped the massacres perpetrated by the Turks,
    where the service and food are provided by the British government. The
    Turks are enemies of the Armenians because they are Christians and
    them not. " Haig Demoyan says "having bought and paid for the photo, I
    was surprised to receive a letter from the vendor who wrote" I sent
    you a photo you bought . When I was writing your address, I understood
    where she was to arrive, so I send you your payment. I do this out of
    respect to your dead and in friendship " .

    In this year of the 100th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, the
    words of the British collector towards Armenians of particular
    meaning.

    Krikor Amirzayan

    Sunday, January 11, 2015,
    Krikor Amirzayan armenews.com

    http://www.armenews.com/article.php3?id_article=106870

    The photo seemed familiar. Searching back a few weeks I found it on ebay.com. It was eBay item number 121508693245, sold for 42 on 12th December, seller was racegair1. The auction description was:

    For auction is a collection of postcards/photocards sent by Driver Billy Butcher during his service in the First World War and then in Mesopotamia in the 1920s. On the way to Mesopotamia (Iraq) he called in at Malta, Aden and Egypt. There are also cards for those places. Some have been written on by him and some have also been cleared by the Field Censor as they were sent through the relevant British Field Post Office. For each lot I will transcribe what has been entered on the back.

    For this particular lot the picture is of Armenian Refugees Fleeing Turkey'. It has a tiny crease on the corner but is in good order apart from that. On the back is written 'Baghdad is the Headquarters of the Armenian Relief Committee of refugees and survivors of the Turkish massacres pour into the country, where they are housed, clothed and fed by the British Government. Their offence against the Turks is that they are Christians and the Turks are not'

    The photo is a little faded and on flimsy paper not like a postcard.
    I had seen the photo when it was listed - and had dismissed it as unimportant. Why? Because it was a commercially produced image and there is no evidence indicating that it really is Armenian refugees that are depicted. It must have been one of a number of photographs purchased by Billy Butcher when stationed in Iraq because the seller had listed several others on ebay. For example there was one showing "Shekh Oomar's Tomb, Baghdad" eBay item number: 121508703144. It too had handwriting on the back: 'I get a good view of this tomb from the train just before reaching Baghdad. (a Shekh is a powerful chief and rules over a certain district)'. The photographs all have a caption on their front, indicating that they are all commercially produced photographs and are part of a series. The "Armenian refugees" photo is captioned "refugees" and has a number "29". The "Shekh Oomar's Tomb" photo is number 20.

    The "refugees", if they are that, could be anyone. In the background there is an individual with a rifle over his shoulder, suggesting a protective escort and an organised evacuation. They could, for example, be Nestorian or Syriac Christians fleeing post-WW1 Kurdish massacres.
    There is nothing to directly connect the handwritten text with the image. Billy Butcher could easily have just been writing the most obvious thing that he knew about regarding refugees in Iraq, to whomever he was sending the photos to.

    I hope the Genocide Museum does not enter this item into their collection as an unequivocal image of the Armenian Genocide, because it is not that.
    Plenipotentiary meow!

  • #2
    Re: Not an unequivocal image of the Armenian Genocide

    The front and back of the photo:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Armenian Refugees 1920s Photo Mesopotamia Drv Billy Butcher RFA 1.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	91.1 KB
ID:	539084

    Click image for larger version

Name:	Armenian Refugees 1920s Photo Mesopotamia Drv Billy Butcher RFA 2.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	93.6 KB
ID:	539085



    And the mosque photo:

    Click image for larger version

Name:	sheik Oomar.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	88.2 KB
ID:	539086
    Plenipotentiary meow!

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Not an unequivocal image of the Armenian Genocide

      More on William Henry Butcher

      For auction is a set of first world war medals issued to Driver William Henry Butcher of the Royal Field Artillery for service in the first world war and Mesopotamia/Iraq. The Iraq general service medal has the inscription around the rim '291143 DVR W. H. BUTCHER R.A. It has the Iraq clasp. The war medal has '786602 DVR W.H. BUTCHER R.A.' and the 1914/1918 medal has '291143 DVR W.H. BUTCHER R.A.' incised on them. I also attach a phot of the WW1 Medal Rolls Index. You will see from this that Billy Butcher had three service numbers and will also see when he was awarded the medals. Also there are two postcards. The first one is of Billy Butcher in his uniform and carrying a pith helmet. I can only assume that this was taken in Mesopotamia. On the reverse is written 'To Alice with love from Billy'. The second postcard is a picture of what he describes on the reverse as 'Some of the lads of B.A.C 2/3 West Riding Field Artillery Bde'
      .

      Click image for larger version

Name:	Billy Butcher.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	93.2 KB
ID:	539087
      Click image for larger version

Name:	Billy Butcher 2.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	96.8 KB
ID:	539088
      Click image for larger version

Name:	Billy Butcher 5.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	93.7 KB
ID:	539089
      Click image for larger version

Name:	Billy Butcher 3.jpg
Views:	1
Size:	90.9 KB
ID:	539090
      Plenipotentiary meow!

      Comment

      Working...
      X