Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

My interesting philosophy...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #51
    Re: My interesting philosophy...

    I was discussing the issue of morality with someone else the other day. We read "Heart of Darkness" (by Joseph Conrad), if you wanted to get an idea of how the discussion comes about; great read, pretty... intense... though.

    She argued, as you are, that morality is subjective.

    I counter-argued, it seems more coincidental, and frankly, like certain "morals" take precedent over other ones.


    To demonstrate my point,
    In the book, there was a moment when "Marlow" had to meet the fiance of recently deceased "Mr. Kurtz". "Marlow" was with "Mr. Kurtz" when he died. The fiance asked "Marlow" what his last words were, certain that it would be regarding her. The truth was, Mr. Kurtz' last words were: "The horror! the horror!"; but "Marlow" told the fiance, "he said your name."

    Was he right to hide the truth; especially since he thinks it's immoral to lie? Or was it moral (because he believes that women live in their "own little world," shielded by the nightmares, and thus decided to protect her)?

    Comment


    • #52
      Re: My interesting philosophy...

      Originally posted by Tali View Post
      I was discussing the issue of morality with someone else the other day. We read "Heart of Darkness" (by Joseph Conrad), if you wanted to get an idea of how the discussion comes about; great read, pretty... intense... though.

      She argued, as you are, that morality is subjective.

      I counter-argued, it seems more coincidental, and frankly, like certain "morals" take precedent over other ones.


      To demonstrate my point,
      In the book, there was a moment when "Marlow" had to meet the fiance of recently deceased "Mr. Kurtz". "Marlow" was with "Mr. Kurtz" when he died. The fiance asked "Marlow" what his last words were, certain that it would be regarding her. The truth was, Mr. Kurtz' last words were: "The horror! the horror!"; but "Marlow" told the fiance, "he said your name."

      Was he right to hide the truth; especially since he thinks it's immoral to lie? Or was it moral (because he believes that women live in their "own little world," shielded by the nightmares, and thus decided to protect her)?

      That is a great book. I read it when I was in high school, along with a few other books by Conrad. He is a great author.

      And I didn't argue that morality is subjective, and think it is the opposite.
      For the first time in more than 600 years, Armenia is free and independent, and we are therefore obligated
      to place our national interests ahead of our personal gains or aspirations.



      http://www.armenianhighland.com/main.html

      Comment


      • #53
        Re: My interesting philosophy...

        Oh, geez. D'oh!! You made it so succinctly obvious, too. Sorry, Armanen... maybe that is a good sign I need to sleep. School has finally kicked me over to nonsensical. Too many exams today, now I can't even read...

        Comment

        Working...
        X