How does everyone feel about Israel?

[KarotheGreat]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

I don't think xxxish isn't the right word I don't think that average xxx/Joe didn't know what was going on and didn't have any connection with what was going on. But what can be said is that there are Zionist organizations involved like the German government and military was involved. However Turks were involved from government till villagers, the government planned everything and the villagers were the ones that were slaughtering, I advise go and read the Armenian Golgotha, there you get to see what the Turks were doing, not the government or policemen but villagers and other ordinary Turks.

[Persopolis]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

... That "eye for an eye" notion is very primitive and anti-Christian.

Try waving flowers at the Azerbaijan military and see how far you get. Yes, war is very primitive. The less arms you have, the more primitive it becomes.

[Persopolis]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

blaming the armenian genocide on j3ws is more of a wetdream for anti-semites and skinheads....

So a J3wish author that writes a 500+ page book detailing the J3wish-Turks involvement in the Armenian Genocide transforms the J3wish author into a "skinhead"? Let me guess: He ate too much sauerkraut, decided to shave his head and write a big book? How did that happen Mos?

No, it's making the connection of blaming the Armenian Genocide on Zionists or xxxs by nit picking a few elements in the whole genocide process.

I certainly have no problem with peace-loving J3ws, but I won't kiss motzah-balls by calling orchestration of the Armenian Genocide "nit picking." Helping to cause Genocide is blameworthy -- I don't care who does it. Turks, J3ws, Eskimos, Kurds, or little green men ...

Mos, didn't you dismiss the author's 500+ page book as "Iranian Propaganda" a comment ago - when on the front cover of the book it indicates that it has a Dutch-J3wish author? My friend, I say this respectfully: before you jump to conclusions about the contents of a book, whether the author is "anti-semitic" or the nationality of the author - shouldn't you at least look at the front cover of the book? Reading the contents of a book might also be useful in formulating an opinion of it (just a suggestion).

[Mos]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

So according to your logic, Mos, it's okay to investigate the Armenian Genocide as long as we focus narrowly on "Turks"? But if we focus research on J3wish-Turks (Khazars / Crypto-J3ws, etc.) ... it's "anti-semitic propaganda"?

No, it's making the connection of blaming the Armenian Genocide on Zionists or xxxs by nit picking a few elements in the whole genocide process. It becomes anti-Semitic when you blame the heavy accusation of genocide on a whole people/religion - rather than focusing on the perpetrators and paying attention to their own identity and intentions. In the end the people who carried it out were Turks and to a large extent Kurds who saw it as an opportunity to rid the lands in which they were living of Armenians, and take their possessions with that.

[Persopolis]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

There are conspiracy theories for everything - there are people who write books about J3wish holocaust not happening. Saying that J3ws are responsible for the Genocide of Armenians is absurd and has no legitimate historic backing, maybe a couple of fringe historians here and there that have an anti-Semitic agenda.

Israeli Minister "We always use the anti-Semitism trick or bring up the Holocaust": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uW3a1bw5XlE

And why keep focussing on the "J3wish Holocaust"? What does that have to do with the Armenian Genocide?

Turks were involved in the Armenian Genocide - among them were J3wish-Turks (Khazars). Do J3wish-Turks exist? Yes, given that they have a website up and running in Turkey, I'd say that is fairly solid evidence - not a conspiracy theory: http://www.turkiye.net/sota/karaim.html

An Israeli Professor, Dr. Sholomo Sand, who also teaches at NYU, has a book called the invention of the J3wish people - is he an "anti-semitic fringe historian" also?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2010...-israel-xxxish

So according to your logic, Mos, it's okay to investigate the Armenian Genocide as long as we focus narrowly on "Turks"? But if we focus research on J3wish-Turks (Khazars / Crypto-J3ws, etc.) ... it's "anti-semitic propaganda"?

From the Turkish-J3wish Website:

“Khazars were a Turkish group of tribes and nations….”

“What strikes any student of Judaism regarding the description of the Karaites in the Crimea and (somewhat less so) in all of Eastern Europe, is how "unxxxish" they are made to appear.”

“The Crimean Karaites did not speak any of the usual xxxish dialects, such as Jiddish or Ladino, but such Turkish dialects as Karaim, similar to those of their neighbours, which they later brought with them to Poland and Lithuania.” (Translation: They hid their identity.)

“The "unxxxishness" of the Karaites of the Crimea and (to a lesser extent) of Eastern Europe, can be explained not only by ethnic linkage, but by their "ability to take on the colouring of the wider society. (It) was evident when they described themselves as xxxs if they lived among xxxs, as Turks when in Turkey, as Russians when in Russia and as Poles when in Poland" (E. Trevisan-Semi, Nazi and Vichy, 82).

Bibliography Cited For Quotes
Petahia of Regensburg, Sibuv, Altona 1770, 2;
T. Kowalski, Karaimsche Texte im Dialekt von Troki, Krakow 1929, XI;
D.M. Dunlop, The History of the xxxish Khazars, Princeton 1954 (with detailed bibliography);
E. Trevisan-Semi, Ebrei Caraiti, 60

[KanadaHye]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

There are conspiracy theories for everything - there are people who write books about J3wish holocaust not happening. Saying that J3ws are responsible for the Genocide of Armenians is absurd and has no legitimate historic backing, maybe a couple of fringe historians here and there that have an anti-Semitic agenda.

It's not an anti-Semitic agenda, the Zionists are an open book. Their role in the holocaust and their ties with the Nazi regime is rather well documented. In addition, Iran played a rather important role in WWII.

'Thousands of Iranian civilians played a role in the war effort from laborers for road building and drivers to skilled mechanics at the "little Detroit's" truck assembly plants at Andimeshk. In one year 648,000 vehicles were built in Iran for shipment to the Soviet Union. '


'The Persian Corridor, or Bridge To Victory as it was called in Persian, provided a vital link for war supplies in one direction while at the same time serving as a humanitarian passage for J3wish and Polish refugees, many of whom arrived in Iran by crossing the Caspian in ships that had delivered supplies to ports in Baku, Azerbaijan or Krasnovodsk, Turkmenistan.'


Bridge to victory
THE IRANIAN: History, World War II, Persian Corridor
http://www.iranian.com/History/Nov97/WWII/index.html

[Mos]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

I think to know who to blame - you first have to first be open to the question of investigating who was responsible (both the main participants and the background players). Turks aren't immune from inquiry, nor should any other group be. I know if someone committed Genocide against my people - I'd even look into whether Eskimos were responsible if presented with a reasonable suspicion. Genocide is a serious crime: those suspected should be looked at carefully.

(Just so everyone doesn't get the wrong idea - Iran has a minority J3wish community that are not Zionists, and nobody has a problem with them. God bless them.)


The author of the book is below - he's not Iranian. Rather than writing off a video as "Iranian propaganda" that's merely subtitled so Iranians can read it in Persian - it makes sense to read the book first. If you looked at the first page, you'd see that it wasn't even written by an Iranian. Why so quick to blame the Iranians, but not investigate the Zionists for a hand in the Armenian Genocide?

"The complete 575 page book
The xxxish Genocide of Armenian Christians
by Christopher Jon Bjerknes
Enlarged Second Edition"

There are conspiracy theories for everything - there are people who write books about J3wish holocaust not happening. Saying that J3ws are responsible for the Genocide of Armenians is absurd and has no legitimate historic backing, maybe a couple of fringe historians here and there that have an anti-Semitic agenda.

[Persopolis]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

blaming the armenian genocide on j3ws is more of a wetdream for anti-semites and skinheads, in my opinion a way to counterweight the genocide of the j3ws in ww2.

I think to know who to blame - you first have to first be open to the question of investigating who was responsible (both the main participants and the background players). Turks aren't immune from inquiry, nor should any other group be. I know if someone committed Genocide against my people - I'd even look into whether Eskimos were responsible if presented with a reasonable suspicion. Genocide is a serious crime: those suspected should be looked at carefully.

(Just so everyone doesn't get the wrong idea - Iran has a minority J3wish community that are not Zionists, and nobody has a problem with them. God bless them.)

seems to me to be more Iranian propaganda against j3ws, more than anything else.

The author of the book is below - he's not Iranian. Rather than writing off a video as "Iranian propaganda" that's merely subtitled so Iranians can read it in Persian - it makes sense to read the book first. If you looked at the first page, you'd see that it wasn't even written by an Iranian. Why so quick to blame the Iranians, but not investigate the Zionists for a hand in the Armenian Genocide?

"The complete 575 page book
The xxxish Genocide of Armenian Christians
by Christopher Jon Bjerknes
Enlarged Second Edition"

[KanadaHye]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

blaming the armenian genocide on j3ws is more of a wetdream for anti-semites and skinheads, in my opinion a way to counterweight the genocide of the j3ws in ww2.

Within j3wish circles, there is a belief that certain j3wish groups engineered their own genocide. Zionists are pretty radical...

[Mos]

Re: How does everyone feel about Israel?

True, but he's just exposing Racism, Zionism, Bolshevism, etc. He's the owner of the website j3wishracism.com. He wrote a 575 page book in .pdf format titled THE J3WISH GENOCIDE OF ARMENIAN CHRISTIANS.

blaming the armenian genocide on j3ws is more of a wetdream for anti-semites and skinheads, in my opinion a way to counterweight the genocide of the j3ws in ww2.