Originally posted by lal
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Please Sign This Petition: Özür diliyoruz
Collapse
X
-
However, their killers did not kill them because they were AG deniers (or even because they were Turks), but because they were representatives of the Turkish state. ASALA considered itself to be at war with Turkey, a state which had committeed genocide and was occupying the Armenian homeland, and so it considered Turkish diplomats to be legitimate targets. I'm not sure how much of it even had to do with AG recognition.
-
What do you all think about what Ayşe Hür has said about the petition? I think she might be right.
According to “Zaman,” some Turkish civil society representatives were quick to object to the campaign. “For me, all these events [of 1915] were the fault of Turkish nationalism flourishing at that time, and personally I don’t identify with it,” historian Ayse Hur told the paper. “So I do not feel the need to apologize personally.”
Link - http://www.huliq.com/1/74137/intelle...great-disaster
Leave a comment:
-
I have no doubt about your good feelings, i got your point.Originally posted by lal View Postyes ı understand you this time. but again , dont you think that some positive messeges must come from the other side. ı mean not for you and me,but for the rest great majority of turkey. wouldnt that help a little? you know ı love armenians, ı only want to be friends again.
Of course it can help. But if you are not ready to take the message, there will be nothing to do.
And important remark, at least for me: This is not a case of equaliztion. This is not mathematic.
Leave a comment:
-
yes ı understand you this time. but again , dont you think that some positive messeges must come from the other side. ı mean not for you and me,but for the rest great majority of turkey. wouldnt that help a little? you know ı love armenians, ı only want to be friends again.Originally posted by ardakilic View PostDont you compare different things?
I wish i could explain something in Turkish; it would be easier. Anyway, as you know very well, there is a "testimonial culture" in Turkey. What do i mean?
For example, if you start speaking in Turkish state's crimes in Kurdistan, you have to start speaking like "I also condemn PKK terror but ....". This is testimonial culture. You dont have to mention PKK to condemn Turkish state's crimes in Kurd cities. These are totally different things. This is not legalization of terror.
Now, could i tell my point?
Leave a comment:
-
Dont you compare different things?Originally posted by lal View Postno it is not clear enough.
armenians or armenia not need to apologise for anything. they only need to declare that they did not support asala terrorizm whatever the reason was.
ı mean if armenians say that it was nice to kill 55 AG deniers and this terror helped the world to hear them, ı dont think they can expect anything from turkey.
I wish i could explain something in Turkish; it would be easier. Anyway, as you know very well, there is a "testimonial culture" in Turkey. What do i mean?
For example, if you start speaking in Turkish state's crimes in Kurdistan, you have to start speaking like "I also condemn PKK terror but ....". This is testimonial culture. You dont have to mention PKK to condemn Turkish state's crimes in Kurd cities. These are totally different things. This is not legalization of terror.
Now, could i tell my point?
Leave a comment:
-
no it is not clear enough.Originally posted by ardakilic View PostNo, although i am a mathematician, dead bodies are not calculated and counted.
What i mean is there is no direct connection between ASALA and Armenian state. Thus, if somebody will apologize, this has to be ASALA, if still exists.
But Genocide proceeded by Ittihadist state and Kemalist Turkish Republic is the successor of it. So, if somebody will apologize, it is Turkey Republic.
I think it is clear enough.
armenians or armenia not need to apologise for anything. they only need to declare that they did not support asala terrorizm whatever the reason was.
ı mean if armenians say that it was nice to kill 55 AG deniers and this terror helped the world to hear them, ı dont think they can expect anything from turkey.
Leave a comment:
-
No, although i am a mathematician, dead bodies are not calculated and counted.Originally posted by lal View Postindividually you may think the way you want to. so you make a calculation and say 1 million minus 50 = 950,000 people armenians.
but if you think from the mass pscology point of view, yes those 50 or so asala murders are extremely important.and a declaration by armenia republic cursing them is also needed.
if to acception of the genocide by some people like us, is enough, we need not to talk anytyhing else. if we want more people to accept the reality, if we want friendly two or three countries in this geography, yes we need some move from armenians also.
but like vahe says, if it is not much important that turkey and armenia be friends in state levels,closed borders are not vital,than its fine, we dont need any moves.
but these are politics. even if today armenians totally declare war on turkey, nothing about history can change.still we owe this apology.
What i mean is there is no direct connection between ASALA and Armenian state. Thus, if somebody will apologize, this has to be ASALA, if still exists.
But Genocide proceeded by Ittihadist state and Kemalist Turkish Republic is the successor of it. So, if somebody will apologize, it is Turkey Republic.
I think it is clear enough.
Leave a comment:



Leave a comment: