Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

[Armenian1]

Re: Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

Hi Crimson Glow
Like it or not she has very powerful voice and wide range in her voice. If you hear Armenian music she is quite unique in Armenia I can't think of anyone having similar voice. What do you mean by:
"Tradition is great and all, but we've got traditional music coming out the you know what. I think it's ok to start exploring new sounds, now." If you think Armenians ahould stop making or singing traditional songs then what should we sing. If we copy everything from the west what will we present in return I think singing non-traditional songs are important but if you want to be respected you must add something uniquely yours on that. Moreover Armenian traditional song is a style if you don't like it don't listen but saying that Armenians shouldn't make Armenian traditional songs that's wrong.

[Էլիա]

Re: Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

Բարեւ Էլիա ես զինք անձանբ չէի գիտեր ես Սուրիաէն չեմ: իմ ազգականս գիտէր իրեն: Աւելի ճիշդը իմ հօրաքդոջս ամուսինը: Այս պատմութիւնը ես իրմէ լսած եմ:

Ներողութիւն, բայց այս «փոստը» չտեսայ՝ անցեալ անգամ, որ հոս եկայ: Ես ալ կարծեցի, որ Նունէին գիտէիր կամ բան մը. շատ հետաքրքիր կ'ըլլար եթէ երգիչի մը հետ կը ծանօթանայիր...

Hi Crimson Glow
Like it or not she has very powerful voice and wide range in her voice. If you hear Armenian music she is quite unique in Armenia I can't think of anyone having similar voice. What do you mean by:
"Tradition is great and all, but we've got traditional music coming out the you know what. I think it's ok to start exploring new sounds, now." If you think Armenians ahould stop making or singing traditional songs then what should we sing. If we copy everything from the west what will we present in return I think singing non-traditional songs are important but if you want to be respected you must add something uniquely yours on that. Moreover Armenian traditional song is a style if you don't like it don't listen but saying that Armenians shouldn't make Armenian traditional songs that's wrong.

Ինչպէս ըսի անցեալ «փոստիս» մէջ, ես պիտի փորձեմ նոր հայ աւանդական / ազգասիրական երգ մը շինել, բայց եթէ նոյնիսկ շինեմ՝ չեմ կարծեր իրական աւանդական կամ ազգասիրական երգ մը կը նկատուի: :-/

[Crimson Glow]

Re: Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

Hi Crimson Glow
Like it or not she has very powerful voice and wide range in her voice.

Ah, yes. A very compelling argument.....

What do you mean by:
If you think Armenians ahould stop making or singing traditional songs then what should we sing.

Ummm.....new songs?

If we copy everything from the west what will we present in return I think singing non-traditional songs are important but if you want to be respected you must add something uniquely yours on that.

Who said anything about copying the West? Where did that comment even come from? There are only so many different ways you can do the same song over....and over.....and over, and over and over again. I'd just like to see some unique, grand-breaking Armenian artists for a change, and you can't be unique and grand breaking by repeating severely overused traditional songs, OR copying the West. Use your imagination a little.

Moreover Armenian traditional song is a style if you don't like it don't listen but saying that Armenians shouldn't make Armenian traditional songs that's wrong.

Re-read what I wrote. At no point did I say stop making traditional music. What I was getting at is that we need more true artists, and less of this tired, "Hi. I'm going to take songs that have been done a thousand times over, and re-do them in a weak attempt at a 'pop-version'" crap. These are cheap attempts at becoming famous, because the singer knows it will rile up ethnic/nationalist pride, and will rally the people around him/her. It's a sure-fire formula, not unlike the wests "boy band" garbage.


The original poster said he/she thinks Nune is one of the greatest Armenian singers. I simply stated why I feel she is not. Relax, Armenian1. There will be people with dissenting opinions from yours. It's no reason to get defensive. At the very last, don't make straw man arguments to defend your point of view.

[Էլիա]

Re: Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

The original poster said he/she thinks Nune is one of the greatest Armenian singers. I simply stated why I feel she is not.

Yay, I'm the original poster! Anyway, I understand your point of view, Crimson Glow, but are you sure there isn't even one song that Nune made up herself!? I'm not a super-duper Nune fan, so I'm not really sure about the answer to that question, so please tell me if you know.

[Armenian1]

Re: Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

Just for the record I'm not "super duper" nune fan I'm not "super duper" fan of anyone at all. But I think it is a fact I have heard from experts about her voice they say it is big powerful voice if this is compelling argument for you or not it's your problem. In the end you don't need 2 people argueing about milk being white but one doesn't like milk others do.
By the way I'm very cool I'm just expressing my point of view at the end we are thalking about music for God sake.
In my post by the word Traditional I was talking about the style not the old songs that have been composed in the past I'm talking about Armenian folk style known as Armenian Traditional songs with Duduk Davour Zourna...etc. For example there is Hamlet Gevorgian who sings Traditional songs NOT old songs.
Comeing back to Nune in her albums she has new songs with old ones. There are songs that she herself has written it. You are right the exsess of old songs isn't nice but it is good to have 1 or 2 old songs made modern. I can't see why it is catastophy for you if the new virsion is nice to listen.

[Էլիա]

Re: Nune Yesayan (Նունէ Եսաեան)

Just for the record I'm not "super duper" nune fan I'm not "super duper" fan of anyone at all. But I think it is a fact I have heard from experts about her voice they say it is big powerful voice if this is compelling argument for you or not it's your problem. In the end you don't need 2 people argueing about milk being white but one doesn't like milk others do.
By the way I'm very cool I'm just expressing my point of view at the end we are thalking about music for God sake.
In my post by the word Traditional I was talking about the style not the old songs that have been composed in the past I'm talking about Armenian folk style known as Armenian Traditional songs with Duduk Davour Zourna...etc. For example there is Hamlet Gevorgian who sings Traditional songs NOT old songs.
Comeing back to Nune in her albums she has new songs with old ones. There are songs that she herself has written it. You are right the exsess of old songs isn't nice but it is good to have 1 or 2 old songs made modern. I can't see why it is catastophy for you if the new virsion is nice to listen.

Լաւ, լաւ, հիմա հոս չենք՝ «Crimson Glow»ին համոզելու որ մէկ երգիչ մը աւելի լաւ է ուրիշէ մը: Իմ կարծիքովս, ես կը սիրեմ Նունէին աւանդական եւ ազգասիրական երգերը, բայց ասիկա ըսել չէ, որ չեմ ուզեր ինքը նոր երգեր շինէ՝ մեր հին, սիերլի երգերուն եղանակներով կամ ոճերով: