Tweet
Re: Temporarily So Called Turkey and the World: Perceptions, Relations...
Relations With The EU (Part I)
Relations With The EU (Part I)
TURKEY INCHES TOWARD EU, CLOUDED BY FRENCH OBJECTIONS
By James G. Neuger
Bloomberg
Update 2
Dec 19 2007
Dec. 19 (Bloomberg) -- Turkey inched ahead with its bid to enter the
European Union, in talks increasingly clouded by French President
Nicolas Sarkozy's determination to make sure the country never gets in.
Negotiations started today over aligning Turkey's regulations with
the EU in the areas of consumer protection and transport and energy
networks. Turkey has now started talks in six of the bloc's 35 policy
areas and completed one.
Under French pressure, the EU has shifted the negotiations into a
lower gear, a sign of rising opposition in the heart of Europe to
letting in a predominantly Muslim country with a standard of living
less than a third of the EU level.
"Certain member states are trying to erode our political and judicial
position," Turkish Foreign Minister Ali Babacan told a Brussels
press conference. "Such attitudes are not proper and do not reflect
a responsible approach."
Turkey has made scant progress toward joining since embarking on
the EU entry marathon in 2005. The bloc froze negotiations in eight
policy areas last year to punish Turkey for refusing to trade with
the Greek-speaking Republic of Cyprus, part of the EU since 2004.
Negotiations in two or three more areas might get under way in the
first half of next year, EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn said.
Alternative Union
Sarkozy, elected in May on a wave of French anti-Turkey sentiment,
says Turkey's place is in an alternative "Mediterranean Union" and has
vetoed talks in policy areas that would lead directly to EU membership.
"Must Europe enlarge indefinitely and, if yes, what will the
consequences be?" Sarkozy said last week after persuading the EU to
set up a blue-ribbon study group that he expects to challenge Turkey's
fitness to join.
Only 21 percent of Europeans want Turkey to become a member, according
to a September poll by the German Marshall Fund. European attitudes
have darkened the anti-EU mood in Turkey, where only 40 percent of
Turks think membership would be a "good thing," down from 54 percent
last year and 73 percent in 2004, the poll found.
Even Turkish schoolchildren are hearing of the broadsides by Sarkozy
and other anti-Turkey politicians in Europe, making it harder for the
government to amass support to modernize the economy along EU lines,
Babacan said.
`Negative Impact'
Such "provocations" stir feelings among Turks "that they are unwanted,
and that in turn has a negative impact on their position toward the
EU," Babacan said.
Babacan, Rehn and Portuguese Foreign Minister Luis Amado, the chairman
of today's meeting, all backed the "accession" process, using the
jargon that France forced the EU to strip from the preparatory
documents.
Diverging public opinion in Turkey and Europe threatens to breed a
"dangerous situation," Amado said.
Rehn, the EU commissioner shepherding the talks, voiced concern
that the "political atmospherics" between Turkey and EU capitals are
damaging the entry process and said the EU needs to be fair to Turkey.
"At the same time, we need to be firm and emphasize conditionality
and that's why we encourage Turkey to relaunch the reform process
in full," Rehn said. As a sign of support for Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan's EU strategy, the European Commission's president,
Jose Barroso, will visit Turkey early next year, he said.
Hammering home a point he often makes in Brussels, Babacan said the
Turkish government's plans to upgrade the economy and enhance civil
rights won't be blown off course by the souring mood.
EU Subsidies
For example, Babacan said, today's start of talks on linking Turkey's
transport and energy networks to the European grid makes Turkey
eligible for EU subsidies to upgrade its infrastructure.
Babacan gave no timetable for meeting the EU's demand that Turkey
rewrite a section of the penal code that has been used to prosecute
authors who challenged the Turkish orthodoxy that that the World
War I massacre of Armenians by Ottoman Turks was not genocide. One
journalist convicted under the law, Hrant Dink, was later murdered
by a teenage nationalist.
Divided Cyprus
The status of Cyprus also remains an obstacle for Turkey. Turkey's
military has occupied the northern part of the Mediterranean island
since a 1974 invasion in response to a Greek-backed coup.
The dividing line hardened in 2004, when Greek-speaking Cypriots
rejected a unification proposal that had the backing of the Turkish
side. As a result, Cyprus joined the EU without the Turkish-speaking
north of the island, which remains fenced off in the only disputed
border in the EU.
Skirmishes between the Turkish army and Kurdish rebels operating out
of northern Iraq played no role in today's talks. The conflict with
the Kurds didn't come up and Babacan said Turkey isn't relying on
military force alone to pacify the border.
An EU statement yesterday called on the Turkish military to exercise
restraint, while acknowledging Turkey's right to combat terrorists.
By James G. Neuger
Bloomberg
Update 2
Dec 19 2007
Dec. 19 (Bloomberg) -- Turkey inched ahead with its bid to enter the
European Union, in talks increasingly clouded by French President
Nicolas Sarkozy's determination to make sure the country never gets in.
Negotiations started today over aligning Turkey's regulations with
the EU in the areas of consumer protection and transport and energy
networks. Turkey has now started talks in six of the bloc's 35 policy
areas and completed one.
Under French pressure, the EU has shifted the negotiations into a
lower gear, a sign of rising opposition in the heart of Europe to
letting in a predominantly Muslim country with a standard of living
less than a third of the EU level.
"Certain member states are trying to erode our political and judicial
position," Turkish Foreign Minister Ali Babacan told a Brussels
press conference. "Such attitudes are not proper and do not reflect
a responsible approach."
Turkey has made scant progress toward joining since embarking on
the EU entry marathon in 2005. The bloc froze negotiations in eight
policy areas last year to punish Turkey for refusing to trade with
the Greek-speaking Republic of Cyprus, part of the EU since 2004.
Negotiations in two or three more areas might get under way in the
first half of next year, EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn said.
Alternative Union
Sarkozy, elected in May on a wave of French anti-Turkey sentiment,
says Turkey's place is in an alternative "Mediterranean Union" and has
vetoed talks in policy areas that would lead directly to EU membership.
"Must Europe enlarge indefinitely and, if yes, what will the
consequences be?" Sarkozy said last week after persuading the EU to
set up a blue-ribbon study group that he expects to challenge Turkey's
fitness to join.
Only 21 percent of Europeans want Turkey to become a member, according
to a September poll by the German Marshall Fund. European attitudes
have darkened the anti-EU mood in Turkey, where only 40 percent of
Turks think membership would be a "good thing," down from 54 percent
last year and 73 percent in 2004, the poll found.
Even Turkish schoolchildren are hearing of the broadsides by Sarkozy
and other anti-Turkey politicians in Europe, making it harder for the
government to amass support to modernize the economy along EU lines,
Babacan said.
`Negative Impact'
Such "provocations" stir feelings among Turks "that they are unwanted,
and that in turn has a negative impact on their position toward the
EU," Babacan said.
Babacan, Rehn and Portuguese Foreign Minister Luis Amado, the chairman
of today's meeting, all backed the "accession" process, using the
jargon that France forced the EU to strip from the preparatory
documents.
Diverging public opinion in Turkey and Europe threatens to breed a
"dangerous situation," Amado said.
Rehn, the EU commissioner shepherding the talks, voiced concern
that the "political atmospherics" between Turkey and EU capitals are
damaging the entry process and said the EU needs to be fair to Turkey.
"At the same time, we need to be firm and emphasize conditionality
and that's why we encourage Turkey to relaunch the reform process
in full," Rehn said. As a sign of support for Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan's EU strategy, the European Commission's president,
Jose Barroso, will visit Turkey early next year, he said.
Hammering home a point he often makes in Brussels, Babacan said the
Turkish government's plans to upgrade the economy and enhance civil
rights won't be blown off course by the souring mood.
EU Subsidies
For example, Babacan said, today's start of talks on linking Turkey's
transport and energy networks to the European grid makes Turkey
eligible for EU subsidies to upgrade its infrastructure.
Babacan gave no timetable for meeting the EU's demand that Turkey
rewrite a section of the penal code that has been used to prosecute
authors who challenged the Turkish orthodoxy that that the World
War I massacre of Armenians by Ottoman Turks was not genocide. One
journalist convicted under the law, Hrant Dink, was later murdered
by a teenage nationalist.
Divided Cyprus
The status of Cyprus also remains an obstacle for Turkey. Turkey's
military has occupied the northern part of the Mediterranean island
since a 1974 invasion in response to a Greek-backed coup.
The dividing line hardened in 2004, when Greek-speaking Cypriots
rejected a unification proposal that had the backing of the Turkish
side. As a result, Cyprus joined the EU without the Turkish-speaking
north of the island, which remains fenced off in the only disputed
border in the EU.
Skirmishes between the Turkish army and Kurdish rebels operating out
of northern Iraq played no role in today's talks. The conflict with
the Kurds didn't come up and Babacan said Turkey isn't relying on
military force alone to pacify the border.
An EU statement yesterday called on the Turkish military to exercise
restraint, while acknowledging Turkey's right to combat terrorists.
Turkish Daily News, Turkey
Dec 15 2007
Is the EU accession process completely blocked?
Saturday, December 15, 2007
İlter TÜRKMEN
Turkey reacted strongly against France's insistence to exclude the
words `accession' and `membership' from the paragraph related to
Turkey within the concluding statement of the European Union summit.
In order to block Turkey's way, Sarkozy had formerly asked for the
establishment of a Committee of Wise Men to determine the
geographical borders of the EU. He did not get his wish and had to be
satisfied with the formation of a think tank, whose agenda excluded
the EU borders and whose powers were limited to issues like energy,
environment and the fight against terror. Sarkozy had also caused the
suspension of the negotiations on five out of the 35 chapters that he
associated with Turkey's full membership.
Actually, this measure provided him with the opportunity to block
Turkey's membership for as long as he wanted to. The exclusion of the
word `accession' from the conclusion statement will achieves nothing
other than underlining his opposition against Turkey's membership and
provoking Turkey's indignation.
It's also important to know that there are those with a milder
approach toward Sarkozy's attitude. This is their point of view: It
would be better to evaluate the French president's current actions
from the angle of internal politics. The main objective of Sarkozy's
domestic strategy is to attract the votes of the radical right,
represented by the National Front. This angle would also serve to
explain his harsh policies against immigrants and Turkey.
When Turkey is in question, Sarkozy insists on excluding the word
`accession' from the conclusion statement, however, he does nothing
to prevent the opening of new chapters. It must be kept in mind that
as soon as he came to power, he sent his diplomatic consultant, who
enjoys more diplomatic power than the foreign affairs minister, to
assure Ankara that the Senate would be prevented from approving the
draft bill, which states that denying the `Armenian genocide' claims
will be considered a crime. Could people who defend this more
moderate approach be right? Only time will show.
Anyway, Turkey's EU membership process has been heavily encumbered
by the negotiations from the beginning. The French attitude is not
the only reason for that. The refusal to include Southern Cyprus in
the Customs Union has lead to the suspension of eight chapters, and
this issue is not likely to be solved very soon. Turkey is trying to
overcome this problem by establishing an extensive settlement process
in Cyprus and wants the United Nations general secretary to bring
back Greek Cyprus and the Turkish Republic of northern Cyprus to the
negotiation table. However, the general secretary has no intention to
initiate anything unless both sides prove their willingness to solve
the problem.
The Greek Cyprus elections to be held in February 2008 are not
likely to create a big change in the current political scene. Latest
developments seem to favor the co-existence of two independent states
as a solution to the present dilemma to such an extent that Greek
Cyprus is now worried that the probable independence of Kosovo will
constitute a precedent for Cyprus. The bistate formula will no doubt
be the ideal solution for northern Cyprus. However, Greek Cyprus has
no reason for concern. We shall not mark any progress towards that
solution until we change our present thinking pattern.
Other factors
This pessimistic picture includes other factors that effect the
negotiation process indirectly, like article 301 of the Turkish Penal
Code and the religious rights of the minorities. The EU Commission's
2007 Progress Report does not differ very much from the previous
ones, where these items are concerned. It especially stresses the
fact that the reform process has slowed down. The only positive
observation deals with the July 22 general elections and the
presidential elections.
The Commission believes that the election results prove the
existence of an active democracy in Turkey. It's a pity that we fail
to exploit this significant success.
Another major factor that has a negative effect on our relations
with the EU consists of the endless remarks against the EU pronounced
by public figures, who also influence the public opinion. How does it
help us to constantly blame the EU for our problems, while we ignore
our own mistakes? Does it relieve us of our responsibilities?
* The translation of İ.Türkmen's column was provided by Nuran
İnanç.
-----------
Copyright 2007, Turkish Daily News. This article is redistributed with
permission for personal use of Groong readers. No part of this article
may be reproduced, further distributed or archived without the prior
permission of the publisher. Contact Turkish Daily News Online at
http://www.TurkishDailyNews.com for details.
-----------
Dec 15 2007
Is the EU accession process completely blocked?
Saturday, December 15, 2007
İlter TÜRKMEN
Turkey reacted strongly against France's insistence to exclude the
words `accession' and `membership' from the paragraph related to
Turkey within the concluding statement of the European Union summit.
In order to block Turkey's way, Sarkozy had formerly asked for the
establishment of a Committee of Wise Men to determine the
geographical borders of the EU. He did not get his wish and had to be
satisfied with the formation of a think tank, whose agenda excluded
the EU borders and whose powers were limited to issues like energy,
environment and the fight against terror. Sarkozy had also caused the
suspension of the negotiations on five out of the 35 chapters that he
associated with Turkey's full membership.
Actually, this measure provided him with the opportunity to block
Turkey's membership for as long as he wanted to. The exclusion of the
word `accession' from the conclusion statement will achieves nothing
other than underlining his opposition against Turkey's membership and
provoking Turkey's indignation.
It's also important to know that there are those with a milder
approach toward Sarkozy's attitude. This is their point of view: It
would be better to evaluate the French president's current actions
from the angle of internal politics. The main objective of Sarkozy's
domestic strategy is to attract the votes of the radical right,
represented by the National Front. This angle would also serve to
explain his harsh policies against immigrants and Turkey.
When Turkey is in question, Sarkozy insists on excluding the word
`accession' from the conclusion statement, however, he does nothing
to prevent the opening of new chapters. It must be kept in mind that
as soon as he came to power, he sent his diplomatic consultant, who
enjoys more diplomatic power than the foreign affairs minister, to
assure Ankara that the Senate would be prevented from approving the
draft bill, which states that denying the `Armenian genocide' claims
will be considered a crime. Could people who defend this more
moderate approach be right? Only time will show.
Anyway, Turkey's EU membership process has been heavily encumbered
by the negotiations from the beginning. The French attitude is not
the only reason for that. The refusal to include Southern Cyprus in
the Customs Union has lead to the suspension of eight chapters, and
this issue is not likely to be solved very soon. Turkey is trying to
overcome this problem by establishing an extensive settlement process
in Cyprus and wants the United Nations general secretary to bring
back Greek Cyprus and the Turkish Republic of northern Cyprus to the
negotiation table. However, the general secretary has no intention to
initiate anything unless both sides prove their willingness to solve
the problem.
The Greek Cyprus elections to be held in February 2008 are not
likely to create a big change in the current political scene. Latest
developments seem to favor the co-existence of two independent states
as a solution to the present dilemma to such an extent that Greek
Cyprus is now worried that the probable independence of Kosovo will
constitute a precedent for Cyprus. The bistate formula will no doubt
be the ideal solution for northern Cyprus. However, Greek Cyprus has
no reason for concern. We shall not mark any progress towards that
solution until we change our present thinking pattern.
Other factors
This pessimistic picture includes other factors that effect the
negotiation process indirectly, like article 301 of the Turkish Penal
Code and the religious rights of the minorities. The EU Commission's
2007 Progress Report does not differ very much from the previous
ones, where these items are concerned. It especially stresses the
fact that the reform process has slowed down. The only positive
observation deals with the July 22 general elections and the
presidential elections.
The Commission believes that the election results prove the
existence of an active democracy in Turkey. It's a pity that we fail
to exploit this significant success.
Another major factor that has a negative effect on our relations
with the EU consists of the endless remarks against the EU pronounced
by public figures, who also influence the public opinion. How does it
help us to constantly blame the EU for our problems, while we ignore
our own mistakes? Does it relieve us of our responsibilities?
* The translation of İ.Türkmen's column was provided by Nuran
İnanç.
-----------
Copyright 2007, Turkish Daily News. This article is redistributed with
permission for personal use of Groong readers. No part of this article
may be reproduced, further distributed or archived without the prior
permission of the publisher. Contact Turkish Daily News Online at
http://www.TurkishDailyNews.com for details.
-----------
Comment