Re: What religion are you?
Just trying my best, bro, just trying my best, glad we’re finally on a different level of conversation. See? I told you, nothing happens without a reason. We argued but it led us to something better, at least it is to me, I’ll talk only about myself but I’m sure you feel the same from your words. I appreciate it too.
Well, first of all, please don’t say “someone like you”, I’m not really that special or anything and I don’t consider myself “above” anyone on this forum or in the world really. I’m just a ripple in the ocean, plainly speaking. Going back to your question, J, I’ll tell you about me soon enough although I think I’ll work on understanding your views right now since we started already and then I’ll start a new topic because I know my story will do just that.
Going back to religion, I ask that you read everything I say, looking at everything in different ways and not taking anything personally, my friend. That way we’ll definitely understand much more. I take it you haven’t really seriously gone through any religion so let’s accept that fact and let’s not mock religion in any way throughout the duration of this discussion otherwise it will make things more complicated. Let’s try and look out of the box whether we believe in God or not and not ask the stupid question whether God exists or not, it’s a childish argument and in the end nothing changes anyways.
My first answer to your question is that religion is a learning institution, like I said before and in school, you don’t always do what you like but what you are supposed to and in the end you understand why you had to go through it all. In your paragraph, you still didn’t say why you don’t like religion as a whole or a particular one which you should because you said that a nice religion to you must bring a happy transformation, etc. Moving on, when I went to art class, I used to draw circles and squares and I never understood why or how these shapes could turn into a beautiful painting or figure but they did in the end and I understood, never asking that question again. Religion is not something created by man and even if it was, it is on a much higher plain materially and spiritually for the simple fact that it has a very powerful impact on our lives and it changes people and this world. Religion is not the same school you go to, it is very different. There, you get the experience and then the lessons in many cases. Religion is just like life and not everything in life is sweet but when you understand that whatever happens, happens so that you can learn something and because you are moving forward instead of going back. You can’t sit down and move forward without endeavor.
That’s why, my second answer is that when you look at spirituality or religion, don’t consider your senses or your skin first. Happiness comes from endeavor, it doesn’t grow on trees, and endeavor comes from understanding, which in turn comes from your mind and heart. Religion doesn’t open your mind; it opens your heart first which is the most difficult process in life. If your heart is not open, your mind never will be and it will be your worst enemy, confusing you and taking you away from the light.
My third answer is as follows. When you say “finding a particular religion”, I want you to understand the meaning of religion first. In school, you learn math but you can learn the same math in any other school just maybe in a slightly different way with slightly different teachers, at a slower or faster pace, but the goal is still the same. You know why there are different religions? What the point of that grand plan is? Because there are so many different people in the world with different views, with different problems, with different limitations, etc. The goal of religion is not to make you see God or something, it’s to prepare you. If you pass 3rd grade, you still have a long way to go, bro, you aren’t there yet. Just something I would like to point out real quick is that statistics show that believers in God seem to live much more peaceful, happy lives then those that don’t. I have even compared two different people I knew with different views and the difference was incredible. The one that didn’t believe in God seemed completely lost and unhappy; making everyone else unhappy while the believer was a completely different story (I’m not saying all are happy or unhappy). So, even if religion was created by man, lol, I am grateful eternally to that man. In this case, we should take into account NOT where or how Religion was created but what impact it has on our lives for the simple fact that NO ONE can prove religion was created by man or God doesn’t exist. Religion has the power to change the world and it is so let’s not laugh at religion as if some idiot created it or it was a mistake and everyone just suddenly people began to follow it like morons. It has always been there.
My point, going back to my original view (don’t think about your skin first) is that don’t look for a religion with the thought of finding one that will fit into your schedule, YOU have to fit into religion, not the other way around because there is good and bad everywhere BUT remember, religion is never mistaken, its followers are. In school, the school teaches perfectly but the students and/or teachers make it a good famous school or an infamous school. NEVERTHELESS, you should respect all religions and go with the religion you feel very close to and feel you can understand better or feel closer to God or to your own heart. You aren’t at school because of the students, you are there to learn. There is no ONE RIGHT PATH in this world and I hate it when preachers try to prove other religions wrong and that their religion is the very best or even worse, is the only right path. When there weren’t the religions we know now, people still believed in God, they didn’t live in emptiness until preachers appeared. They have always been around too though and I don’t have anything against them. They sometimes go too far though. Last but not least, do anything you do with your heart and not with force but sometimes you have to control yourself and try hard. Religion is not a very easy task and people shy away. Endeavor and understanding spells and equals sacrifice. Be prepared although don’t be afraid, it’s not a daunting task. People spend so much more energy on material activities but are afraid to follow simple guidelines that take away almost only 5-10% of the energy spent overall. Man complicates things too much sometimes. Let’s not make religion comfortable for us but get comfortable with a religion. Many Christians out there don’t follow half of what Jesus say’s, those people manipulate the religion instead of working on themselves for the religion.
You basically say that you go to school but don’t accept the teacher’s words. I don’t know what religion you’re talking about or why you do this but it’s not particularly wrong but it’s a way of making a religion more comforting for you which is not exactly right but is right in its own way. I would like you to answer this dilemma in detail and with examples.
You just have to remember that neither you nor the opposing team can say God doesn’t exist. Many can say he does though which is where you start to think. Religion is not a light subject and no one can simply throw it in the dustbin. Deep down, they still feel like something isn’t right with their doubts. Many people have proven much already for believers to not lose all hope in believing God exists and religion in itself has provided LOT’S of proof so its not like there are no sources of proof like atheists and agnostics like to think.
I’m still trying to understand this point so please elaborate so I can see what we’re talking about here. Overall, I get it but a detailed explanation would be great.
Yeah, I’ve heard of it, nice question. It’s a type of yoga but most importantly it is an impersonalist approach to God. It has a great connection to India more then anywhere else and it more or less was born from there. I haven’t gone very deep into it although I’ve read about it. It doesn’t worship a particular God but instead it sort of says that you are God. It is pretty much completely experimental and many things can’t be explained, even the religion can’t be explained at times. It’s not confusing just unnecessarily complicated and is Yoga, just another form. The word "Zen" is Japanese for a style of Buddhism. From the start I knew you were following Zen or the like because your views had a lot to do with impersonalism but the problem with impersonalism is that it is difficult to understand and it mainly comes from your mind, demoralizes a lot, and makes you get to the top the difficult way. Many times, it isn’t difficult to understand but it nonetheless has many un-understandable areas. Its like instead of going to school, you sit at home and meditate, trying to understand everything with your mind. This religion was created, there is solid proof if I’m not mistaken and if you compare this religion to say Christianity and or most other religions, the others seem more solid, easier, and more comforting, but most importantly, you don’t have to trouble your mind too much because the books teach you what you must search for through meditation. Doing something complicated instead of the simple doesn’t always mean you are getting there faster and/or understand more. Many could follow Zen (I’m not talking about you) but they could simply believe in it because it’s a quick answer to their doubts and/or because it doesn’t make man look illiterate. You use your mind but not everything can be understood with the mind. This body wasn’t built to understand everything; it was built to prepare us for a much higher understanding. That is what impersonalists forget. The mind itself needs to be controlled before you can use it and the problem with Zen, that I see, is that every person gets his own understanding, following whatever he/she understands in the end. It is basically not so solid and when you look at it, it seems like it was created out of agitation towards other religions that believed in a solid God or figure. Its patriarchs even tore up other scriptures. It is confusing, basically, but isn’t wrong, it’s a path nonetheless, but it can take you back instead of forward if you aren’t careful on many occasions because you place yourself under the will of your mind most of the time. It is a way of clouding out many things. This is a perfect example of creating concepts because many times, you don’t LEARN the religion, you just simply meditate and try to experimentally understand. It’s not wrong, again, and I’m not against it but it is sort of pointless when there is so much to understand already, why take the rocky road? It comes from what type of person you are, in the end. Impersonalism is a branch of Buddhism you can say to some extent. Zen is a method of knowing yourself more then rather knowing God which is the first step but not the only step to understanding who we are and who God is anyways or why we are here. Zen doesn’t always answer that question.
Well, Armenians originally worshiped the fire God (Agni, in Hindu scriptures) so does that make you a fire worshiper? I love Christianity, I love Jesus Christ, but in the end, your country should never be connected to your religion. It must come from your heart but yeah, I love my country, you can’t even imagine how much and I feel great knowing that my country was the first Christian country.
Stop saying the word “RELIGION” with so much malice and hate. Christianity is a religion and is very deep but believe it or not, many people from other religions think the same way you do about Christianity, saying it is just a man made set of rules or simply a religion. God is one and screw those that disrespect everyone in the world for going with different religions. They ruin this world more. As Christians, we need to remember what Jesus told us to, yet half of us never do. So enough with the shaking of the banners. Millions of people out there just hang a cross and think they understand what religion is. I’m tired already, enough. I get your point though Pepsi, I hope you got mine.
There are many that don’t function on religion so that’s another wrong statement. Religion is very different from everything, it feels and works very differently, I won’t even talk about the effects it has on the world.
Yes, your words did have meaning to me, I decided to read your last post more carefully this time and it was much easier I guess because we're not trying to argue anymore. I appreciate this and thank you.
So, since I don't know your particular beliefs or what you make of your path, why don't you make it explicit by sharing? I'd like to know what beliefs someone like you holds close to their heart.
In my case, I think part of my problem with finding a particular religion I find comfort in is that so many of them have create ideas and morals, however, it is not a question of which religion has better ones but instead, how well an individual can interpret those ideas to bring about a happy transformation in their lives, which will consequently end up being shared with the people around them.
My first answer to your question is that religion is a learning institution, like I said before and in school, you don’t always do what you like but what you are supposed to and in the end you understand why you had to go through it all. In your paragraph, you still didn’t say why you don’t like religion as a whole or a particular one which you should because you said that a nice religion to you must bring a happy transformation, etc. Moving on, when I went to art class, I used to draw circles and squares and I never understood why or how these shapes could turn into a beautiful painting or figure but they did in the end and I understood, never asking that question again. Religion is not something created by man and even if it was, it is on a much higher plain materially and spiritually for the simple fact that it has a very powerful impact on our lives and it changes people and this world. Religion is not the same school you go to, it is very different. There, you get the experience and then the lessons in many cases. Religion is just like life and not everything in life is sweet but when you understand that whatever happens, happens so that you can learn something and because you are moving forward instead of going back. You can’t sit down and move forward without endeavor.
That’s why, my second answer is that when you look at spirituality or religion, don’t consider your senses or your skin first. Happiness comes from endeavor, it doesn’t grow on trees, and endeavor comes from understanding, which in turn comes from your mind and heart. Religion doesn’t open your mind; it opens your heart first which is the most difficult process in life. If your heart is not open, your mind never will be and it will be your worst enemy, confusing you and taking you away from the light.
My third answer is as follows. When you say “finding a particular religion”, I want you to understand the meaning of religion first. In school, you learn math but you can learn the same math in any other school just maybe in a slightly different way with slightly different teachers, at a slower or faster pace, but the goal is still the same. You know why there are different religions? What the point of that grand plan is? Because there are so many different people in the world with different views, with different problems, with different limitations, etc. The goal of religion is not to make you see God or something, it’s to prepare you. If you pass 3rd grade, you still have a long way to go, bro, you aren’t there yet. Just something I would like to point out real quick is that statistics show that believers in God seem to live much more peaceful, happy lives then those that don’t. I have even compared two different people I knew with different views and the difference was incredible. The one that didn’t believe in God seemed completely lost and unhappy; making everyone else unhappy while the believer was a completely different story (I’m not saying all are happy or unhappy). So, even if religion was created by man, lol, I am grateful eternally to that man. In this case, we should take into account NOT where or how Religion was created but what impact it has on our lives for the simple fact that NO ONE can prove religion was created by man or God doesn’t exist. Religion has the power to change the world and it is so let’s not laugh at religion as if some idiot created it or it was a mistake and everyone just suddenly people began to follow it like morons. It has always been there.
My point, going back to my original view (don’t think about your skin first) is that don’t look for a religion with the thought of finding one that will fit into your schedule, YOU have to fit into religion, not the other way around because there is good and bad everywhere BUT remember, religion is never mistaken, its followers are. In school, the school teaches perfectly but the students and/or teachers make it a good famous school or an infamous school. NEVERTHELESS, you should respect all religions and go with the religion you feel very close to and feel you can understand better or feel closer to God or to your own heart. You aren’t at school because of the students, you are there to learn. There is no ONE RIGHT PATH in this world and I hate it when preachers try to prove other religions wrong and that their religion is the very best or even worse, is the only right path. When there weren’t the religions we know now, people still believed in God, they didn’t live in emptiness until preachers appeared. They have always been around too though and I don’t have anything against them. They sometimes go too far though. Last but not least, do anything you do with your heart and not with force but sometimes you have to control yourself and try hard. Religion is not a very easy task and people shy away. Endeavor and understanding spells and equals sacrifice. Be prepared although don’t be afraid, it’s not a daunting task. People spend so much more energy on material activities but are afraid to follow simple guidelines that take away almost only 5-10% of the energy spent overall. Man complicates things too much sometimes. Let’s not make religion comfortable for us but get comfortable with a religion. Many Christians out there don’t follow half of what Jesus say’s, those people manipulate the religion instead of working on themselves for the religion.
You could say that I am interested in every religious practice (discerning what underlying messages it and its followers have to teach which lead to happiness)
Unless I forget this understanding which seems to occur in debates in which I argue agnostic points of view, usually started because of debates about God existing or not
which I continue to find to be wasteful activities because the endeavor of trying to proving such a thing has no place in one's feeling God in their lives.
I would like to clarify something about pointlessness however. First, I will ask you a compound question, have you heard of Zen and if so, what do you know about it?
Originally Posted by KarotheGreat
My religion is Hayastan, Armenia for the rest I just don't care about religion at all.
My religion is our history. Christianity is part of our history.
My religion is Hayastan, Armenia for the rest I just don't care about religion at all.
My religion is our history. Christianity is part of our history.
Why would anyone follow religion (which is man made rules)?
The diffrence between Christianity & all other religions is that Christianity is not a religion. It’s a personal relationship with you & Christ.
The diffrence between Christianity & all other religions is that Christianity is not a religion. It’s a personal relationship with you & Christ.
Religion is a behavioral rule for a society to function. For us Armenians to thrive we should base our religion on our OWN past experiences.
Comment