Announcement

Collapse

Forum Rules (Everyone Must Read!!!)

1] What you CAN NOT post.

You agree, through your use of this service, that you will not use this forum to post any material which is:
- abusive
- vulgar
- hateful
- harassing
- personal attacks
- obscene

You also may not:
- post images that are too large (max is 500*500px)
- post any copyrighted material unless the copyright is owned by you or cited properly.
- post in UPPER CASE, which is considered yelling
- post messages which insult the Armenians, Armenian culture, traditions, etc
- post racist or other intentionally insensitive material that insults or attacks another culture (including Turks)

The Ankap thread is excluded from the strict rules because that place is more relaxed and you can vent and engage in light insults and humor. Notice it's not a blank ticket, but just a place to vent. If you go into the Ankap thread, you enter at your own risk of being clowned on.
What you PROBABLY SHOULD NOT post...
Do not post information that you will regret putting out in public. This site comes up on Google, is cached, and all of that, so be aware of that as you post. Do not ask the staff to go through and delete things that you regret making available on the web for all to see because we will not do it. Think before you post!


2] Use descriptive subject lines & research your post. This means use the SEARCH.

This reduces the chances of double-posting and it also makes it easier for people to see what they do/don't want to read. Using the search function will identify existing threads on the topic so we do not have multiple threads on the same topic.

3] Keep the focus.

Each forum has a focus on a certain topic. Questions outside the scope of a certain forum will either be moved to the appropriate forum, closed, or simply be deleted. Please post your topic in the most appropriate forum. Users that keep doing this will be warned, then banned.

4] Behave as you would in a public location.

This forum is no different than a public place. Behave yourself and act like a decent human being (i.e. be respectful). If you're unable to do so, you're not welcome here and will be made to leave.

5] Respect the authority of moderators/admins.

Public discussions of moderator/admin actions are not allowed on the forum. It is also prohibited to protest moderator actions in titles, avatars, and signatures. If you don't like something that a moderator did, PM or email the moderator and try your best to resolve the problem or difference in private.

6] Promotion of sites or products is not permitted.

Advertisements are not allowed in this venue. No blatant advertising or solicitations of or for business is prohibited.
This includes, but not limited to, personal resumes and links to products or
services with which the poster is affiliated, whether or not a fee is charged
for the product or service. Spamming, in which a user posts the same message repeatedly, is also prohibited.

7] We retain the right to remove any posts and/or Members for any reason, without prior notice.


- PLEASE READ -

Members are welcome to read posts and though we encourage your active participation in the forum, it is not required. If you do participate by posting, however, we expect that on the whole you contribute something to the forum. This means that the bulk of your posts should not be in "fun" threads (e.g. Ankap, Keep & Kill, This or That, etc.). Further, while occasionally it is appropriate to simply voice your agreement or approval, not all of your posts should be of this variety: "LOL Member213!" "I agree."
If it is evident that a member is simply posting for the sake of posting, they will be removed.


8] These Rules & Guidelines may be amended at any time. (last update September 17, 2009)

If you believe an individual is repeatedly breaking the rules, please report to admin/moderator.
See more
See less

German Correspondence: Eyewitness acounts

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • German Correspondence: Eyewitness acounts

    http://www.armenocide.de/armenocide/armgende.nsf/$$AllDocsTrans/1915-08-21-DE-011?OpenDocument

    From the Chairman of the Baghdad Railway in Constantinople Franz Johannes Guenther to the Legation Councillor of the German Embassy in Constantinople Neurath

    Correspondence


    Chemin de Fer Ottoman d’Anatolie (Ottoman Railway of Anatolia).

    Constantinople, 21 August 1915

    Dear Mr. von Neurath,
    For obvious reasons I do not wish to convey the enclosed report to you through official channels, but simply as a private person and for your own personal information.

    With best regards,


    Yours faithfully,
    Guenther

    [Note Mordtmann, 24 August]

    Have noted. I am adding a detailed record containing the latest reports by Messrs. Zabel and von Hollbach.

    Enclosure

    Konia, 16 August 1915

    The undersigned German nationals, at present residing in Konia, would herewith like to present the following report to the Imperial German Embassy.
    For the past week we have been witnesses of the most moving scenes, which anyone not coming into close contact with them can hardly imagine. Every day long trains of Armenians arrive here, who according to their accounts, have been deported from Ismidt, Ada-Basar and the surrounding areas.

    From some of those passing through we have learned that the deportation regulations have already been enforced for many months in Cilicia and North Mesopotamia and as we hear, also other places in Anatolia are being cleared of the Armenians. Today the local Armenians also received the order to leave the town within eight days.

    Naturally, it is not up to us to complain about the measures taken by the authorities. We are also aware that there are some guilty ones among the Armenians. What we wish to achieve with our report is only to express our objection to the way in which these deportees are being treated, which runs completely counter to any form of humanity.

    Women and children are being driven along with blows of the fists and with sticks. They are being chased out into the night on open carts and Tatar carriages and those without money have to continue the difficult journey on foot carrying the remainder of their possessions.

    Those who are even without the bare necessities have to sell off their few belongings, but these are often torn from them by force and stolen.

    How great is the despair of mothers who have to give away their children in order to spare them the most wretched fate.

    Children who have been taken in by compassionate Christian families are later taken away from them by the authorities and given to the Turks.

    Help from our side is not favoured. This reminds us of an occurrence in April of this year where the assistance of the local American mission given to approx. 3000 Armenians expelled from Seitun was forbidden; on the other hand, no objection was raised from any side when, during the Balkan turmoils, beds and linen worth more than 500 Ltq. were distributed from Eski-Chehir to Eregli among the Muslim emigrants.

    The whole of the route from here to beyond Aleppo resembles a caravan of misery and wretchedness. In places such as Karaman, Eregli and xxxanti, where the people themselves are suffering from a shortage of bread, the fate of the deportees is unimaginable; they are destined to suffer a slow, agonising death by starvation. For your information we would like to mention that in xxxanti, despite a price of 8 piasters for an oka [just over 2 pounds] of bread, there is none available at all.

    In the mountainous areas on this side and in the plain on the other side of the Taurus, these poor people are subjected to the most disgraceful lustful desires of the half-wild Muslim population.

    The whole measure seems to be aimed at a complete extermination of the Armenians.

    This inhumane treatment constitutes a disgrace, which is indelible in world history, not only for the Turks, but also for us Germans as their current allies and advisors if we continue to stand back and allow the destruction of this people. Apart from this, this procedure is highly deplorable in the interest of the economic position of the country, and German enterprises will also be affected when this industrious people is destroyed.

    If the undersigned take the liberty of conveying a report about these circumstances to the Imperial Embassy, then they are doing so under the assumption that these facts are not known in full to the Imperial German Embassy.

    We Germans, who are forced daily to observe this inhumane activity, feel it is our duty as members of a cultural state in the midst of a half-civilised people, to protest against it.

    In expectation that our petition will be considered to such an extent that at least the fate of many thousands of innocent women and children is relieved, we remain,


    Yours faithfully,

    Willy Seeger, Chairman of the Anatolian Industrial and Trading Company Ltd., Konia branch. Georg Biegel, secondary school teacher. Heinrich Janson, foreman. J. E. Maurer, qualified engineer.

    [Record Mordtmann, 24 August]


    I) On his journey from Mesopotamia to here, Mr. Rudolf Zabel from the newspaper Tägliche Rundschau, who visited me on 20th inst., observed the train of Armenian emigrants as far as Konia and even further.
    He was in possession of a copy of the objection raised by the Germans from Konia.

    He describes the way in which the deportation is carried out, beginning in the west, as follows:

    The transports are first directed to Konia where there is a fairly large concentration camp; those who cannot buy a rail ticket have to go on foot.

    In Konia most of them sell their belongings, but are only allowed to sell to Turks.

    The wealthier deposited their cash with the Banque Ottomane; this was later prohibited and the deposits were confiscated by the authorities; this is what happened to a rich Saracen from Izmid, amongst others.

    The property owned by Armenians is registered by the Armenian Bishop of Ismid; the register is in the hands of the engineer Maurer, who will later be passing it on to here.

    More recently, the Protestant and Catholic Armenians are being spared; the Armenians who have been deported from Izmid and the surrounding areas are at present in Eskischehir, and are supposed to be heading for Kintakja, where the Armenians have been expelled.

    The accommodation and food-supply for the deportees is bad. There is a high death rate.

    In Eregli there is a large camp (approx. 3000 people); it appears that those who have travelled by train are accommodated there as the people still had a lot of belongings with them; there is also a high death rate in this camp.

    In E. five railway trains arrive each day, each with 1000 - 1500 Armenians; Mr. Zabel has seen 8000 moving along on foot.

    Ulu Kischla is one of the worst stations. The camp there was formerly occupied by labour battalions, is infested with refuse, insects, etc. The conditions for the deportees there is very wretched.

    Beyond Ulukirchla there is no more transport by train. The deportees are herded on in individual groups like cattle.

    It is there that the attacks by robbers begin; Mr. Z. had proven news of such an attack. 15 Armenians were killed or wounded during the ambush.

    In xxxanti, the next station, there is neither accommodation nor bread; from there it is another 10 kms without a break to a refugee camp along the military supply and communication route.

    Beyond xxxanti there are no longer any strong men to be seen among the deportees. There are only a few carts for those with money, as all available vehicles have been requisitioned by the military.

    In Adana the emigrants arrive completely exhausted.

    The military route Adana - Osmanié - Hamidé is now only passed along on foot; the camps (in the open air) are in a terrible condition. Beyond Aleppo there are also no longer any marriageable girls among the deportees.

    Lieutenant Colonel Klinckhardt was offered 2 girls by Turkish officers in Ratulem. [This sentence was deleted.]

    In Kubla there is another large camp where, amongst others, the Armenians from Dörtjol are accommodated.

    Of the other things that Mr. Z. has observed, it should be mentioned that Azmi bej, who was posted to Beirut, gave the order to destroy the bell-tower of the local Armenian Protestant Church, which is also frequented by German Protestants, shortly before his departure from Konja. Despite an urgent plea from the German side, the order was carried out.

    Mr. Zabel gives the impression of being a sober, impartial observer; he has collected plenty of material, including a series of photographs and films.

    His judgement on the behaviour of the Turkish authorities in the interior of the country was devastating; among other things he said:

    he had travelled in many countries in disquieting times - while war and revolution dominated the country - but he had never seen any anarchy of this kind anywhere at all.


    II On 23rd inst., Mr. von Holbach (Regie official, has been in Turkey for many years) visited me; he was last in Adana and came here almost simultaneously with Zabel.

    His accounts of the suffering of the deportees coincide with the reports of Mr. Zabel.

    I would like to emphasise a few of his details:

    Those transported by train are being crowded, at present 50 to 60 at a time, into cattle trucks which can otherwise hardly hold 40.

    In Konia and Adana there have been many conversions to Islam; many Armenians are already selling their children in Konia.

    The trade in Adana will be badly damaged by the persecution of the Armenians. The whole of the bazaar in Adana is Armenian. The cotton cultivation is also almost exclusively in Armenians hands; trade with this commodity in Greek hands.

    Hakki bey (General Staff Officer), Vali of Adana, tried at the beginning to protect the Armenians, but was then ordered to Constantinople, and since his return has been relentlessly against the Armenians.

    Mr. von Hollbach closed his report with the words:

    He has always been completely sympathetic with the Turks; but after all he had seen with his own eyes, he had been totally ridden of his sympathies for the Turks.

    For now he would keep his silence, but at the right moment he would bring everything into the newspapers.



    [Notes Mordtmann, 24 August]


    Willy Seeger in Konia, 19 August to Mr. Guenther: (excerpt)

    1) The preparation period for their deportation granted to the Armenians has been reduced from 8 to 6 days; on 21st 2000 persons are to be expelled. ...
    2) The Armenian Bishop is asking me to send a message to His Majesty the Emperor, saying that all Gregorian Armenians wish to become Protestants and are requesting the protection of the Emperor. ...

    3) There is a rumour going around that due to the intervention of His Majesty Franz Joseph, the Catholics are being exempted from deportation. ...

    4) There is the greatest despair among the Armenians. Policemen are even taking the liberty of infringing on them. Their possessions are being sold off at ridiculous prices and all kinds of obstacles are being put in the way of these poor people while their belongings are being sold. ...

    5) As notified, approx. 25 Armenians have declared their willingness to become Muslims.

    6) As I already wrote, the order even applies to my employees.


    is asking the Embassy to undertake steps on behalf of the persecuted.

    [Note by Mordtmann, 24 August]

    With regard to the Catholics and the Protestants, Talaat Bey repeated his earlier assurances to me yesterday; I especially mentioned item 6); with regard to this, Talaat B. remarked that he had already spoken to H. Guenther about the matter. The railway officials will remain, but are to be gradually replaced.
    General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

  • #2
    Excerpts of the Writings of a German Citizen Who Died in Turkey


    I traveled to Marash between June 28 and August 20, 1915. The subject of the discussions of the inhabitants of the Beshgeoz village, which is situated between Kilis and Ayntab, was that the deportation of Armenians from Marash was going to start the next day. A few moments later, a well dressed man who gave the impression that he was a Circassian -- due to the fact that he was partly dressed like a mufti (a religious leader) and partly like an officer -- approached the crowd and asked, "From which side of the city are they taking the population away; through which road are they passing; what kind of people are they; and how can we take advantage of them?" One of the persons present asked him whether he was a civilian or a military personnel. He replied, by smiling, "Can there be a better opportunity than now for being a military personnel?" The same individual added, "This time Germany has given such a lesson to these pigs that they will never forget."
    Having heard that comment, I was forced to reply saying that mentioning the name of Germany with these events was equivalent to burying it. When I came back, I heard that the first caravans of Ayntab, that were exclusively consisted of wealthy people, were robbed up to their last shirts. I learned from different sources that the governmental authorities had turned a blind eye to these events and that the person mentioned above was collaborating with them. In Karabuyuk, which is located between Ayntab and Marash, I came across a group of Armenians comprised of 40 women and children, as well as 5 or 6 men. Before them walked 100 soldiers, at a distance of 180 yards. Among the women, there was a young teacher who had been carrying out her duties among Germans for a few years. She had just healed from acute typhus. The soldiers required that she and another young woman, the husband of whom was a conscript in Damascus, spend the night with them, and it resorted to violence. The attacks of the soldiers were driven back, thanks to the intercession of muslim muleteers who rushed to the aid of the women.

    On August 6th, the Armenian village of Fendedjak, near Marash (which had 3,000 inhabitants), was totally destroyed. The population consisted almost entirely of muleteers had been forced to transport Armenians to the Euphrates during the prior three months. They had seen with their own eyes bodies in the Euphrates, as well as the sale and rape of women and girls.

    In one of the Armenian schools of Marash, I saw more than 100 women and children who had sustained bullet wounds in their legs and arms, and who had been mutilated in various ways. Among them there were one- or two-year old children.

    On the 13th of August, 34 Armenians -- two of whom were 12 year old boys -- were executed in Marash. In the same way, on the 15th of August, 24 persons were shot and 14 hung. The 24 people who were shot were attached to each other by their necks with a heavy chain and had been forced to stand up as one body. They were shot behind the American college, in the presence of the local inhabitants. I saw with my own eyes that the bodies, still shaken with agonizing pain, were delivered to a strange crowd of civilians who tugged at their hands and legs. During the following half hour, policemen and gendarmes kept shooting at the bodies -- some of which were terribly disfigured -- with pistols, while the population joyfully observed. Later, the same crowd filed past the German hospital and chanted, "Long Live Germany!" Muslims told me repeatedly that the reason for the massacre of Armenians in this manner was due to the Germans.

    While traveling from the city to a village, on the outskirts of the town, I saw a human head separated from the body on a pile of garbage, which the Turkish notables (aghas) were using as a target. During my stay in Marash, Armenians were killed every day by inhabitants of the city, and the bodies remained in open sewers or elsewhere for several days.

    In Marash, General Kadir told me, "I know that all these people in the region of the 4th Army died as a consequence of an order of the government."

    On the Friday, the 20th of August, 1915, at six o'clock in the evening, it was publicly announced in Marash that, according to an order of the Governor of Adana, all men above the age of 15 (5,000 persons) should gather outside the city to depart on Saturday afternoon. If after 12 o'clock any of them were found in the city, they would be killed on the spot. Everybody knew the meaning of that order and we lived in terror for hours that day. At the very last moment, thanks to the intercession of the very kind Governor of Marash, the order of the Governor of Adana was modified, to the extent that it allowed the men to depart with their families; whereas, on the 18th of August, the Governor had reassured the religious authorities that the Armenians of Marash would not be deported. Thus, those who had come out of the cities were forced to leave without any preparations.

    All the Armenian inhabitants of the village of Beoveren, which is situated near Albistan and amounted to 82 people, were murdered, with the exception of a 12 year old boy who dove in the water and escaped.

    The inhabitants of a village located around Zeytoun were deported, despite being contaminated with smallpox. Those who suffered from smallpox, among whom were people who had lost their sight, stayed in the hotels of Marash, where deportees from other regions were already present.

    I saw a caravan of 100 people. Among them were a few blind people. A 60 year old mother was leading her daughter who was lame from birth. They started their travel on foot. An hour later, a man fell near the bridge of Erkesen. They immediately robbed and killed him. Four days later we saw his body still lying in the mud.

    Last night I visited a friend. He hosted a mother and her child -- who were the survivors of a family of 26 individuals deported from Sivas -- that were deported from Sivas three months earlier, but whom had only arrived a few days ago.

    In Ayntab I saw a written order of the Governor forbidding the Muslim population to buy the belongings of deported Armenians. That same Governor organized an attack on the deportees; two caravans were robbed completely.

    Two thousand eight hundred people deported from Gurin were attacked near Ayran Ponar (at a distance of 12 hours from Marash in a north-eastward direction) and massacred by 8 bandits who were either wearing military uniforms or dressed like civilians. In Kizil Getchit, located at a distance of an hour and a half from Ayran Ponar, the 8 bandits were joined by the gendarmes accompanying the caravan and they engaged in a long discussion. In Ayran Ponar, gendarmes ordered the people to split into two groups. One group was comprised of women. They were told to undress and then they were robbed. In the night, four women and two girls were removed and then raped. The next morning, five of them returned to the caravan. In one of the straits of the Engisek mountain, Turks and Kurds together pillaged the entire caravan. During this attack 200 people died. Seventy heavily wounded people were left behind and more than 50 others were taken away with the caravan. Later, I came across the same caravan again in Karabuyuk, at which time it was comprised of 2,500 people. People were in an indescribable state of misery. At a distance of an hour and a half from Karabuyuk, two men were lying on the road: one was wounded by two blows from a knife, the other by seven. A bit further, women who were exhausted were lying on the road. Even further down the road lay 4 ladies, one of whom was a 13 year old girl, holding in her arms her 2 day old baby which was wrapped in pieces of cloth. A 60 year old man, who was lying on the road because of his wound -- which measured one finger long and 2 fingers wide (caused by a blow from a knife) -- told me he had taken to the road with his 13 animals from Gurun. All his animals and belongings were confiscated from him in Ayran Ponar, and he had dragged himself to a place which was at a distance of an hour and a half from Karabuyuk, where he finally collapsed from exhaustion.

    All those people were wealthy. The animals, belongings, and the amount of money stolen from them was valued at 8,000 Turkish golden coins. The wounded were lying on the road, surrounded on both side by bodies. There were barely 30-40 men in this caravan which consisted of 2,500 people. Every man above the age of 15 had been taken away in the presence of the women and most likely murdered. These Armenians were intentionally transferred via tortuous roads and dangerous straits. By a straight road, they would have reached Marash in 4 days; whereas, they were on the road for more than a month. They were forced to travel without animals, beds, or food. They received a thin slice of bread per day, which could not satisfy their hunger. Four hundred of them (Protestants) arrived in Halep, and 2 or 3 people died every day.

    The robbery of Ayran Ponar took place with the complicity of the Kaymakam (governmental representative in a provincial district) of Albistan, who received 200 Turkish golden coins and promised the people to take them safely to Ayntab. The Kaymakam of Gurin received 1,200 Turkish golden coins and provided the same reassurances. In the club of Gurun, I saw a man who was remitting that sum to the Kaymakam. In the vicinity of Ayntab, a few women belonging to that group were raped by the inhabitants of Ayntab. During the robbery of Ayran Ponar, men were tied to trees and burned alive. While the Armenians of Gurin moved away from the town, the mollas chanted prayers on the roofs of Christian churches. An eyewitness told me about an argument between two brothers regarding loot seized in Ayran Ponar. One of them told the other, "For these four loads, I assassinated 40 women."

    In Marash, a Muslim named Hani, that I had known for years, told me the following, "In Nisibin, the other muleteers and I were imprisoned in an inn. A few young women coming from Furnuz were raped in the night both by gendarmes and civilians accompanying the caravan."

    In the office of the police superintendent of Ayntab, a Muslim notable (agha) told the following to an Armenian, in my presence, "Letters were found in such and such places. What kind of relationship do you have with that man? How many times did I tell you to become a muslim? If you had listened to me, you would have avoided all the unpleasant things to which your nation is being subjected."

    Out of the 18,000 people deported from Harpout and Sivas, 350 reached Halep (women and children). Out of the 1,900 people deported from Erzeroum, only 11 persons -- an ill boy, four girls, and six women -- arrived in that city. A group of women and girls were forced to walk for 65 hours from Ras-El-Ayn to Halep following the railway, despite the fact that at the same time, trains used for the transportation of soldiers were returning empty. Muslim travelers who had passed through these regions described the road as being impassable due to the numerous bodies left in plain view, the smell of which stunk up the air. One hundred to one hundred and twenty people from among the survivors died in Halep as a consequence of the tortures they had endured during the journey. When starving women and children arrived in Halep, they hurled themselves upon food like wild animals. The digestive organs of many of them ceased to function. After having gulped down a few spoonfuls of food, they laid their spoons down. The government asserted that the deportees were provided with food, but in the case of the above-mentioned caravan, which was coming from Harpout, there was only one distribution of bread during the course of three months.



    "Germany, Turkey and Armenia", J. J. Keliher, 1917, London.
    General Antranik (1865-1927): “I am not a nationalist. I recognize only one nation, the nation of the oppressed.”

    Comment

    Working...
    X