Turk's Release May Clear Vatican Mystery
Turk's Release May Clear Vatican Mystery
By NICOLE WINFIELD, Associated Press WriterMon Jan 9, 7:31 PM ET
The release of the Turk who shot Pope John Paul II may shed light on a quarter-century-old mystery: the disappearance of the teenage daughter of a Vatican employee who was abducted by kidnappers claiming they were seeking to win the gunman's freedom.
Emanuela Orlandi's family has asked prosecutors to reopen the case because "new elements" have emerged that warrant investigation, the family's lawyer, Massimo Krogh, told The Associated Press on Monday.
He declined to speculate on whether the release of Mehmet Ali Agca, who turned 48 on Monday, from a Turkish prison would affect the case. But he cautioned that Agca has been a highly inconsistent witness over the years.
"He has said so many things. One cannot trust him," Krogh said.
Another investigator, however, said Agca's release can only help the investigation into Orlandi's disappearance, although prosecutors haven't decided whether to reopen the case.
Agca is to be freed on parole Thursday because he has completed his prison term for crimes committed in Turkey, a Turkish military court ruled last week.
An official, speaking on condition of anonymity Monday because he was not authorized to speak to the press, said Monday that Agca may still face trial in Turkey for allegedly dodging the draft and escaping military custody. The inmate's lawyer said that was unlikely, suggesting that Agca's time in prison would cover the time he would have served for those crimes as well.
The lawyer, Mustafa Demirbag, said Agca would likely be taken to a military station following his release and later to a military hospital in Istanbul for medical checks, a routine procedure.
"He has no plans for the future for now, but he is looking forward to his freedom," Demirbag told The Associated Press by telephone.
Agca was extradited to Turkey in 2000 after serving almost 20 years in prison in Italy for shooting and wounding the pope on May 13, 1981, in St. Peter's Square.
Orlandi, the daughter of a Vatican messenger, disappeared after a music lesson in Rome on June 22, 1983. She was 15 at the time. Her self-proclaimed kidnappers demanded Agca's release for her freedom, although they never offered any proof they had the girl or that she was alive.
Krogh said the Orlandi family believes that Emanuela's disappearance and the attempt on John Paul's life were connected and that the kidnappers wanted to exchange her for Agca. But asked whether Agca's release might also mean freedom for Orlandi, Krogh responded: "I frankly cannot say."
However, Judge Ferdinando Imposimato, who once headed the investigation into the attempt on John Paul's life, said Agca's freedom could only help the investigation.
Imposimato has maintained Agca was directed by Bulgarian agents and had been approached by a Soviet general in the KGB before the shooting. A Bulgarian-Soviet connection has long been suspected because of Soviet alarm over the pope's support for the Solidarity trade union in Poland.
But Italian investigators never found any hard evidence and John Paul himself ruled out any Bulgarian role during a 2002 trip to that country, declaring he had "never believed in the so-called Bulgarian connection because of my great esteem and respect for the people."
Imposimato told the Apcom news agency that Agca's freedom, and any possible new testimony, "could help resolve the mystery of the disappearance of Emanuela Orlandi."
He acknowledged in an interview with the ANSA news agency, however, that it was unlikely Italian investigators would ever get a chance to question Agca, "even if Agca promised to cooperate after his release."
Agca spoke about Orlandi during a 1985 prison interview with Italy's RAI state television, saying the girl was alive and not in danger. He denied any direct knowledge of her fate, though, saying he had made "some logical deductions."
He said then that he wished she would be freed "without any precondition."
The Vatican, meanwhile, has limited its reaction to Agca's pending release, stressing that it defers to the Turkish judicial system.
Papal spokesman Joaquin Navarro-Valls recalled on Vatican Radio Monday that John Paul had personally pardoned Agca while still hospitalized after the attempt on his life, saying "I pardon the brother who struck me." John Paul also forgave Agca during a 1983 prison visit.
But Navarro-Valls stressed the Vatican never interfered in either the Italian or Turkish court processes or Italy's decision to pardon him and extradite him to Turkey.
___
Associated Press writer Selcan Hacaoglu in Ankara, Turkey, contributed to this story.
Turk's Release May Clear Vatican Mystery
By NICOLE WINFIELD, Associated Press WriterMon Jan 9, 7:31 PM ET
The release of the Turk who shot Pope John Paul II may shed light on a quarter-century-old mystery: the disappearance of the teenage daughter of a Vatican employee who was abducted by kidnappers claiming they were seeking to win the gunman's freedom.
Emanuela Orlandi's family has asked prosecutors to reopen the case because "new elements" have emerged that warrant investigation, the family's lawyer, Massimo Krogh, told The Associated Press on Monday.
He declined to speculate on whether the release of Mehmet Ali Agca, who turned 48 on Monday, from a Turkish prison would affect the case. But he cautioned that Agca has been a highly inconsistent witness over the years.
"He has said so many things. One cannot trust him," Krogh said.
Another investigator, however, said Agca's release can only help the investigation into Orlandi's disappearance, although prosecutors haven't decided whether to reopen the case.
Agca is to be freed on parole Thursday because he has completed his prison term for crimes committed in Turkey, a Turkish military court ruled last week.
An official, speaking on condition of anonymity Monday because he was not authorized to speak to the press, said Monday that Agca may still face trial in Turkey for allegedly dodging the draft and escaping military custody. The inmate's lawyer said that was unlikely, suggesting that Agca's time in prison would cover the time he would have served for those crimes as well.
The lawyer, Mustafa Demirbag, said Agca would likely be taken to a military station following his release and later to a military hospital in Istanbul for medical checks, a routine procedure.
"He has no plans for the future for now, but he is looking forward to his freedom," Demirbag told The Associated Press by telephone.
Agca was extradited to Turkey in 2000 after serving almost 20 years in prison in Italy for shooting and wounding the pope on May 13, 1981, in St. Peter's Square.
Orlandi, the daughter of a Vatican messenger, disappeared after a music lesson in Rome on June 22, 1983. She was 15 at the time. Her self-proclaimed kidnappers demanded Agca's release for her freedom, although they never offered any proof they had the girl or that she was alive.
Krogh said the Orlandi family believes that Emanuela's disappearance and the attempt on John Paul's life were connected and that the kidnappers wanted to exchange her for Agca. But asked whether Agca's release might also mean freedom for Orlandi, Krogh responded: "I frankly cannot say."
However, Judge Ferdinando Imposimato, who once headed the investigation into the attempt on John Paul's life, said Agca's freedom could only help the investigation.
Imposimato has maintained Agca was directed by Bulgarian agents and had been approached by a Soviet general in the KGB before the shooting. A Bulgarian-Soviet connection has long been suspected because of Soviet alarm over the pope's support for the Solidarity trade union in Poland.
But Italian investigators never found any hard evidence and John Paul himself ruled out any Bulgarian role during a 2002 trip to that country, declaring he had "never believed in the so-called Bulgarian connection because of my great esteem and respect for the people."
Imposimato told the Apcom news agency that Agca's freedom, and any possible new testimony, "could help resolve the mystery of the disappearance of Emanuela Orlandi."
He acknowledged in an interview with the ANSA news agency, however, that it was unlikely Italian investigators would ever get a chance to question Agca, "even if Agca promised to cooperate after his release."
Agca spoke about Orlandi during a 1985 prison interview with Italy's RAI state television, saying the girl was alive and not in danger. He denied any direct knowledge of her fate, though, saying he had made "some logical deductions."
He said then that he wished she would be freed "without any precondition."
The Vatican, meanwhile, has limited its reaction to Agca's pending release, stressing that it defers to the Turkish judicial system.
Papal spokesman Joaquin Navarro-Valls recalled on Vatican Radio Monday that John Paul had personally pardoned Agca while still hospitalized after the attempt on his life, saying "I pardon the brother who struck me." John Paul also forgave Agca during a 1983 prison visit.
But Navarro-Valls stressed the Vatican never interfered in either the Italian or Turkish court processes or Italy's decision to pardon him and extradite him to Turkey.
___
Associated Press writer Selcan Hacaoglu in Ankara, Turkey, contributed to this story.
Comment