Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Please Sign This Petition: Özür diliyoruz

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • hipeter924
    replied
    Originally posted by ardakilic View Post
    Actually, i suppose it is different from what you told qualitatively. It is not a war of "bellum omnium contra omnes" in the level of minorities.
    Okay, well I will put it this way. Minority groups in the Ottoman Empire, after the conquest of the Eastern Roman/Byzantine Empire fought for influence, this ended in bloodshed and sometimes it was resolved, but overall there was mostly bloodshed.

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Originally posted by hipeter924 View Post
    Well really the Ottoman Empire was a horrific time for everyone, all the minority groups were fighting and killing each other, the Turkish government favored the Kurds above the other minorities. Now the Turkish government has finally turned against the Kurds as well.
    Actually, i suppose it is different from what you told qualitatively. It is not a war of "bellum omnium contra omnes" in the level of minorities.

    Leave a comment:


  • hipeter924
    replied
    Originally posted by Saco View Post
    I'm starting to remember the movie "Gangs of New York", lol, after reading what you said.
    Yeah but the Ottoman Empire really was like that, but saying that an Empire itself is a bad thing, as in Empire's there are racial groups oppressing another racial groups.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sako
    replied
    I'm starting to remember the movie "Gangs of New York", lol, after reading what you said Peter.

    Leave a comment:


  • hipeter924
    replied
    Originally posted by chinchilla View Post
    Hah. Has anyone else noticed that the only time Turks seem to care about Kurds is when 1915 comes up? Yet many Kurds seem to have apologized for what happened to the Armenians (some even acknowledging Kurdish responsibility), so it's sort of contradictory.

    This is obviously written with a core audience in mind - Turks, who throughout history have apparently been engaged in a battle with imperialists and the evil West. Don't believe me? It's in their national anthem.

    Oh, and LOL, Peter Gabriel? I'm loving this!
    Well really the Ottoman Empire was a horrific time for everyone, all the minority groups were fighting and killing each other, the Turkish government favored the Kurds above the other minorities. Now the Turkish government has finally turned against the Kurds as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • chinchilla
    replied
    Hmm. Bulent Kenes now conveniently recalls a tragedy experienced by his grandmother and grandfather. The Turkish people have apparently bottled up this attempted genocide against them, and only like to bring it up when Armenians are mentioned! Perhaps he should demand reparations!

    Oh, Bulent. You couldn't help but use this classic quibble, could you: "Moreover, if the Turks had intended to commit systematic genocide on the Armenian people, they would have done it easily, at the time when their power was at its peak."

    I think we're going to be seeing more of these tit for tat arguments.

    Article at Today's Zaman: http://todayszaman.com/tz-web/yazarD...haberno=161457

    BTW-This may be the first time I have come across two articles from Turkish columnists with a total absence or reference to the "world Armenian lobby."

    Leave a comment:


  • chinchilla
    replied
    He's trying to stir trouble with the "foreign influence" tripe.

    I think he has a problem with apologizing in general. He's obviously hinting to the Holocaust when he refers to Germany.

    Hah. Has anyone else noticed that the only time Turks seem to care about Kurds is when 1915 comes up? Yet many Kurds seem to have apologized for what happened to the Armenians (some even acknowledging Kurdish responsibility), so it's sort of contradictory.

    This is obviously written with a core audience in mind - Turks, who throughout history have apparently been engaged in a battle with imperialists and the evil West. Don't believe me? It's in their national anthem.

    Oh, and LOL, Peter Gabriel? I'm loving this!

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    Ertugrul Ozkok: The apology campaign for Armenians is a joke

    At last I am relieved. Peter Gabriel, a singer I enjoyed very much during his "Genesis" days, but whose ethnic obsession I find it difficult to understand, has joined the campaign "to apologize to Armenians".

    He apologizes on behalf of us, "Turks", to the Armenians for the bad things that "we Turks" did to the Armenians.

    I was considering whether to join the campaign or not. I was relieved when I read the news about Gabriel.

    Since he apologizes to the Armenians on our behalf, Turks, then I apologize to the Indians, the Pakistanis and to the indigenous people of former colonies in the Far East on behalf of the "Brits".

    For the bad things that "those Brits" did to these people.

    The formula for the historic solution of the Armenian issue has been found. People from different countries apologize to the people of some other country for the bad things that another country did to them.

    In addition the country's parliaments have been taking over the authority of "rewriting history" or vice a versa for the bad things that one country did to some other nation.

    In that case, for us, as Turks there is no problem. As for the Armenians; we now have a chance to solve this problem via proxies.


    * * *

    Let's leave aside the amusing aspect of it. I consider this "apology campaign" started by some Turkish intellectuals as a huge joke.

    The text they had prepared is wonderful!

    Now I am waiting with some trepidation to see just how many Turks join the most romantic campaign in the history. A million people? Maybe two, three, five million?

    What if the number of people who sign does not reach the 47 percent that presents the national will?

    Think about it: "The national will definitely does not apologize..."

    We would be disgraced in eyes of Armenians.

    * * *

    Since Peter Gabriel has joined, I think we should place on the table all the issues that need apologizing for.

    For example, who is going to apologize for the Turkish diplomats murdered by the ASALA terror organization?

    We should find people from other countries since no Armenian, either from Armenia or the diaspora has come forward to do that.

    I propose an appeal to Mick Jagger. He will sign it for sure.

    We should knock on Germany’s door to get apologizes for the Turks and Kurds who were slaughtered by the Armenian gangs in 1915, but the Germans have another apology issue to deal with.

    What about the Turkish civilians who were killed in Thessaloniki during the Balkan Wars, despite the fact they had laid down their weapons.

    Who is going to apologize of their behalf?

    Do you think a Canadian might do it?

    Leonard Cohen, for example.

    No he won't - since he loves the Greeks and lived on a Greek island for years.

    Maybe it would be possible to find someone from Asia.

    Let me warn you: It is easy to find someone who would come down hard on Turks but it is not so easy to find someone who to apologize for the Turks that were slaughtered.

    * * *

    Still it is a good thing to have a few Turkish intellectuals who would apologize on behalf of Turks.

    In the future we will stand up in front of the whole world and say "Look, we have people who apologize. But there is not even one representative from them."

    I sincerely support this campaign only to say that.

    And I promise to give my full backing, as Peter Gabriel has done, to signature campaigns that are launched for the all bad things that the Brits and French have done.

    I flied into rage! He is mocking. There was a lyric of the song Mr Jack, System of A Down: xxxx YOU PIG!

    Leave a comment:


  • ardakilic
    replied
    [Turkish PM says apology campaign to Armenians unacceptable

    It is unacceptable to affirm support to the recent internet campaign launched to issue a public apology to Armenians, Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan told reporters on Wednesday. (UPDATED)

    Around 200 Turkish academics, writers and journalists launched a website issuing an apology to the Armenians regarding the 1915 incidents and calling for people to sign on in support.

    The efforts of the intellectuals drew fierce reaction in Turkey.

    "I got difficulty to understand these writers. I neither accept nor support this campaign. We did not commit a crime, therefore we do not need to apologize," Erdogan said, adding the issue is still being discussed by historians.

    He said such initiatives only reverse the positive steps taken by Turkey.

    Armenia, with the backing of the diaspora, claims up to 1.5 million of their kin were slaughtered in orchestrated killings in 1915.Turkey rejects the claims saying that 300,000 Armenians, along with at least as many Turks, died in civil strife that emerged when Armenians took up arms, backed by Russia, for independence in eastern Anatolia.

    The issue remains unsolved as Armenia drags its feet on accepting Turkey's proposal to form a an independent commission to investigate the claims.

    Hurriyet Daily News, 17/12/2008

    Leave a comment:


  • Alexandros
    replied
    Originally posted by ardakilic View Post
    Now i try to make some Arabic intellectuals participate the campaign in Syria. It will be better comrade!
    Evet kardes!

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X