Announcement

Collapse

Forum Rules (Everyone Must Read!!!)

1] What you CAN NOT post.

You agree, through your use of this service, that you will not use this forum to post any material which is:
- abusive
- vulgar
- hateful
- harassing
- personal attacks
- obscene

You also may not:
- post images that are too large (max is 500*500px)
- post any copyrighted material unless the copyright is owned by you or cited properly.
- post in UPPER CASE, which is considered yelling
- post messages which insult the Armenians, Armenian culture, traditions, etc
- post racist or other intentionally insensitive material that insults or attacks another culture (including Turks)

The Ankap thread is excluded from the strict rules because that place is more relaxed and you can vent and engage in light insults and humor. Notice it's not a blank ticket, but just a place to vent. If you go into the Ankap thread, you enter at your own risk of being clowned on.
What you PROBABLY SHOULD NOT post...
Do not post information that you will regret putting out in public. This site comes up on Google, is cached, and all of that, so be aware of that as you post. Do not ask the staff to go through and delete things that you regret making available on the web for all to see because we will not do it. Think before you post!


2] Use descriptive subject lines & research your post. This means use the SEARCH.

This reduces the chances of double-posting and it also makes it easier for people to see what they do/don't want to read. Using the search function will identify existing threads on the topic so we do not have multiple threads on the same topic.

3] Keep the focus.

Each forum has a focus on a certain topic. Questions outside the scope of a certain forum will either be moved to the appropriate forum, closed, or simply be deleted. Please post your topic in the most appropriate forum. Users that keep doing this will be warned, then banned.

4] Behave as you would in a public location.

This forum is no different than a public place. Behave yourself and act like a decent human being (i.e. be respectful). If you're unable to do so, you're not welcome here and will be made to leave.

5] Respect the authority of moderators/admins.

Public discussions of moderator/admin actions are not allowed on the forum. It is also prohibited to protest moderator actions in titles, avatars, and signatures. If you don't like something that a moderator did, PM or email the moderator and try your best to resolve the problem or difference in private.

6] Promotion of sites or products is not permitted.

Advertisements are not allowed in this venue. No blatant advertising or solicitations of or for business is prohibited.
This includes, but not limited to, personal resumes and links to products or
services with which the poster is affiliated, whether or not a fee is charged
for the product or service. Spamming, in which a user posts the same message repeatedly, is also prohibited.

7] We retain the right to remove any posts and/or Members for any reason, without prior notice.


- PLEASE READ -

Members are welcome to read posts and though we encourage your active participation in the forum, it is not required. If you do participate by posting, however, we expect that on the whole you contribute something to the forum. This means that the bulk of your posts should not be in "fun" threads (e.g. Ankap, Keep & Kill, This or That, etc.). Further, while occasionally it is appropriate to simply voice your agreement or approval, not all of your posts should be of this variety: "LOL Member213!" "I agree."
If it is evident that a member is simply posting for the sake of posting, they will be removed.


8] These Rules & Guidelines may be amended at any time. (last update September 17, 2009)

If you believe an individual is repeatedly breaking the rules, please report to admin/moderator.
See more
See less

New danish documents one the Armenian Genocide

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • New danish documents one the Armenian Genocide

    "All truth passes through three stages:
    First, it is ridiculed;
    Second, it is violently opposed; and
    Third, it is accepted as self-evident."

    Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860)

  • #2
    DOCUMENT 1

    1915-07-03-DK-001

    The minister in Constantinople (Carl Ellis Wandel) to the foreign
    minister (Erik Scavenius)

    Source : Danish National Archives, Foreign Office, Group Cases
    1909-1945. Dept. 139, Gr. D, No. 1, "Turkey - Inner Relations".

    Package 1, to Dec. 31, 1916

    No. LXX [70]

    Constantinople, July 3, 1915.

    Confidential.

    Mr. Foreign Minister,

    In my earlier reports I have already several times had the opportunity
    to mention the hatred that the Young Turk government has been showing
    with less and less ambiguity against the aliens in Turkey since
    the beginning of the war and the abrogation of the capitulations,
    and particularly against the Christians.

    In spite of the repeated promises that the Grand Vizier has given
    to the Apostolic delegate [Monseigneur Angelo Marie Dolci] and to
    the mission chiefs, many of the monasteries and other religious
    institutions that have been seized have not yet been reopened, and
    they are still being treated with the utmost arbitrariness, often
    under the pretext of military necessity.

    The Catholic church in Bebek by the Bosporus has even been placed
    at the disposal of the local Muslims, who have converted it into
    a mosque ; and property belonging to the Holy See in Kadikeui,
    near Constantinople, has been taken over in order to establish a
    Muslim school.

    All of these violations, though, amount to nothing compared to a
    very vital step, that I have learned today has been taken by the
    government to remove the protected status which the Catholics have
    enjoyed in Turkey from old times.

    The government has established a non-clerical council, made up of 12
    Catholic Ottoman subjects - naturally chosen among followers of the
    government - who must choose a chairman among themselves.

    This council is supposed to administer the Catholic church in Turkey
    (i.e., the Latin, not the Greek, Armenian, etc.), and will thus become
    some sort of a new Patriarchate.

    This way, the representative of the Papal delegate and of the
    countries that have Catholic interests in Turkey will be robbed of any
    opportunity of attending to such interests and that all monasteries and
    churches, and everything that the Catholic church owns in this country,
    will be administrated by this new council and seized by the Caliphate.

    Not surprisingly, the Papal delegate has refused to receive the 12
    newly appointed gentlemen in corpore.

    In Catholic circles, there had been hope that under these circumstances
    the German ambassador, who represents so many millions of Catholics,
    and the representative of the "Apostolic king" [i.e., the Austrian
    ambassador Johann Pallavicini] would have a moderating influence on
    the Young Turk government, but this seems not to be the case.

    The German ambassador says that it must be due to a misunderstanding
    if one thinks that Germany or any other power has any influence
    here, because the Turkish government disregards the daily efforts
    he makes to direct its attention to the many unwise acts by which it
    makes itself still more hated, and the Austrian-Hungarian ambassador
    expresses himself in a similar way, in that he, among other things,
    complains about the arrogant way the Turks try to give the impression
    that the advancement of the Austrian armed forces first and foremost
    is caused by the Turkish victories against the allied forces at the
    Dardanelles and elsewhere.

    With the highest esteem I remain, Mr. Minister, yours faithfully

    [Wandel]

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    DOCUMENT 2

    1915-09-04-DK-001

    The minister in Constantinople (Carl Ellis Wandel) to the foreign
    minister (Erik Scavenius)

    Source : Danish National Archives, Foreign Office, Group Cases
    1909-1945. Dept. 139, Gr. D, No. 1, "Turkey - Inner Relations".

    Package 1, to Dec. 31, 1916

    No. CXIII [113]

    Constantinople, September 4, 1915.

    Confidential.

    Mr. Foreign Minister,

    In continuation of my most respectful reports No. LXXVIII [78] of
    July 22, No. LXXXVII [87] of July 31, and No. IC [99] of August 18,
    I have the honor of reporting that the persecutions of the Armenians
    are continuing with great intensity, in spite of the promises made
    by the government here, and of which I have already reported.

    At the reception Monday the 16th of August, the German ambassador
    once again brought up these persecutions with the Grand Vizier,
    and asked him to induce his government to cease, - especially when
    it comes to the Armenian Catholics who have never participated in
    revolutions or interfered with politics and still are subjected to
    the most persistent persecutions.

    Even the Gregorian Armenians, who have distanced themselves from
    all nationalist ideas to the extent that they have abandoned their
    mother tongue and have embraced the Turkish language as their own,
    are being persecuted.

    The promises which the Grand Vizier gave to the German ambassador
    were not kept, and when the persecutions and killings continued, His
    Holiness Monseigneur Paul Pierre XIII, the Armenian-Catholic Patriarch,
    turned to the resident Spanish minister and asked him, in the name of
    Catholic Spain, to try to turn once more to the Grand Vizier to obtain
    that at least the safety of the Catholic Armenians were respected.

    The Spanish minister, who consented and, using the words of the
    Patriarch, objected to the Grand Vizier at the reception last Monday,
    tells me that His Highness, after having listened to him, showed his
    surprise about what had happened, and that he, when the minister
    firmly claimed that he had proof that the cruelties mentioned had
    actually taken place, noted it and promised to immediately order that
    the Armenian Catholics were spared.

    However, both the minister and the Patriarch are convinced that these
    terrible persecutions will not cease, among other things because the
    central government has no power over the provincial authorities,
    who, when it suits them, do not obey the orders they receive from
    Constantinople, and - last not least - because the Germans in their
    opinion only pretend to protest against the persecutions and killings.

    It is obvious, they say, that the Germans are interested in the
    extermination of the Armenians and in the Greeks fleeing, who fear
    that the same thing should happen to them, so that they (the Germans)
    without effort can take over Turkey`s trade and become the only
    Europeans with a foothold here.

    The authorities in the provinces and the Young Turks, they say, do
    not consider the German ambassadors' application to the government
    as serious.

    I shall briefly allow myself to give an account of the important and
    sad communications of the latest developments, that has been given
    to me by completely reliable and truthful source, and which is of
    such a nature that it will cause general regret everywhere in the
    Christian world.

    The Turks are vigorously carrying through their cruel intention,
    to exterminate the Armenian people.

    In Brussa they have forced the well-to-do Armenians to pay the police
    300 Turkish pounds (approximately 5000 Danish kroner) a person to be
    allowed to stay in the city, and yet the next day they have banished
    them from the city with their wifes and children.

    Where these unfortunate people are now, and what fate they have met
    after they have had to leave their homes, it is not possible to learn
    even for the closest family.

    In Adana the governor has ordered the posting of a proclamation which,
    in a French translation I have received from the Patriarchate, goes
    as follows :

    "1) Jusqu`a la fin du mois courant les armeniens se trouvant dans la
    ville meme d`Adana doivent avoir ete expedies au fur et a mesure et par
    groupes. 2) Les proprietaires des fabriques sises a Mersina et a Adana,
    ainsi que les employes de celles-ci qui travaillent pour le compte
    du Departement Militaire, son exemptes pour le moment : ils ne seront
    pas expedies et seront employes comme auparavant dans leur travaux.

    3) Les familles dont les soutiens ou les maris sont en service
    militaire ne seront pas expedies.

    4) Tout le monde doit, a partir d`aujourd`hui, regler et mettre en
    ordre ses affaires et se tenir pret a l`ordre de monter en chemin
    de fer.

    5) Il ne sera fait aucun cas de recours, qui seront faits faits pour
    une demande de prolongation de delai ou d`autres empechements. 6)
    L`expedition se fera quartier par quartier. 7) Il ne sera permis
    pour chaque famille que le transport d`une quantite de meubles de
    150 kilos seulement.

    8) Pour les familles composees de plus 6 personnes, grandes ou petites,
    il sera permis le transport de 200 kilos de meubles.

    9) La population musulmans de la ville et de la banlieue est obligee
    de fournir, pour cette expedition, les moyens de transport.

    10) La commission nommee pour s`occuper des moyens de transport,
    a commence deja ses travaux.

    11) Les familles qui se seraient procure elles-meme leur moyens
    de transport, sont autorisees, en vertu des pièces qui leur seront
    delivrees par les Commissaires de Police, a se rendre directement a
    Badjou et de la a Alep.

    12) Par le train qui sera prepare le samedi 15 du mois courant,
    seront expedies les quartiers de Akdje, Nesjid, Saradjen, Kharab,
    Bagtche, Tchoukour, Kassab Bekir, Yarbachi, Tcinanli et Karan.

    13) A partir de demain la population de ces quartiers devra absolument
    s`adresser a la Commission d`inscription placee sous la presidence de
    Adil Bey dans le Commissariat de Police et après s`etre fait inscrire,
    devra prendre une pièce scellee et legalisee.

    14) Ceux qui d`après l`inscription de leur etat civil, sinon du nombre
    des habitants de ces quartiers et qui actuellement resident ailleurs,
    leurs domiciles actuels ne seront pas pris en consideration, mais
    ils seront obligee d`aller se faire inscrire avec les habitants des
    quartiers auxquels ils appartiennent, et de partir, dans la meme
    journee, avec les habitants de leur quartier d`origine.

    15) Pour l`expedition soit des familles de militaires, soit des
    personnes qui se trouveraient habitant dans d`autres quartiers, il
    sera tenu compte, pour principe d`operation, de l`enregistrement de
    leur etat civil.

    16) Toutes les operations qui ne seront pas faites par inscription,
    ne seront pas prises en consideration.

    17) La population de ses quartiers devra, au matin du jour designe
    ci-haut a 12 heures a la turque, avec ses bagages, tel qu`il est
    dit a l`Art. 7 et avec les membres de la famille, se trouver a
    la Nouvelle Station. 18) On doit se rendre a Alep par la voie de
    Osmanieh-Radjou. 19) Une Commission speciale etant envoyee a Osmanieh,
    sur la presentation des pièces, conformement a l`Art. 13, distribuera
    a chaque famille, dans la mesure possible, des moyens de transport
    et organisera les expeditions par groupes.

    20) A l`arrivee a Osmanieh la susdite Commission fera diligence pour
    l`installation et le bien-etre des groupes : par consequent chaque
    quartier devra faire par l`intermediarie de leur Mouhtar respectif,
    recours a la susdite Commission.

    21) La quantite des personnes employees dont le sejour a ete decide,
    avant etre notifie aux bureaux de la Police et de la Gendarmerie,
    il sera procede, par les dits bureaux, a la separation et au maintien
    de ceux-ci.

    22) La sera delivre par la direction de la police, aux personnes
    ainsi exemptees, des documents reguliers et legalises, concernant
    leur maintien.

    23) Si parmi la population des quartiers qui ont ete avisees, il se
    trouvait des personnes, qui, a partir de demain, ne se presenteraient
    pas et ne se feraient inscrire, ou qui ne se trouveraient pas
    presentes a la Nouvelle Station au jour indique pour le depart soit
    le samedi 15 du mois courant a l`heure indique ou qui chercheraient a
    trouver des ruses ou des pretextes, les Mouhtars et les Conseils des
    vieillards sont obliges de prevenir les Autorites et si les habitants
    et le Mouhtar auraient contrevenu a tout cela, ils seront consideres
    comme ayant agi contre l`Autorite Militaire et les ordres de l`etat
    de mobilisation et seront immediatement deferes a la Cour Martiale
    et dans les 24 heures une sentence sera donnee et executee.

    24) Les ordres formelles, comme il convent, ayant ete donnes a tous les
    bureaux. Il est preferable de travailler a completer ces preparatifs
    plutôt que de perdre du temps a chercher des pretextes et a faire
    des demarches inutiles. Août 1915.

    In a letter received here from the bishop of Erzerum, Monseigneur
    Melchisedechian, it is stated that the parish of Khodirtchour, which
    was made up of 12 villages, has been completely evacuated, and that
    no one knows what has happened to the vanished population.

    That same prelate, on July 17 this year, reported that he himself
    had been forced to set out for an unknown destination, and nothing
    has been heard of him since.

    The former bishop of that same district, Monseigneur Ketchourian,
    at the same time travelled to Constantinople, but disappeared along
    the way.

    The bishop of Karput, Monseigneur Israëlian, on June 23 reported to
    the Patriarchate that he had been ordered to leave the town for Aleppo
    with all of his parishioners within 48 hours, and it has later been
    learned that this bishop and all the clergy that accompanied him have
    been attacked and killed between Diarbekir and Urfa at a place where
    approximately 1700 Armenian families have suffered the same fate.

    The whole of the population in the abovementioned parish are considered
    lost.

    The population in the parishes of Diarbekir and Malatia has also been
    driven out of their villages, and it is not known what has happened
    to the bishops Tchelebian and Khatchadourian and their parishioners.

    The sad message has also been confirmed that the archbishop of Mardin,
    Monseigneur Maloyan, and approx. 700 of his Catholic parishioners
    have been killed, and that the population in the town of Tallermen,
    which was purely Catholic, has been completely exterminated.

    Reports are completely lacking on what has happened to the bishop
    of Mouch, Monseigneur Topuzian, and his parishioners, but there is
    reason to believe that they too have been killed.

    It is feared that a similar fate has befallen the clergy and
    parishioners of Gurin.

    In the parish of Sivas, the only village to have been spared is
    Pirkinik, where the archbishop, Monseigneur Ketchedjian, has escaped
    to. He, and one cleric that accompanied him, are the only survivors.

    Trebizond, Samson, [illegible], Marsivan, and Amassia have been
    completely evacuated, and there is no knowledge of what has happened
    to the 47 clerics of these towns.

    Tarsus, Hedzin, and Mersina have suffered the same fate.

    In Angora, all of the men have been abducted from the town, and the
    women have been forced to marry Muslims ; approximately 6000 men,
    approximately 70 clerics, and the bishop, Monseigneur Gregoire Bahaban,
    have been shot on the road to the place of banishment.

    In the city of Ismid, the government has ordered that the Armenian
    Catholics who had been banished to Eskicheir should be allowed to
    return to their homes, but the governor would not let them enter
    the city, and sent them back. The same thing has happened in many
    other places.

    Even here in Constantinople Armenians are being abducted and sent to
    Asia, and it is not possible to get information of their whereabouts.

    The Patriarchate has calculated that half of the Armenian-Catholic
    hierarchy has been lost ; 7 bishops, approximately 100 priests, 70
    other clerics, and thousands upon thousands of their parishioners
    have disappeared.

    The Church formerly consisted of 16 districts (Constantinople, Mardin,
    Diarbekir, Karput, Malatia, Sivas-Tokat, Mouch, Erzerum, Trebisond,
    Angora, Cesaree, Brussa, Adana, Marache, Aleppo, and Alexandrie [=
    Alexandrette]), and according to the latest information only Marash,
    Aleppo, and Cesaree have been spared outside of Constantinople.

    The fate that thus has befallen the Catholic Armenians, have with
    even greater cruelty befallen all the other Armenians, in that the
    aim of the government, as I have already had the honor to report,
    is to completely exterminate the Armenian people.

    With the highest esteem I remain, Mr. Minister, yours faithfully

    [Wandel]
    General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

    Comment


    • #3
      DOCUMENT 3 1915-09-22-DK-001

      The minister in Constantinople (Carl Ellis Wandel) to the foreign
      minister (Erik Scavenius)

      Source : Danish National Archives, Foreign Office,Group Cases
      1909-1945. Dept. 139, Gr. D, No. 1, "Turkey - Inner Relations".

      Package 1, to Dec. 31, 1916

      No. CXXV [125]

      Constantinople, September 22, 1915.

      Mr. Foreign Minister,

      In my earlier reports I have already tried to demonstrate how H. M.

      the Sultan rules, and how the Committee is managing.

      I have tried to demonstrate that Turkey has been incautious in giving
      up its neutrality, given that the country`s position will be very
      difficult if the war ends with a victory of one of the groups of
      Great Powers.

      Regarding the fate of the country if the Entente powers win, Mr.

      Foreign Minister is far better informed than I ; the matters that I
      have the opportunity to observe will only have a minor influence in
      the event of such an outcome, and I therefore prefer to deal with
      the question of what will happen in the event of a victory for the
      Central Powers.

      If the Central Powers are victorious, and the Balkan coalition is
      not being reformed against the "German danger," Turkey will in all
      probability be faced with the choice of either giving up the major
      parts of its political and economic independence to the benefit of
      Germany, who will then gain firm ground here, or to enter into a
      probably rather hopeless struggle for independence against its mighty
      ally, and when this choice is to be made, the matters that I observe
      daily could be decisive.

      There is already full awareness in the German embassy here, that a
      serious conflict between Germany and Turkey, who in a future union
      undoubtedly will demand an equal status, hardly will be avoidable,
      even at best, if the chauvinists remain in power. Some remarks made
      to me recently by the embassy`s advisory specialist in Balkan policy
      is certainly indicative thereof.

      When I, after having expressed my admiration for the great and
      outstanding achievements of the German diplomatic and military missions
      to the benefit of Germany`s interests, added that I still found it
      hard to forgive German Balkan policy that it, by strengthening and
      flattering the Committee, has helped bring about its arrogance and
      xenophobia to such an extent that the government here has become
      thoroughly intractable, he answered that, from the German position,
      this was readily regretted.

      "But you must not forget," he said, "that we had no other option ;
      we needed Turkey`s help - it was for us a matter of life and death,
      and we had to let things slide."

      By and large, there can therefore hardly be much doubt about where
      it goes from here ; since the foreign warships (station ships) left
      the roadstead of Constantinople, the presumptuousness of the Young
      Turks has been ever increasing, and there can probably be no talk of
      moderation in thought and principles before the ships return.

      A thorough study of the prospects in the event of a victory for the
      Central Powers, though, faces many difficulties, since it is almost
      impossible to obtain reliable information about the composition and
      practical circumstances of the true, but irresponsible, government
      of the country - the Committee. The history of the Committe has not
      yet been written, and the persons who know it dare not speak out.

      Considering the topicality of the subject, I will still try to give,
      based on what I learn here, a short description of the Committee
      and its men - who make up a kind of directorate, consisting of 15-20
      members, that decides the actions of the government - and of the change
      in its policy since July 1908, when it intervened for the first time
      in the fate of the country with a firm grip and, measured with the
      standards of this country, [became] a uniquely thorough organization.

      The distinctive feature of the Young Turk Committee has always been,
      and still is, its organizational strength. Without this firmness,
      the Committee would not have been able to withstand being persecuted
      by despotism, and to even grow in strength to such an extent that
      it could topple the old regime. This organizational firmness, which
      the Committee created in its earliest days when it toiled with its
      great work of liberation, it has kept since that time, for better
      or for worse, and when in power it has, aided by that firmness,
      been able to get away with unpunished abuses similar to that of
      the toppled despotism, [and,] aided by it, it could regain power by
      determined action when it had been dethroned. And the Committee is
      not only equipped with this organizational strength, it also is and
      has always been the only Turkish political organization in possession
      of this quality ; all the other parties, that have been formed since
      the introduction of the constitution, have lacked it - and they have
      quickly succumbed.

      An effect of this state of things is that the top positions of the
      Committee are no longer held by the theorists who originally drew
      up the program of the Committee, but by its political-organizational
      leaders, those men who have worked in the service of the organization
      from the beginning, not as great idealists or founding statesmen,
      but as organizers who use all means to further the well-being of their
      organization. This fact also explains that the Committee now, albeit
      under much the same leaders as in its earliest years of struggle,
      actually fights for a completely different program than then it had -
      it is not the ideals, but power that has been and is being fought for.

      Among the men in the leadership of the Committee, one first of all
      has to mention the present leader of the government, interior minister
      Talaat Bey, without doubt a significant politician.

      Talaat Bey, former telegraphist in the provinces, was working for
      the Committee from its earliest days, and he came to the forefront
      immediately after the revolution as one of the leaders of Turkish
      politics, but only after 1909 did he and other Young Turk leaders
      become direct members of the government - Talaat Bey as interior
      minister - to replace the old Pashas, who still for some time had
      been allowed to remain in office as puppets. It was Talaat Bey who,
      when the Committee had been toppled by "the liberating officers"
      (in the Spring of 1912), led the secret effort of the Committee
      to regain power, and he who, together with his friends, in effect,
      by nationalistic demonstrations, forced Kiamil [Kamil] Pasha, the
      then Grand Vizier, to engage in the unfortunate war against the
      Balkan states (the end of 1912), instead of accepting to effectively
      implement the reforms demanded by the Powers. And once again, it was
      Talaat Bey who, together with Enver Pasha, was the leader behind the
      new coup d`etat, that once again brought the Young Turks to power -
      in accordance with Talaat`s plan at the exact moment when the Kiamil
      cabinet sent the note to the Great Powers, where it gave up Adrianople
      as a result of the urgent requests of those Powers. Kiamil Pasha`s
      abandonment of the holy Adrianople would have put the men of the coup
      d`etat in a more flattering light as national liberators who toppled
      the cabinet that had unnecessarily surrendered parts of the country,
      but, as chance would have it, the toppled cabinet had not delivered
      the note of reply to the Powers (it had been sent, but because of an
      editorial error it was called back before the delivery to the Austrian
      ambassador), and it was the new Young Turk ministry that was left with
      responsibility for the decision. It was luck - the internal struggle
      of the Balkan states - and not foresight that saved Talaat and the
      Committee`s power and regained Adrianople for Turkey.

      Since then, Talaat has more and more become the centre of the Young
      Turk Committee. The military members - and especially Enver Pasha
      - have had to focus on the defence of the country, and the entire
      government has slipped into the hands of Talaat Bey, who actually is
      both minister of the interior, of finance, and of foreign affairs.

      Close to Talaat is his friend Halil Bey, chairman of the deputy chamber
      and of the Committee, Bedri Bey, prefect of the security police in
      Turkey (in the Spring of 191[ ?] he had been condemned to death for
      having shot a military police officer, had later escaped from prison,
      been pardoned, and made chief of public security), Nazim Bey, the
      Committee`s chauvinist secretary general and leader of the daily
      administration of the Committee, Midhat Chukri Bey and Behaeddine
      Chakir Bey, also pronounced chauvinists, Hussein Djahid Bey, former
      editor of the Committee`s organ "Tanin," and Djavid Bey, the former
      finance minister, who took care of the great loan in France in 1914,
      from a Jewish family that converted to Islam, originally school
      inspector in the provinces, etc., etc.

      A person completely preoccupied at the moment by the military events
      is Enver Pasha, the officer who, together with Niazi Bey who was
      killed shortly after, in June 1908 raised the rebel banner with his
      troops in Albania, and thereby originated the revolution itself,
      after which he became military attache in Berlin, a nomination that
      surely has had a great impact on the relationship between Germany and
      Turkey. After having returned to Turkey he became chief of staff for
      the 10th Army Corps, was an active participant in the coup d`etat in
      1913, and led the triumphant expedition to Adrianople. As a reward
      he was, albeit relatively late, made minister of war in January 1914,
      and thereby gained all of Turkey`s military power in his hand, after
      the Committee had fired all the old generals and high ranking officers,
      who enjoyed popularity with the troops, and replaced them with Enver
      Pasha`s new proteges.

      Another influential military member of the Committee was until lately
      Enver Pasha`s co-suitor to the military leadership, Djemal Pasha, the
      former military commander of Constantinople, named Pasha the same day
      as Enver, decorated with the Osmanieh Order at the same time as Enver,
      and finally, on Enver Pasha`s advice, made traffic minister to limit
      his influence, but later, after urgent request, made marine minister,
      a capacity in which he worked with great force on the renewal of the
      fleet right until the beginning of the war, when he left Constantinople
      as chief of the army that was sent to Egypt. From this time on, Djemal
      Pasha has naturally been unable to participate in the governing of
      Turkey, and the Marine Ministry too has been in the hands of Enver.

      Among other people who have left their mark on the work of the
      Committee during the past time, besides from the "liberator" Mahmoud
      Chevket Pasha who was murdered in June 1913, must be mentioned Azmi
      Bey, who, together with the then military commander of the city,
      Djemal Pasha, and in connection with Talaat Bey, led the terror
      regime as Chief of Police in the capital after the killing of Mahmoud
      Chevket Pasha, but who on the Russian embassy`s firm demand was sent
      to Konia shortly thereafter as governor, furthermore Hadji Adil Bey,
      the present governor in Adrianople, mentioned in my report No. CXXIII
      [123] of yesterday, and finally 2 men, who have eventually distanced
      themselves from the Committee because they could not follow it in its
      lust for power and its abuse : Rahmy Bey, the governor of the vilayet
      Aidin (Smyrna), who, as also mentioned in my earlier reports, several
      times has opposed the Committee`s orders when he found them unjust,
      and Ahmed Riza Bey, who became the only important opponent of the
      Committee`s autocracy in the last parliamentary session. Riza Tevfik
      Bey, an influential member in the early days of the Committee as the
      original intellectual protagonist of the Committee, and very esteemed
      by all sides, also by the opponents of the Committee, was already at
      an early stage repulsed by the way the rulers realized his ideals,
      and was already in 1910 among the opponents of the Committee.

      The Committee for Union and Progress took control under the motto :
      Equal rights for all Ottomans. But to achieve the unity, that was at
      the beginning of the Committe`s title, in the vast and ethnographically
      tangled empire, there had to be created both an Ottoman sense of unity
      shared by all peoples of the empire, and be raised guarantees that
      this new "Ottomanism" would also be led by the Young Turk members
      of the Committee in the future, both be created equal rights for all
      Ottoman citizens, without consideration for nationality and religion
      (the idealistic demands of the revolution), and made sure that the new
      Ottomanism would still become a purely Turkish movement. The struggle
      between these demands lasted for some time, until the Committee
      immediately after the end of the Balkan war threw one of the demands
      (equal rights for all Ottomans) overboard and decided to go forward
      along the road of Turkification, the road that is characterized by
      the anti-Greek boycott in the Spring of 1914 that affected those
      Greeks who were Ottoman subjects just as well as the Greek subjects,
      the simultaneous persecutions of the Greeks in Asia Minor and Thrace,
      and, later that same year - with German assistance - the declaration
      of Jihad, which was favoured by the World War and the subsequent
      abrogation of the capitulations, and which finally has led to the
      xenophobic and nationalistic policy, whose effects I have lately looked
      closely upon several times in my reports, and whose main purpose at the
      moment is the extermination of the Armenian population of the empire.

      Mr. Foreign Minister will maybe realize from this account, in spite of
      its faultiness, that it does not seem to be men with great political
      refinement and experience, or with good knowledge, who now rule Turkey,
      but people whose foolhardiness and irrepressable force of will and
      action has replaced the former inertia, which was the strength of
      the old Pashas before 1908, and Germany, should the occasion arise,
      will have to realize that they are not manageable.

      They are chauvinists and xenophobes, more or less true fanatics and
      enthusiastic desperados ; for some of them there can be no doubt about
      their integrity, but the common perception is that it will continue
      down that same road that has already led to so many serious conflicts.

      After the Greeks and the Armenians, the Jews and the Germans will most
      likely be next, and it is very probable that the present government
      will, at a given moment, prefer to play va banque and put everything on
      the line, rather than understand that wise compliance and a compromise
      for practical reasons can be preferable to a policy that almost can
      be characterized as national suicide.

      With the highest esteem I remain, Mr. Minister, yours faithfully

      [Wandel]
      General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

      Comment


      • #4
        DOCUMENT 4

        1916-04-27-DK-001

        The minister in Constantinople (Carl Ellis Wandel) to the foreign
        minister (Erik Scavenius)

        Source : Danish National Archives, Foreign Office, Group Cases
        1909-1945. Dept. 139, Gr. N, No. 1, "Armenia"

        No. LXXXXVIII [98]

        Constantinople, April 27, 1916.

        Confidential.

        Mr. Foreign Minister,

        The Papal minister [Angelo Marie Dolci] yesterday turned up in the
        local Spanish legation [in Constantinople] accompanied by a German
        Catholic priest who had arrived here from the Turkish Vilayet of Angora
        in Asia Minor, where he has witnessed the treatment that has befallen
        the local Armenian Catholic congregation, and which he introduced to
        the [Spanish] minister, whom they asked to intervene and protest to
        the Porte in the name of Catholic Spain.

        The reason for their turning to the Spanish legation, they said, was
        because the German and Austrian embassies had such a relationship
        with the Turkish government that they, in order not to [offend]
        it, had to show so much consideration that they really could not
        energetically plead the cause of the Armenians.

        When one bears in mind that the two embassies mentioned represent
        24 and 34 million Catholics respectively, and that the leader of the
        Catholic Centrum of the German Reichstag [Matthias Erzberger] in these
        very days is here in Constantinople on an official visit as a guest
        of the Turkish government, and that the local German ambassador,
        Count Metternich, himself is a Catholic, one can conclude by this
        request how careful the German diplomacy in Turkey is now acting,
        and the extent to which it weighs Germany`s political considerations
        over all other considerations.

        Even though, as it appears from my report No. CXIII [113] of September
        4 last year, 13 of the 16 Catholic congregations that existed among
        the Armenians in Turkey outside of Constantinople have disappeared
        completely, without anyone having knowledge of what has happened to
        all of the clergy, the Catholic Centrum of the German Reichstag does
        not seem to dare to attempt any forceful intervention on behalf of
        its unfortunate, persecuted co-religionists.

        While describing the state of things, I shall not refrain from adding
        that it is very possible that even a vigorous German diplomatic
        intervention on behalf of the Armenians would not move the Turkish
        government to refrain from its project, because the great effort that
        the local American embassy, which does not have to show the same
        kind of consideration as the German and Austrian embassy, has done
        to save the Armenians, has, the American Charge d`Affaires [Phillips]
        tells me, been fruitless, and this has in all probability, after what
        I only later have learned, also been one of the contributing factors
        to the departure of the American ambassador [Henry Morgenthau].

        With the highest esteem I remain, Mr. Minister, yours faithfully

        [Wandel]

        --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

        --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

        DOCUMENT 5

        1916-03-14-DK-001

        The minister in Constantinople (Carl Ellis Wandel) to the foreign
        minister (Erik Scavenius)

        Source : Danish National Archives, Foreign Office, Group Cases
        1909-1945. Dept. 139, Gr. N, No. 1, "Armenia"

        1 enclosure.

        No. LVIII [58]

        Constantinople, March 14, 1916.

        Mr Foreign Minister,

        In continuation of my report No. LIV [54] dated the 10th of this
        month concerning the persecutions of the Armenians, I have the honor
        to report that the latest pieces of information received here state
        that the general removal of the Armenian population, which has already
        taken place in all the other Vilayets of Asia Minor except for the
        Vilayet Aidin (Smyrna), has now also begun in the Vilayet of Castamuni,
        in which the Armenians hitherto have not been disturbed.

        The governor of the Vilayet of Castamuni, who has not used the
        authority given to him to have the Armenian population removed,
        has been dismissed, and in his place the governor up till now of the
        Vilayet of Angora, who has been more zealous, has been appointed.

        I use the opportunity to send an enclosed official announcement from
        today concerning the execution of 4 Armenians, who were hanged in
        Stambul yesterday morning.

        With the highest esteem I remain, Mr. Minister, yours faithfully

        [Wandel]

        Enclosure : "Lloyd Ottoman", March 14, 1916 :

        Pendaisons

        Du commandement de la place :

        Par decision de la cour martiale sont condamnes a la peine capitale
        : Les nommes Horen veledi Hatchadour Beremian, forgeron habitant
        la quartier Kouyoumdji a Adapazar, Kirkor veledi Ohannès, Kabian,
        locataire de l`hôtel Ararat et du casino habitant dans le quartier
        Abdal de la meme ville, le bijoutier Karabet veledi Ohannès Patokian,
        du village Bagdjedjik (Ismidt), convaincus d`avoir fait partie du
        comite revolutionnaire armenien et d`avoir neglige de remettre,
        durant le delai prescrit, aux autorites les bombes cachees dans leur
        maison ; ainsi que le converti Mehmed Chakir bin Minas alias Abdullah,
        de Brousse coinvancu d`avoir complote contre le gouvernement ottoman
        et d`avoir fait l`espionnage contre le gouvernement pou le compte du
        gouvernement Anglais et le nomme Adem effendi de Monastir, agent de
        police, convaincu d`avoir assassine par premeditation Ali Riza bey,
        merkez m'mour du poste Tcinili a Scutari.

        Cette decision de la court martiale ayant ete sanctionnee par irade
        imperial, l`execution a eu lieu hier matin. Les quatre premiers
        condamnes ont ete pendus sur la place de Bayazid et l`agent de police
        Adem effendi pres du debarcadère de Scutari.

        # # #

        ---------------------------------------------------------------------
        Translations of reports from the archives of the Danish foreign
        ministry documenting the Armenian genocide were by Matthias Bjørnlund.

        Copyright Matthias Bjørnlund and Wolfgang Gust,

        website : www.armenocide.de http://www.armenocide.de/

        email : [email protected].
        General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

        Comment


        • #5
          Danish and Norwegian Missionaries





          I may have posted this before but it is worth a second look. Picture #32 is particularly haunting for me and I cannot explain why.

          Below is the English Summary. Every photo has an English caption as well.





          Women Missionary Workers
          Kvinnelige misjonsarbeidere

          Documenting genocide

          Women Missionary Workers (WMW) was established in 1902 after the pattern of Danish and Swedish sister organisations. WMW soon focused on the humanitarian situation for the Armenian people, who for some years had been subject to oppression from Turk authorities. In 1905 the missionary nurse Bodil Biørn (1871-1960) was sent to Armenia. First based in the town of Mezereh (now Elazig) and later in Mush she worked for widows and orphaned children in cooperation with missionaries from the German Hülfsbund. She witnessed the massacres of 1915 in Mush and saw most of the children in her care murdered along with Armenian priests, teachers, and assistants. She barely escaped after 9 days on horseback but stayed on in the region for another 2 years under increasingly difficult working conditions. After a period at home she again went to Armenia and until she retired in 1935 worked for Armenian refugees in Syria and Lebanon.

          Bodil Biørn was also an able photographer. Many of her photos are now in the WMF archive, which since the organisation was dissolved in 1982 has been preserved in the National Archives of Norway. In combination with her comments, written in her photo albums or on the back of the prints themselves, these photos bear strong witness of the atrocities that she saw.

          During World War 1 reports out of Armenia and Kurdistan to the outside world had to be carefully worded if they were to pass the censorship imposed by the Turk authorities. Extracts of letters from Bodil Biørn were published in the WMF newsletters to their members all over Norway, and they constitute eye-witness reports of what has been regarded as the first genocide of the 20th century. Missionaries from other nations have made similar contributions.

          But it is Bodil Biørn’s pictures of the many people that she met – smiling and expectant in times when things looked promising, terrified and despairing in the face of extinction – that leaves us with the stongest impression.
          General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

          Comment


          • #6
            Danish and Norwegian Missionaries





            I may have posted this before but it is worth a second look. Picture #32 is particularly haunting for me and I cannot explain why.

            Below is the English Summary. Every photo has an English caption as well.





            Women Missionary Workers
            Kvinnelige misjonsarbeidere

            Documenting genocide

            Women Missionary Workers (WMW) was established in 1902 after the pattern of Danish and Swedish sister organisations. WMW soon focused on the humanitarian situation for the Armenian people, who for some years had been subject to oppression from Turk authorities. In 1905 the missionary nurse Bodil Biørn (1871-1960) was sent to Armenia. First based in the town of Mezereh (now Elazig) and later in Mush she worked for widows and orphaned children in cooperation with missionaries from the German Hülfsbund. She witnessed the massacres of 1915 in Mush and saw most of the children in her care murdered along with Armenian priests, teachers, and assistants. She barely escaped after 9 days on horseback but stayed on in the region for another 2 years under increasingly difficult working conditions. After a period at home she again went to Armenia and until she retired in 1935 worked for Armenian refugees in Syria and Lebanon.

            Bodil Biørn was also an able photographer. Many of her photos are now in the WMF archive, which since the organisation was dissolved in 1982 has been preserved in the National Archives of Norway. In combination with her comments, written in her photo albums or on the back of the prints themselves, these photos bear strong witness of the atrocities that she saw.

            During World War 1 reports out of Armenia and Kurdistan to the outside world had to be carefully worded if they were to pass the censorship imposed by the Turk authorities. Extracts of letters from Bodil Biørn were published in the WMF newsletters to their members all over Norway, and they constitute eye-witness reports of what has been regarded as the first genocide of the 20th century. Missionaries from other nations have made similar contributions.

            But it is Bodil Biørn’s pictures of the many people that she met – smiling and expectant in times when things looked promising, terrified and despairing in the face of extinction – that leaves us with the stongest impression.
            General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

            Comment


            • #7
              My sincerest thanks for your efforts.

              Comment


              • #8



                Bodil Biorn - An Unsung Heroine
                [December 10, 2007]

                "When we finished shooting the film," said Jussi Flemming Biorn, "The director, who had been an atheist all his life, said, 'I now have no choice but to believe in God.' I thought that it could not have been any other way - throughout the shoot there had been all sorts of lucky 'coincidences', even miracles, as if someone up above truly wanted this movie to be completed. Throughout production, it seemed as if we always ended up in the right place at the right time."

                Norwegian Jussi Flemming was in Armenia to select Armenian music for his movie entitled They Call Me Mother, about his grandmother Bodil Biorn.

                "There are people," said Jussi, "Who have been real heroes, and whose mission has required more effort and courage than the first people to the North or South Poles. One of them was Bodil Biorn, a person who embodied the ideals with which Norway has moved forward today."

                In 1902, a Danish woman, Emsy Collet, founded a union called the Women's Missionary Workers, located in Copenhagen. Within this movement, schools were opened which preached the Bible, funds were raised for charitable purposes and - one of the main objectives of the union - missionaries were sent to Anatolia to work with the Christians there. Of all the organizations operating in that region at the time, this stood out as the smallest and the only one consisting solely of women.

                Bodil Biorn was the only Norwegian of the twenty-two women sent to Western Armenia by the organization. She was born in 1871 in the Norwegian city of Kragero, into a family of wealthy ship owners. The building that is currently the Kragero City Hall used to be her family home. Bodil was one of the few girls who went to school at that time. Girls were simply refused an education then, but her paternal uncle was the principal of a school in Oslo and he admitted her there.

                In 1909, after Bodil graduated from school, she was sent to Berlin to study music for two years. She was then supposed to marry and start a family, like all girls of her time. But Bodil chose a different destiny. Bodil trained as a gynecological nurse, joined the Women's Missionary Workers, and left for Western Armenia. The living and working conditions there were very different from those in her native city of Kragero. The Christians were living in conditions of constant oppression and persecution. In those days, when women had only just received the right to vote, Bodil opened orphanages, schools and free hospitals in Western Armenia, gathering a staff consisting only of locals, whom she trained. She spoke Armenian, Turkish, Arabic, German and English. Bodil worked in the Near East for more than thirty years.

                She was in Western Armenia when the Armenians were massacred. But in 1917, Bodil was forced to flee from Eastern Anatolia to escape the Ottomans. She left for Norway, only to return just a year later to the newly independent Republic of Armenia. Four years later, she was forced to flee once more, this time to escape the Soviet authorities.

                Bodil continued her missionary service in Syria. She lived with her son until her death and was especially close to her grandson, Jussi Flemming Biorn.

                Bodil Biorn died in 1960, at the age of 90. After her death, Jussi had come up with the idea of both a book and a movie based on his grandmother's life. The significance of Bodil's work also lay in the fact that she had left journals and numerous photographs, which spoke in great detail not only of the massacres and the related tragedies - starving and emaciated orphans - but also of the daily life and culture of the people who lived in those times.

                Jussi left his job as an advisor in the energy sector, found a director who agreed to shoot the film and a producer who was willing to cover the costs, and began shooting in 2004.

                In the film, currently in post-production, Jussi facilitates a meeting between the past and the present. He is sent along the footsteps of his grandmother to Syria (Aleppo and the desert of Der-Zor), many regions of Turkey and Western Armenia. He tries to find the people who grew up as children in the orphanages established by Bodil, as well as other people she had mentioned in her journals.

                The film has a number of aims. When Bodil fled from Western Armenia, she took with her to Norway an Armenian child, whom she said she had adopted in Mush. She only mentioned that the child, whom she had named Fritjoff, had had brothers and sisters, and that his father's name had been Petros Safaryan. Bodil had refused to give other details, and rumors started going around that the child, who had fair skin and blue eyes - resembling Bodil greatly - was in fact her biological son and not adopted. Fritjoff's son Jussi has tried to find his real roots - were they Armenian, or Norwegian?

                "The other aim is to focus not only on the tragic events, which is often the case in movies related to the Genocide," said Jussi, "I want to present the many cheerful stories with happy endings that Bodil had written about."

                One of those stories was linked to an amazing coincidence which they had witnessed while shooting the movie. Jussi was telling a story from Bodil's journals to the Armenian community in Aleppo. It was about a family who had escaped from the Turks during the massacres by hiding in a well for a few days, without food or water. They had then managed to escape with the help of a Turkish officer and had fled to Syria. The family consisted of four girls, their father and mother, who was pregnant with a fifth child. After he completed the story, one of those present left and came back with someone else, who then told Jussi that that had been the story of his family and that he had been the unborn child at that time.

                A memorial stone to Bodil was made in Aleppo. It now stands in her native Kragero, opposite City Hall. "They knew of Bodil's family in City Hall," said Jussi, "But they didn't know that their native city had borne a true heroine. People know very little about Bodil in Norway. She is buried in a very modest grave in Oslo. A year after the installation of the memorial stone, City Hall recognized the Armenian Genocide as a historical fact. This could be the first step for official recognition by Norway."

                Another coincidence occurred when the crew were shooting in Gyumri. In 1921, Bodil had set up an orphanage in Gyumri, then Alexandropol, which had then been closed down four years later by the Soviet authorities. Jussi had used the photographs and journal descriptions to determine an approximate location of the orphanage.

                "At one point, I just felt that we were very close and I asked the driver to stop the car. We stepped out and saw Ludwig."

                Ninety-year old Ludwig knew the story of the orphanage well. He had grown up in an American orphanage and remembered that the children of Bodil's orphanage (around thirty people) had slept two to a bed, but had had no lack of food or clothing.

                In Western Armenia, their expensive camera broke down when they were shooting in Van. "We had rented it in Oslo and didn't know what to do. If it had been in Istanbul, it wouldn't have been a problem to find a similar camera. But there was nothing we could do in this distant place."

                The Kurd accompanying them came to the rescue. He found a small recording company that worked to provide video coverage of weddings. The company owner had a month ago coincidentally bought the same make of camera that the director had been using. It was very expensive and too complicated to use for weddings, so the man was delighted to rent it out to the foreigners.

                "What was funny was that people would ask me in Western Armenia, 'Are you looking for gold?' as they would ask prospectors a hundred years ago. They wanted to become partners in the deal. I used to say, 'Yes, I'm looking for gold, but this is a different kind of gold.'"

                They Call Me Mother will be shown as part of the upcoming Golden Apricot film festival. An exhibition of Bodil's photographs will also be organized simultaneously.

                Jussi Fleming also presented Bodil Biorn's story in Yerevan, at a conference dedicated to the 40th anniversary of the establishment of Genocide Memorial.


                Hasmik Hovhannisyan
                Copyright © 2002-2007 Hetq Online. All rights reserved. Design by NetFlute. Developed and supported by Aram Badalyan
                General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

                Comment


                • #9
                  Interesting.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X