I Really Want To Know These Questions...

[fincancay]

I have four questions about this Genocide(!) I hope you respond me...

First question:

Turkish Government is telling that they could open their archives and records about The Armenian Genocide(!) but Armenian Government did not accept it. I want to know why did Armenian Government reject it(!) we could only see the truth in archives and records because they are the only proof that could show real. Does it mean that ' Armenian People do not care about truth' (!)

Second question is about photos of dead people. I am seeing a lot of pictures of dead people but how could I know it those pictures belong to dead Armenian people(!) . They might be dead Turkish people who Armenian People had killed(!) How could it be proven? Might it be Turkish Genocide instead of Armenian Genocide(!)

Third question is a mental question. Why did Turkish people want to kill Armenian people who lived with Turks about hundreds of years in Ottoman(!) Might Armenian people kill Turkish people behind them in the First World War to find a new government of Armenia?

Last question is about Peace(!) Do you think that Turkish and Armenian people could make Peace(!) between them? They both lived together lots of years did not they?

I hope(!) you will respond all of my questions...

[Joseph]

I have four questions about this Genocide(!) I hope you respond me...

First question:

Turkish Government is telling that they could open their archives and records about The Armenian Genocide(!) but Armenian Government did not accept it. I want to know why did Armenian Government reject it(!) we could only see the truth in archives and records because they are the only proof that could show real. Does it mean that ' Armenian People do not care about truth' (!)

Second question is about photos of dead people. I am seeing a lot of pictures of dead people but how could I know it those pictures belong to dead Armenian people(!) . They might be dead Turkish people who Armenian People had killed(!) How could it be proven? Might it be Turkish Genocide instead of Armenian Genocide(!)

Third question is a mental question. Why did Turkish people want to kill Armenian people who lived with Turks about hundreds of years in Ottoman(!) Might Armenian people kill Turkish people behind them in the First World War to find a new government of Armenia?

Last question is about Peace(!) Do you think that Turkish and Armenian people could make Peace(!) between them? They both lived together lots of years did not they?

I hope(!) you will respond all of my questions...

Please read the following:

http://www.armeniangenocide.com/showthread.php?t=2873

http://www.armeniangenocide.com/showthread.php?t=631

[1.5 million]

I have four questions about this Genocide(!) I hope you respond me...

First question:

Turkish Government is telling that they could open their archives and records about The Armenian Genocide(!) but Armenian Government did not accept it. I want to know why did Armenian Government reject it(!) we could only see the truth in archives and records because they are the only proof that could show real. Does it mean that ' Armenian People do not care about truth' (!)

Re herring argument - there was no Armenian State in 1915 - thus there are no "archives" for this period - and certainly nothing relating to anyting directly to do with the genocide of Armenians by Ottoman Turks. As for the (various) Turkish archives - well who can believe that a state that has so vigorously denied any culpability (by Turks) for the atrocities commited against Armenians - who could believe that they would not doctor the archives to attempt to eliminate any eveidence to the contrary - and there is in fact documention of this beginning even with the CUP who were noted to be destroying vast numbers of such documents. So "archives" are not necessarily the repositor of ultimate truth in all cases. And if one wishes to peruse relevent archival records of these times I would suggest starting first with the German archives, then the American, Russian and Austrian archives...then we can talk.

Second question is about photos of dead people. I am seeing a lot of pictures of dead people but how could I know it those pictures belong to dead Armenian people(!) . They might be dead Turkish people who Armenian People had killed(!) How could it be proven? Might it be Turkish Genocide instead of Armenian Genocide(!)

Yes - perhaps those are just dead Germans - killed by Jews in the concentration camps. ...Very few pictures really exist of the Armenian Genocide - considering the vast nature and extreme horrors of the crimes commited. The reason is the severe Ottoman censorship (under threat of death) that exsisted at the time in regard to any pictures being take and taken away. However there is more then sufficient documention of the sources of the pictures which are available to not entertain such absurd notions as you are putting forth. To begin try googling Armin Wegner - and at least make an attempt to learn something of the truth.

Third question is a mental question. Why did Turkish people want to kill Armenian people who lived with Turks about hundreds of years in Ottoman(!) Might Armenian people kill Turkish people behind them in the First World War to find a new government of Armenia?

Why did Germans start killing Jews in WWII - when Jews had experienced nearly the best treatment in all of Europe while in Germany prior? Might the Jews have been behind German defeats in WWI? Might they have been undermining the Wiemer Republic - in league with Communists...etc etc? So Nazi sympathyzers and propoganda would have you believe. Your absurd Turkish notion of the history of the Armenian Genocide suffers from the same completely absurd and unsupportable notions. You have internalized your own state's racist propoganda and are attempting to foster it off on us who just happen to know a bit better. Please come back to us when you have graduated grade school and learned a bit of real history.

Last question is about Peace(!) Do you think that Turkish and Armenian people could make Peace(!) between them? They both lived together lots of years did not they?

Yes - I suggest following the example of Germans and Jews...ie the ball is in your court asehole.

I hope(!) you will respond all of my questions...

done

[phantom]

If the Turks love Hrant Dink and Turkish Armenians so much, then why did you kill him, especially if, as you say, he denied that there was a Genocide?

[phantom]

Fincancay,

Anatolia was once the heartland of the Armenian people. About 2 million of them had been living there since at least as early as 600 B.C. Between 1915 and 1918 those people were erased from Anatolia. Do you think it is possible to erase 2,000,000 people from their home of almost 3000 years in a matter of only 3 year without a plan? Do you think it was all an accident? Do you think the Armenians (the loyal Millet as you pointed out) all decided to take a vacation one day and never came back? Please be logical. Try to use your brain.

[imported_crusader1492]

Regardless of Hrant's stance on the Genocide, he was targeted and murdered simply for the fact that he was Armenian.

[phantom]

And BTW, his stance was that it was a Genocide. He just didn't think that the diaspora was handling it the right way by getting foreign governments to acknowledge it or criminalize its denial, as in France and Switzerland.