Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Please Sign This Petition: Özür diliyoruz

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • bell-the-cat
    replied
    Originally posted by Gavur View Post
    Your problem is ,you want to follow but you find it difficult,you want to lead but find your self unprapered and to stand by and watch is exhausting,so what to do.What to do?
    Emigrate and live in the diaspora. There you can comment on anything in complete safety and (being free from having the possiblility of doing anything practical) you don't even need to leave the comfort of your armchair. No difficulties; no preparation; no exhaustion - problem solved!

    Leave a comment:


  • Sako
    replied
    I'll join Joseph in saying welcome livefromistanbu and I'm happy to know you signed the petition and hope everything ends well there. Thanks for being considerate as well, it's Turks like you that can make a difference, which you already did.

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Originally posted by Joseph View Post
    On the surface everyone is friendly...as long as you keep silent and never complain.
    I think it is the main difference between totalitarianism and authoritarianism.

    In totalitarian states, you can see the hostility directly. It is like a smell in the air.

    But in authoritarian states, like Turkey now since 1950 (before that it was totalitarian), everything seems normal; for example for a tourist. But in deep, you face the dark side.

    Leave a comment:


  • Joseph
    replied
    Originally posted by livefromistanbu View Post
    hello from istanbul,

    first of all let me note how much I was impressed by the overall decency of the messages on this thread - thank you all.

    I'm Turkish, raised in a predominantly secular environment even though officially I'm tagged as Muslim. well - it had been quite a while that I concluded that religion wasn't something for me (put as mildly as possible - no offense for believers) though.

    I have signed the petition and I have one good reason for that. I remember asking my Armenian friend from university -Kirkor- in my -among friends- well known direct style (sometimes a bit offensive I'm afraid) whether or not he was thinking that a genocide or the big catastrophe or the massacre took place. He gave me the turmoil times xxxx; an answer that he had prepared and was apperantly reusing everytime to soothe the turkish conscience. what stroke me though was the tiniest trembling I caught in his voice. I am a pretty open minded person so I was sure that Kirkor wouldn't fear my response upon his real answer. But I guess, he couldn't live out of it. His sincere thoughts were left behind a curtain and I doubt that he was daring to take those thoughts out into light even for himself. Then I started to think - not about the history but about the trembling in his voice.

    I realized that the racism in Turkey was lived in a very passive-aggresive way. On the surface we are wonderful people who love to help especially foreigners. It is very evident on your visits to Turkey. People are very friendly, compassionate and helpful but we are behind the curtains quite racist.

    This does not make however turkish mean are worse than any other nation or ethnicity. Every culture shows discriminative characteristics. It's in our dna - an instinct for survival. It only shows that we are human. just like anyone reading this post. there is a song by sezen aksu that I like very much. the lyrics goes like: "masum degiliz hicbirimiz". "non of us are innocent."

    then I was freed. to call it genocide or not was just a detail and a useless discussion. some people who shared the same culture i inherited had failed as human beings. this was what really mattered.

    so i'm sorry for the trembling in Kirkor's voice. I'm sorry because mine, my friends' and my family's passive aggresive acceptance of the status quo has made him live in such a repressive atmosphere. and unlike the things that had happened some 90 years ago, i was directly responsible about it. It needed an apology - and i signed the petition.

    now some of you will think that i have freed myself from the brain washer apparatus of the state. maybe true but we have to remind ourselves that most of us are products of such apparatuses.

    sorry for the disorganised message. but i have to leave now.

    in the hope of a borderless world.
    Welcome! Hosgeldiniz


    You hit on a very point, one which I can attest to as well since my wife's family still lives in Turkey. The situation for Armenians in Turkey is not an easy one. On the surface everyone is friendly...as long as you keep silent and never complain.

    Leave a comment:


  • livefromistanbu
    Guest replied
    hello friends

    hello from istanbul,

    first of all let me note how much I was impressed by the overall decency of the messages on this thread - thank you all.

    I'm Turkish, raised in a predominantly secular environment even though officially I'm tagged as Muslim. well - it had been quite a while that I concluded that religion wasn't something for me (put as mildly as possible - no offense for believers) though.

    I have signed the petition and I have one good reason for that. I remember asking my Armenian friend from university -Kirkor- in my -among friends- well known direct style (sometimes a bit offensive I'm afraid) whether or not he was thinking that a genocide or the big catastrophe or the massacre took place. He gave me the turmoil times xxxx; an answer that he had prepared and was apperantly reusing everytime to soothe the turkish conscience. what stroke me though was the tiniest trembling I caught in his voice. I am a pretty open minded person so I was sure that Kirkor wouldn't fear my response upon his real answer. But I guess, he couldn't live out of it. His sincere thoughts were left behind a curtain and I doubt that he was daring to take those thoughts out into light even for himself. Then I started to think - not about the history but about the trembling in his voice.

    I realized that the racism in Turkey was lived in a very passive-aggresive way. On the surface we are wonderful people who love to help especially foreigners. It is very evident on your visits to Turkey. People are very friendly, compassionate and helpful but we are behind the curtains quite racist.

    This does not make however turkish mean are worse than any other nation or ethnicity. Every culture shows discriminative characteristics. It's in our dna - an instinct for survival. It only shows that we are human. just like anyone reading this post. there is a song by sezen aksu that I like very much. the lyrics goes like: "masum degiliz hicbirimiz". "non of us are innocent."

    then I was freed. to call it genocide or not was just a detail and a useless discussion. some people who shared the same culture i inherited had failed as human beings. this was what really mattered.

    so i'm sorry for the trembling in Kirkor's voice. I'm sorry because mine, my friends' and my family's passive aggresive acceptance of the status quo has made him live in such a repressive atmosphere. and unlike the things that had happened some 90 years ago, i was directly responsible about it. It needed an apology - and i signed the petition.

    now some of you will think that i have freed myself from the brain washer apparatus of the state. maybe true but we have to remind ourselves that most of us are products of such apparatuses.

    sorry for the disorganised message. but i have to leave now.

    in the hope of a borderless world.

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Originally posted by lal
    especially ı cant respect to mr arda . ı do not consider turks fight for independence as a make up story. ı cant criticize great ataturk as genocider or dictator. ı mean everybody was dictator in those years. you dont think todays poitics.
    I am sorry, but it is typical Kemalist response lal.

    "Everybody was dictator in that time". This argument is absolutely out of base.

    Let me explain:

    1. You accept Kemal is a dictator but you legalize it saying "everybody do that".

    2. OK, that's true. In those times (1914-40) there are 24 dictatorship in all over the world, very similar to Kemalist one. But: Today, every of them collapsed and criticized. But Kemalism is still alive.

    3. So-called war indeoendence is not totally invented. But lal, ok, more simple, let us talk about numbers and let us see Kemalists didnot fight against "enemies" but fighted against their people.

    According to General Staff (Genelkurmay in Turkish) statistics, in whole "War of Independence", 9200 Turkish soliders died.

    But in only Independence Courts (Istiklal Mahkemeleri in Turkish), 9000 people hanged. Can you imagine? Do you see who is the enemy of Kemalists?

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Originally posted by berkopath View Post
    You may disagree with mr.arda in many aspects. But please do not classify him with your thoughts. Arda is not insulting to anyone as far as I read his comments in the forum. Maybe he dislikes Ataturk and he may freely express his dislike with any comment against him. Why should this create any discomfort in you? I respect Ataturk with his leadership and personally I also like "some" of his personal features. There also things that I strongly oppose to him. But ok I mean. This is me. And I don t give anything to anyone's thoughts about him. Why should I? If you say, do you think like the same if anyone here would insult Ataturk, then I would just leave this case to the insulter him/herself. Anyone can be also offensive against him since the benefits that Ataturk gained for Turkey was the natural losses for others. This is how it is. He was a real enemy for a serious majority of people in our region. And if I were them, I would also be without today's thoughts of mine. The important thing here is that not to darken these days with the thoughts that we have about the people of the past. Let s simplify the case with Ataturk. You like Fenerbahce (do you by the way? ) and Arda does not...It "must" be as simple as this. If you say that it can't, then yes dear..We have to divide apart. Because there would be no room for us to live together here with all these millionated differential of thoughts.
    I wish that burdened subject would be so simple as supporting a football team.

    It is breaking a chain whose shadow darkens our mind for a century; Ittihadist-Kemalist tradition.

    Please look at Turkey in 1908, and now. A complete century!

    Leave a comment:


  • Sako
    replied
    Arda, try to say what you say as simply as possible, Lal doesn't know really good English and I don't say that in a bad way Lal, I just want us to understand each other better. I'm starting to simplify my already simple posts as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Originally posted by No Pasaran View Post
    Kemalism is not ideology and also i am not a anti-kemalist too.
    This argument is also a Kemalist argument in order to avoid the discussion.

    Whenever you propose, for example, "Kemalism is...", they reply "No, Kemalism is not a rigid ideology. It is a doctrine of pro-science, pro-rationality and modernism. It is so flexible in order to fit present civilization level".

    Please see the writings of Mahmut Esat xxxkurt (Justice Minister of Kemal), Recep Peker (General Secretary of Kemal) and Tekin Alp (aka Moiz Cohen, ideologue of Kemalism).

    So you see, i never refer to anti-Kemalist writers like Nuri Dersimi, İsmail Beşikçi or Abdurrahman Dilipak.

    Have a look on original Kemalist resources and see it is so similar to Mussolini's fascism. Only much more bloodier than Italian one.

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Originally posted by lal View Post
    but , on the other hand, ı really dont like to be considered in the same side with people like mr arda. ı mean he wants turkey to be divided into many pieces,not only kurdistan, he wants turkey to accept many other genocides,he doesnt respect ataturk,he can ally with islamists , he is emberrased by our national fights,etc.so, ı dont understand them at all either. and ı dont want to be considered the same with these people.
    How superficial consideration lal!

    I am sorry but these considerations are really contamined by Kemalism. Let me try to explain:

    1. Division of Turkey
    - Division of Turkey is not necessity. But, although nation as a political entity is an imaginery and constructed notion, i defend self-determination right of people. So, i defend "voluntarily integration". However, first aim should be the destruction of Turkish oppresion and persecution. After that, two nations can be integrated in terms of state but if Kurdish people doesnot want this solution, they have right to have their own independence. If Kemal didnot deceive Kurdish people, we wouldnt discuss this issue. Shortly: Kemal promised Kurdish notables a federation but after he took the power, started massacres and denied their identity. Please see Amasya Protocols, El-Cezire Cephesi Kumandanlığına Emir or Izmit Sohbetleri. You will see the whole story.

    2. Kurdistan
    - Kurdistan is a geographical naming. As Kemalist state and contamined-Turks supposed, it is not necessarily political. Kurdistan is where Kurds live. So simple!

    3. "Other Genocides"
    - If you are fair, not only AG, but Assyrian Genocide, Greek Genocide and Dersim Genocide should be accepted. If you mention confrontation of past, how can you recognize one and deny others?

    If your argument is "They killed us we killed them", please remember that this is Turkish denial system works so. And please remember that Greek expulsion started in 1912, when nothing happened.

    "War between two nations" argument is also used in AG denial. It is true that some Armenian bands attacked Turk and Kurd villages. But when? When you look at attack dates, you will see they all are in 1918 and after. Shouldnot we condemn that since they happened after Genocide as revenge acts? I think no, they were also atrocities but not Genocide.

    4. Respect for Kemal
    - I mentioned this. I cant have any kind of respect to a bloody dictator. In my opinion, he has no difference from Talat or Enver. Just foxier than them.

    5. Ally with Islamist
    - Of course i can. What's wrong with it? When your Kemalists call for an army coup d'etat, those some honest Islamists blame army murders in Hakkari, Kurdistan. Remaining their and my view conserved, i can ally my people's representatives. Their criticism on Kemalism are right in many aspects.

    6. Shame for your national fights
    - If you imply so-called War of Independence, Turco-Greek war namely, i am not ashamed for this. But if you try to abuse this war in order to legalize Kemalist dictatorship, please stop here. I am asshamed for that Turkish troops burnt beatiful Smirna and ashamed for the atrocities of Greek troops. But i feel honour for the communist Greek soldiers who objected to fight in Anatolia as an invader power.

    You told "ı dont understand them at all either". Which point didnt you understand?

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X