Announcement

Collapse

Forum Rules (Everyone Must Read!!!)

1] What you CAN NOT post.

You agree, through your use of this service, that you will not use this forum to post any material which is:
- abusive
- vulgar
- hateful
- harassing
- personal attacks
- obscene

You also may not:
- post images that are too large (max is 500*500px)
- post any copyrighted material unless the copyright is owned by you or cited properly.
- post in UPPER CASE, which is considered yelling
- post messages which insult the Armenians, Armenian culture, traditions, etc
- post racist or other intentionally insensitive material that insults or attacks another culture (including Turks)

The Ankap thread is excluded from the strict rules because that place is more relaxed and you can vent and engage in light insults and humor. Notice it's not a blank ticket, but just a place to vent. If you go into the Ankap thread, you enter at your own risk of being clowned on.
What you PROBABLY SHOULD NOT post...
Do not post information that you will regret putting out in public. This site comes up on Google, is cached, and all of that, so be aware of that as you post. Do not ask the staff to go through and delete things that you regret making available on the web for all to see because we will not do it. Think before you post!


2] Use descriptive subject lines & research your post. This means use the SEARCH.

This reduces the chances of double-posting and it also makes it easier for people to see what they do/don't want to read. Using the search function will identify existing threads on the topic so we do not have multiple threads on the same topic.

3] Keep the focus.

Each forum has a focus on a certain topic. Questions outside the scope of a certain forum will either be moved to the appropriate forum, closed, or simply be deleted. Please post your topic in the most appropriate forum. Users that keep doing this will be warned, then banned.

4] Behave as you would in a public location.

This forum is no different than a public place. Behave yourself and act like a decent human being (i.e. be respectful). If you're unable to do so, you're not welcome here and will be made to leave.

5] Respect the authority of moderators/admins.

Public discussions of moderator/admin actions are not allowed on the forum. It is also prohibited to protest moderator actions in titles, avatars, and signatures. If you don't like something that a moderator did, PM or email the moderator and try your best to resolve the problem or difference in private.

6] Promotion of sites or products is not permitted.

Advertisements are not allowed in this venue. No blatant advertising or solicitations of or for business is prohibited.
This includes, but not limited to, personal resumes and links to products or
services with which the poster is affiliated, whether or not a fee is charged
for the product or service. Spamming, in which a user posts the same message repeatedly, is also prohibited.

7] We retain the right to remove any posts and/or Members for any reason, without prior notice.


- PLEASE READ -

Members are welcome to read posts and though we encourage your active participation in the forum, it is not required. If you do participate by posting, however, we expect that on the whole you contribute something to the forum. This means that the bulk of your posts should not be in "fun" threads (e.g. Ankap, Keep & Kill, This or That, etc.). Further, while occasionally it is appropriate to simply voice your agreement or approval, not all of your posts should be of this variety: "LOL Member213!" "I agree."
If it is evident that a member is simply posting for the sake of posting, they will be removed.


8] These Rules & Guidelines may be amended at any time. (last update September 17, 2009)

If you believe an individual is repeatedly breaking the rules, please report to admin/moderator.
See more
See less

Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

    The Armenian Church is Held Hostage by Its Hierarchy: Part 3

    By Vosgan Mekhitarian
    November 5, 2013
    The continuing culture of corruption and abuse of power at the Catholicosate level of the Armenian church becomes more than evident when we consider the impact the resignation letter of the Primate of France, His Eminence Archbishop...


    The continuing culture of corruption and abuse of power at the Catholicosate level of the Armenian church becomes more than evident when we consider the impact the resignation letter of the Primate of France, His Eminence Archbishop NorvanZakarian, has been having on the psyche of the current and future generations of the clergy.

    Let us begin our analysis of the present state of affairs of the Armenian Church by introducing Archbishop NorvanZakarian, in order to provide a context for understanding the unjust victimization and severity of penal threats levied by CatholicosKarekin II against this devoted and humble servant of God.

    Archbishop NorvanZakarian was born in Beirut, Lebanon, in 1940. After graduating from the local parochial elementary school, he attended the seminary of the Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia. Thereafter, he pursued his higher education at the St. James’ Brotherhood Seminary in Jerusalem. In 1967, he went to France to continue his theological studies. Archbishop SerovpeManoukian, the former Primate of France, recognized the exceptional character of this young seminarian and ordained him as celibate priest in 1968.

    In appreciation of his many years of service in the Church, His Holiness CatholicosVazken I ordained him a bishop in 1982. Bishop Zakarian has had a long and distinguished track record of selfless and obedient service to his parish and church. Moreover, he played an instrumental role in creating and establishing the Armenian Church Diocese of France. He was the force behind the movement that transformed that dream into reality.

    In 2007, by a majority of the votes of the Diocesan Assembly he was elected as the first Primate of the newly-created Diocese of France, followed by his nomination as a member of the Supreme Spiritual Council of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin and appointment as Pontifical Legate to the Armenian communities of Western Europe.

    Those who have come to know Archbishop Zakarian have consistently regarded him as a model clergyman, always willing and able to serve the needs of his parishioners, who possesses the intellectual integrity of the highest caliber—predicating any number of important achievements. This is truly a dedicated man of the cloth, who has become the pride of the Church and has won the hearts and minds of the faithful.

    Archbishop NorvanZakarian is currently being targeted for ostracization and vilified by vengeful wrath and subsequent shunning by the Catholicos for not supporting the priest VatcheHairabedian, a known convicted criminal. Archbishop Zakarian summarizes his disappointment at Karekin II’s behavior and verbal invectives in his letter, stating, “For a while now, I have come to realize that insulting me and hurting my feelings somehow gives you pleasure. Your accusations addressed to me, indeed, surprise me. You probably do not realize you are squashing the moral integrity of a human being beneath your feet.”

    The phrase, “for a while now” leads one to believe that this volley of threats is not singular in nature, but just the latest attempt to humiliate and defrock him by a disgruntled and vindictive head of the church. In fact, the Archbishop iterates in his four-page letter addressed to the members of the Supreme Spiritual Council many other instances of his public chastisement by the Catholicos. We must ask ourselves if this is the just and proper show of appreciation for his 45 years of dutiful service to the Church and nation. Granted, as Christians we can only expect recognition for our good deeds from the Almighty. However, is it not only reasonable to expect not to be persecuted and undermined for such deeds? How can such indefensible behavior by the highest authority of the Church be justified and what message does it send to the new, aspiring generation of seminarians vowed to serve the Church?

    A specific incident in a public location, disclosed by Archbishop NorvanZakarian, attests to the extent of the injury inflicted on him by His Holiness Karekin II, who, upon visiting the Diocese in France, launched into a tirade, declaring, “I will take away your hood…I will take away your cloak…I will make you stand before your parishioners and have them witness your punishment. You will not be able to perform conduct any ceremonies such as baptisms, matrimony or funeral.”

    Archbishop Zakarian has expressed his frustrations with the leadership of the Church by reiterating that the Armenian Church has long stood for love, grace, and compassion, whereas the current powers have instilled a culture of fear and intimidation.

    Indeed, this is a very sad state of affairs, but these revelations are nothing new. Other high and low ranking priests have been targeted as well, yet the turmoil and abuse of power continues. His Holiness Aram I, of the Catholicosate of Cilicia, suffers from the same megalomaniacal psychopathy, who has declared on several occasions to his young priests, “…anyone who does not listen and obey my orders, I will smash him and cast aside like a dirty rag and will humiliate him, and will make him suffer”. Young priests, the world over, are attesting to this kind of humiliation today. How is it feasible to attract young people to come and serve the Church under such dreadful conditions? Indeed, it is not!

    Let us make it clear: our concerns are not so much with particular individuals, --although the actions of the current leadership is at best deplorable,-- but with the lack of brotherly love among all priests and absence of the manifestations of love that was taught to us by Jesus Christ. Concomitantly, we should be distressed by the lawlessness within the hierarchy of Church because at the heart of the matter is a representative institution, for, of, and by the people. Where there is no law, there is infamy and the law of jungle, and hence one loses the ability to listen to public opinion and the ability to conquer conflict or bridge differences, especially among ensuing generations, who are now privy to the turmoil in and moral turpitude of the Church.

    The Church can once again become a beacon of moral and constructive behavior, but only when the ranks of the concerned faithful servants of God abide by His Word and begin acting accordingly. Alas, I am not referring the cowards or those who have sold their souls to please the authorities and gain temporal, worldly awards and decorations.

    Adding insult to injury, non-elected members of the Supreme Spiritual Council of Etchmiadzin have rendered decisions which exemplify their obsequious nature and servile obedience to the morally bankrupt authority of the Church.

    His Holiness Karekin II, in his letter to Archbishop Zakarian, states, “ We were surprised to read your letter and the accusations that you make. It is your duty to prove to the Supreme Spiritual Council in session that your accusations are founded and that you have evidence to prove your allegations”. At prima facie, it seems utterly ridiculous to demand substantiation for something that occurred at a public location and was witnessed by dozens of officials, but there we are at an absurd point of having to prove that the rant of CatholicosKarekin II at the Orly airport of Paris, France, actually took place. Isn’t this latest demand a clear case of the abuse of power and rule with impunity by the head of the Church?

    Who among us is going to have the courage to stand up and declare the truth? For, as the Bible says, “there is nothing hidden that shall not be revealed” (Matt. 10:26).

    (To be continued)
    Plenipotentiary meow!

    Comment


    • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

      The Armenian Church is Held Hostage by Its Hierarchy: Part 4

      By Vosgan Mekhitarian
      November 26, 2013
      The Armenian Apostolic Church must transcend this limited interpretation of its institutional mission if it is to survive


      Illegal election of the members of the Supreme Spiritual Council of Holy Etchmiadzin

      In order to better understand the nature and composition of the Supreme Spiritual Council of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin, we must view it in historical perspective -- how it came to be, and how it evolved throughout the years.

      The first reference to the expression “Concerning the Spiritual Consistories And Governing [Bodies] Of Gregorian Armenians” is found in the 1831 Constitution,--commonly referred to as the “Polozhenye,”—which was imposed upon the Catholicosate of Holy Etchmiadzin by the then Russian Tsarist regime. Its original text was written in Russian and subsequently translated into Armenian by Mkrditch Kardashian.

      Next, we encounter a reference to the Supreme Spiritual Council of the Armenian Church in the “Regulations Concerning the Convening of The National Ecclesiastical Council,” established by his Holiness Catholicos Kevork V on October 22, 1925, and validated on May 28, 1930. In this iteration of the Constitution, it is stated: "The duties of the National Ecclesiastical Council are: (a) To elect a new Catholicos; (b) To elect new members of the Supreme Spiritual Council of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin.” It continues by listing four additional duties.

      The next citation of the Supreme Spiritual Council is found in the “Regulations Concerning the Convening Of The National Ecclesiastical Council,” as validated by His Holiness Catholicos Kevork VI on June 19, 1945, wherein we read, "The duties of the National Ecclesiastical Council are: (a) To elect a new Catholicos; (b) To elect new members of the Supreme Spiritual Council of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin.” It continues by listing three additional duties.

      Thereafter, many drafts of the Constitution have been prepared, but, to date, none has been officially validated and put into action.

      Without deviating from the topic at hand, it is instructive to note that Chapter One (“Fundamental Principles”), Article 13, of the “Draft Constitution of the Holy Armenian Apostolic Church” (prepared in 1958) states: “The administration of the Holy Armenian Apostolic Church is formed by democratic principles. The faithful elect their leaders, --Priest, Bishop, Catholicos, -- of their own free will.” Article 14: “The Armenian Apostolic Church is governed by the principle of democratic elections.” These two points will become germane to our discussion in the offing.

      In this 1958 Draft Constitution it is clearly stated that the duties of the National Ecclesiastical Council are: “(a) to elect a new Catholicos, (b) to elect the members of the Supreme Spiritual Council.” I this same Draft, under the heading of the Supreme Spiritual Council, it is stated that “The Supreme Spiritual Council is the consulting body of the Catholicos of All Armenians, elected by the National Ecclesiastical Council, for a term of five years. The Supreme Spiritual Council consists of nine to eleven members, of which only four shall be lay people.”

      Another draft, dated September 20, 1987, and prepared by Archbishop Tiran Nersoyan, is of particular interest. Under the heading of Supreme Spiritual Council, it states: The Supreme Spiritual Council consists of eight bishops, --if need be, also of celibate priests,-- and four lay people. The members of the Supreme Spiritual Council are appointed by the Catholicos of All Armenians.” This version, granting supreme powers to the Catholicos and deviating from the initial intent of members being democratically elected, was never validated either by the Council of Bishops or the National Ecclesiastical Assembly.

      A subsequent Constitutional Draft appeared in September, 1988, written in Western Armenian Dialect and Classical Armenian Orthography. Even though there are no signatories at the end of this draft, it seems to be the work of Archbishop Tiran Nersoyan because it is similar in tone, scope, and nature to the above mentioned 1987 draft, containing analogous language, with new additions and deletions.

      The 1991 draft of the Constitution, which bears the seal of the Supreme Spiritual Council and is not validated by the National Ecclesiastical Council or the Catholicos, contains some further changes. Under the heading of Supreme Spiritual Council –which consists of eight articles--, Article Five states: “The Supreme Spiritual Council consists of ten members: two bishops from the Diasporan dioceses; five bishops from the internal [i.e. non-Diasporan] dioceses, three of which are appointed by His Holiness and two are elected by the Council of Bishops; and three laymen from the internal dioceses.”

      The last draft of the Constitution is written in Western Armenian and Classical Armenian orthography, prepared in September, 1995, By Archbishop Vatche Hovsepian and Bishop Aris Shirvanian. In this draft, under the heading of Supreme Spiritual Council, we find 18 articles defining the duties and obligations of the members of the Council. Under Articles Four and Five, respectively, it states: “The Supreme Spiritual Council comprises a minimum of 21 members—14 of which should be bishops and, if need be, married and celibate priests, with an additional 7 lay members. The members of the Supreme Spiritual Council are elected by the National Ecclesiastical Council or by the Diocesan Representatives Council for a 4-year term and are eligible to be re-elected for another term.”

      These historical facts offer a chronological profile of the evolution of the Supreme Spiritual Council of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin as delineated under the articles of the various drafts described above. Since no Constitution has been validated by either the National Ecclesiastical Council or the Catholicos since 1945, every decision and action taken after 1945 by the Supreme Spiritual Council, --many of whose members are/were directly appointed by the Catholicos,-- is clearly without legal standing, with no approved authority, and utterly unacceptable.

      The implications and ramifications of the current state in which the Armenian Apostolic Church finds itself are monumental. Its basis for the organizational and governance structures for the Church is constitutionally illegal and illegitimate. Hence, the Church and its hierarchy has no moral or legally justifiable ground upon which to execute its sacred, spiritual charge or carry out its mission to bring the faithful to the Church with full participatory rights. The absence of credibility, accountability, and transparency in the Armenian Church, and the absence of a devoted clergy places the Armenian Church on a precarious legal and moral perch, and possibly, on the brink of dissolution.

      The indifference of our political leaders, educational and benevolent institutions, intellectuals and media has, unwittingly or otherwise, conspired to bring about an oligarchic dictatorship within the Armenian Church—a clear violation of self-proclaimed democratic principles and human values.

      We should never allow "privileged" clergy to hijack the Hierarchy of the Armenian Church and limit the participation of the faithful. The 1995 draft of the Constitution, which, if ratified and validated by the National Ecclesiastical Council, would place this entire religious institution, recognized around the world as the first national Christian Church, in jeopardy of devolving into a religious body with no moral credibility and authority to carry out its spiritual edicts.

      It is incumbent upon every individual of faith and avowed Christian Armenian to express their outrage at the current state of affairs in the Church, shed light upon the unacceptable behavior of the Catholicos and his obsequious henchmen, and demand the restoration of a validated Constitution that obligates the Supreme Spiritual Council to act in accordance with its stated democratic principles and adherence to its founding mission.

      The Armenian Apostolic Church must transcend this limited interpretation of its institutional mission if it is to survive and, indeed, thrive in the modern world. Moreover, it must embrace not only its spiritual commission, but become a beacon for the educational and cultural institutions of the Armenian people, thereby ensuring the continual existence of this proud and faithful nation.

      (To be continued)
      Plenipotentiary meow!

      Comment


      • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

        The Armenian Church is Held Hostage by Its Hierarchy: Part 5

        By Vosgan Mekhitarian
        December 3, 2013
        As we know, the ranks of priesthood (exceptions are always honorable) are replete with individuals who used to be mediocre teachers, sextons (jamgotch), people with singing ability, and those with connections to different organizations. These are...


        The re-evaluation of the spiritual mission of the clergy and the requirement to abstain from involvement in secular business

        Unfortunately some do enter the priesthood because they do not have the courage to work and earn a daily living, while others do so in order to nurture their ambitious, greedy, glorified feelings. Our theory is solidly based on the popular proverb, “Could not succeed in business, therefore became a priest.”

        As we know, the ranks of priesthood (exceptions are always honorable) are replete with individuals who used to be mediocre teachers, sextons (jamgotch), people with singing ability, and those with connections to different organizations. These are the people who consider priesthood as the best way to earn a living and lead a comfortable life.

        Also, there are others who, as some would say, have “street smarts,” and who have entered the priesthood with the anticipation of becoming a prelate of a rich diocese, or becoming a Patriarch or Catholicos, in order to abuse the genteel, spiritual feelings of the faithful for their own personal gain. Unfortunately, the erstwhile truly devoted servants of the faith and Church are very few and pretty much lost among today’s profligate, libertine, and self-serving members of the clergy that fill the ranks of the Church today.

        Keeping in mind that our interest is the re-evaluation of the spiritual mission of the clergy and renewal of their vows, it is imperative that the Church revive itself and inspire people of good morals to enter the priesthood and preach the Gospel following the example of our Lord.

        To enable the success of the spiritual mission of the clergy, the Church has to revive itself and accept into priesthood only those who are well educated, in good moral standing, ready to teach the Gospel and lead the faithful down the righteous path, thereby shutting the doors to those candidates for clergy who are business and profit-minded.

        The world is changing while the power of the Church has waned, and few are attracted to enter the priesthood. There is much turbulence in the Christian faith today. The reasons for this are also evident in the Armenian Apostolic Church. And, clearly, it is not for the want of pursuing spiritual fulfillment –for we see people all around the world who are committed to welcoming faith into their lives– but rather it is due to this incessant hunger for accumulating material wealth which has gripped the imagination and lives of most everyone on this planet.

        It is obvious that some clergy are misguided in their understanding of their profession and devotion to their work. Those who entered the priesthood with a clear understanding of their calling will no doubt be successful in their mission, and the glory of their work will follow…

        Those, on the other hand, who see the priesthood as a business from which to profit with material wealth, cannot understand the meaning of vow and devotion because their minds are focused on money and temporal glory. The lives of such clergymen are full of temptations and scandals.

        Where are the devoted Princes of the Armenian Apostolic Church...those who shined throughout the ages in our monasteries, dioceses and catholicosates...those who devoted their lives to enrich ours with high morals and values?

        For millennia, our monasteries would take pride in being the spiritual and intellectual centers of our people. Unfortunately, today they have degenerated into becoming centers of corruption and the hub of scandals.

        If the Armenian clergy is criticized today, it is because prospective priests have no calling, which is nothing other than the harmonious congregation of many abilities to lead the faithful to the glory of God.

        It has been historically evident that a priest who has a wavering character poses a danger to the Church and causes moral scandals among the faithful.

        A priest can earn respect and inspire trust among his faithful only by virtue of his good conduct and character. Unfortunately, the public is not inspired by the clergy today, because the priests have become robotic performers of church services with an eye for self-aggrandizement and enrichment.

        Being aware of the spiritual, psychological and social needs of our public, we ought to scrutinize candidates for the work of the Church very carefully in order to ensure that they have the required moral character and commitment to uphold their vows and remain true to their calling. Also, we must remain vigilant to keep away from those who come to serve with secret agendas and ill intentions.

        The Armenian Church today is at a very serious and critical juncture. The standards for religious teachings are loosened and our youth are increasingly distancing themselves from the Church. It is imperative that we start a new movement to awaken the public from its spiritual hibernation.

        Who will lead this movement today? I believe it is only the clergy–in its historical construct with selfless tenets of service to its flock–that can have the moral authority and legitimacy to reform the current state of corruption and degeneracy that has engulfed and permeated the entire hierarchy of the Church. It is only those who have the “true calling” and understand fully the implications of devotion to the faith and are rightfully ordained who can affect a meaningful reformation of the Armenian Apostolic Church. All others are mere sycophants and need not apply.

        (To be continued)
        Plenipotentiary meow!

        Comment


        • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

          Originally posted by bell-the-cat View Post
          [SIZE=4]
          For millennia, our monasteries would take pride in being the spiritual and intellectual centers of our people. Unfortunately, today they have degenerated into becoming centers of corruption and the hub of scandals.
          not today. The degeneration has been in progress for a long time

          criminals inside the Armenian church for a long time had the protection of the church hierarchy. Political parties and other Armenian organizations are usually there to defend them too! The problem runs deep

          In the ottoman empire Armenian church leaders' role models were Ottoman pashas and sultans

          Comment


          • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

            Originally posted by lampron View Post

            In the ottoman empire Armenian church leaders' role models were Ottoman pashas and sultans

            I tend to agree with you.

            Members of the church are part of, and therefore a sample of society of the time.

            A very good current example is the Anglican Church, where gay Priests and gay Bishops do not raise any eyebrows.

            Similarly to satisfy the feminist fundamentalists, decision of women priests is a reflection of the same phenomena.

            .
            Last edited by londontsi; 02-01-2014, 03:08 PM.
            Politics is not about the pursuit of morality nor what's right or wrong
            Its about self interest at personal and national level often at odds with the above.
            Great politicians pursue the National interest and small politicians personal interests

            Comment


            • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

              "Religious security issues"!


              Armenia's Security Council to fight migration, harmful sects in 2014
              Armenian News - Tert.am
              01.02.14


              Fight against migration and harmful religious sects will be on the
              National Security Council's agenda in 2014, according to its
              secretary.

              At a news conference on Saturday, Artur Baghdasaryan said those two
              problems are at the heart of their new demographic security strategy
              which he expects to receive a government approval this year.

              "Migration is widely discussed, so it is necessary to clearly outline
              the problem in order to prevent it," he said, adding that the document
              will address the emigration statistics in Armenia since the 1990's and
              propose future steps.

              Another important document will address religious security issues,
              Baghdasaryan added. "There are different concerns over different
              religious movements, so our objective is to respond to them. Knowing
              the international experience, it is necessary to develop an
              invulnerable document to have a clear vision," he explained.
              Plenipotentiary meow!

              Comment


              • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

                Originally posted by lampron View Post
                In the ottoman empire Armenian church leaders' role models were Ottoman pashas and sultans
                And today their role models are oligarch criminals?
                Plenipotentiary meow!

                Comment


                • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

                  Originally posted by bell-the-cat View Post
                  And today their role models are oligarch criminals?
                  Hey its the American way so it must be good.
                  Hayastan or Bust.

                  Comment


                  • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

                    Church Runs Businesses
                    Lragir.am, 03 May 2014


                    It’s been two days the social networks are discussing the unlawful “defrocking” of Priest Martiros Berberyan of the Armenian community of Moscow. The Armenian community of Moscow protested toughly. Ter Martiros held an interview which was followed by the response of the Information Service of the Mother See and the clarification of the press service of the Armenian Diocese of Russia and New Nakhidjevan. The latter referred to the priest’s “business” to justify their extreme approach, which is exaggerated, considering that it is the honest income of the priest’s family, which has never interfered with full performance of his service, the letter of a group of members of the Armenian community in Moscow runs.
                    This is obviously not the reason but an excuse because a lot of Armenian priests run different businesses, and as the ex-primate of the French Diocese Archbishop Norvan Zakaryan said, uncontrollable priests raised with a business psychology would not be punished. Moreover, they multiply their possessions and spend more. The society is well-aware of the offshore scandal of Archbishop Navasard Kchoyan of the Ararat Patriarchal Diocese nicknamed “Bentley” on which the Mother See did not even touch upon.
                    In their letter the representatives of the Armenian community in Moscow have published a list of clergymen who run businesses, and the church leadership treats it normally, ignoring the 21st apostolic rule which officials of the church should reject possessions and money:
                    Catholicos Garegin II, uncontrolled turnover of immense sums under the name of construction of churches and other buildings,
                    Archbishop Paren Avetikyan, antique business in his 5 star mansion in Yerevan, starting from Detroit,
                    Archbishop Abraham Mkrtchyan, owns a university in the diocese of Vayots Dzor, a camp,
                    Bishop Mkrtich Proshyan, has opened a bakery near St. Gevorg Church of Mughni,
                    Dean Komitas Hovnanyan, runs his own restaurant in Marseilles, France,
                    Priest Armen Melkonyan, runs his own restaurant in Antwerp, Belgium,
                    Priest Virap Ghazaryan, regularly travels between Aparan and Germany to follow up cars for sale,
                    Priest Vache Hairapetyan, apart from other “occupations”, has been involved in a false money deal in Nice, France,
                    Priest Mesrop Aramyan, implements educational programs on big money transfers from other countries.
                    Plenipotentiary meow!

                    Comment


                    • Re: Have our spiritual leaders lost their moral compass?

                      The tiltle actually says "Part VII", but I think that is a mistake and it should be "Part VI"

                      The Armenian Church is Held Hostage by Its Hierarchy: Part 6
                      By Vosgan Mekhitarian
                      January 4, 2014


                      We proceed in our endeavors to reform the Armenian Church with the understanding of its original mission to be the apotheosis of Jesus Christ and dissemination of His Word, and to uphold his teachings according to the Gospel, i.e., to shun all secular wealth and to comfort and heal the spiritual wounds of the faithful.

                      With this principle in mind, we call upon the high-ranking clergy of the Armenian Church, who are entrusted with the charge of guiding and leading their flock, "...to destroy the pride in your souls and approach your faithful with a humble heart".
                      We beseech you to sell your diamond rings and gilded crosses, your prized cars and extravagant accessories, and donate the proceeds of your ill-gotten gains to the poor and needy–that is, if you truly believe the teachings of the Bible. Heed your vows of poverty and let them lead you to the treasures of service, devotion, and compassion in your hearts.
                      We believe this vow of poverty is essential in the lives of the clergy–it enables them to remain truly spiritual and shields them from temptation.
                      It appears, modern civilization has transformed human beings into automatons, who are solely concerned with the trappings of convenience, entertainment, and safe harbor in opulence and display.
                      Similarly, the accumulation of wealth has also permeated our educational institutions, where preference is given not to the pursuit of spiritual enlightenment, but rather to the accumulation of personal riches and self-aggrandizement. Hence, the amassing of wealth has become the ultimate goal of people, young and old, supplanting all moral and religious objectives.
                      The clergy, who is also part of our society, has succumbed to its worldly temptations and, in the process of achieving these temporal goals, has become willing to renounce its vows and to eschew all moral values.

                      As a result of such unorthodox behavior, members of the clergy have become businessmen in every conceivable field–from dealing in diamond to real estate, from trading in the stock market to investment expertise, and bankrolling even in the most risqué ventures.
                      Today our prevailing concerns are not of dogmatic or even of theological nature for that matter, but rather organizational and administrative.
                      The clergy of the Armenian Church today is reminiscent of the clergy of the Catholic Church in the 17th century, which led to the reformation of the Church by Martin Luther. The very same conditions of materialism, corruption, and ignorance that pervaded the Catholic Church then and laid the groundwork for its eventual reformation, have infiltrated the current climate of the Armenian Church, where members of the clergy are ordained through nepotism and bribery. Their lives are so infested with the morass of corruption and influence peddling that their morals and commitment to righteous behavior have fallen by the wayside. It is high time for them to renew their vows and reestablish their nexus to God and His faithful.
                      Perhaps we need someone like St. Ignatius of Loyola (1491-1556), the founder of the Jesuit Brotherhood, to revitalize and revolutionize the Armenian Church and restore its once heralded glory as the bastion of Christianity. Better yet, we need individuals who can collectively eradicate corruption within the Church and reclaim the mantle of spirituality and Holiness.
                      The Armenian clergy of today regard their profession in strictly secular terms with an eye for personal gain. This mutation of the original calling to serve God and His faithful is a direct result of the commercial climate created by the self-serving actions of the most powerful in the hierarchy of the Armenian Church.
                      Potential candidates to the priesthood need to undergo a wholesale psychological transformation in order to garner the trust and faith of the public as their spiritual servants.
                      Lastly, in light of the strife and misery that has gripped many corners of the world, reducing human life to abject suffering, it is paramount that individuals entrusted with the mission to comfort and heal remain true to their charge and provide solace, understanding, and love to the faithful. Only then, can the Armenian Apostolic Church become, once again, the fulcrum around which people’s daily lives revolve and find meaningful purpose.


                      Vosgan Mekhitarian

                      to be continued
                      Plenipotentiary meow!

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X