Announcement

Collapse

Forum Rules (Everyone Must Read!!!)

1] What you CAN NOT post.

You agree, through your use of this service, that you will not use this forum to post any material which is:
- abusive
- vulgar
- hateful
- harassing
- personal attacks
- obscene

You also may not:
- post images that are too large (max is 500*500px)
- post any copyrighted material unless the copyright is owned by you or cited properly.
- post in UPPER CASE, which is considered yelling
- post messages which insult the Armenians, Armenian culture, traditions, etc
- post racist or other intentionally insensitive material that insults or attacks another culture (including Turks)

The Ankap thread is excluded from the strict rules because that place is more relaxed and you can vent and engage in light insults and humor. Notice it's not a blank ticket, but just a place to vent. If you go into the Ankap thread, you enter at your own risk of being clowned on.
What you PROBABLY SHOULD NOT post...
Do not post information that you will regret putting out in public. This site comes up on Google, is cached, and all of that, so be aware of that as you post. Do not ask the staff to go through and delete things that you regret making available on the web for all to see because we will not do it. Think before you post!


2] Use descriptive subject lines & research your post. This means use the SEARCH.

This reduces the chances of double-posting and it also makes it easier for people to see what they do/don't want to read. Using the search function will identify existing threads on the topic so we do not have multiple threads on the same topic.

3] Keep the focus.

Each forum has a focus on a certain topic. Questions outside the scope of a certain forum will either be moved to the appropriate forum, closed, or simply be deleted. Please post your topic in the most appropriate forum. Users that keep doing this will be warned, then banned.

4] Behave as you would in a public location.

This forum is no different than a public place. Behave yourself and act like a decent human being (i.e. be respectful). If you're unable to do so, you're not welcome here and will be made to leave.

5] Respect the authority of moderators/admins.

Public discussions of moderator/admin actions are not allowed on the forum. It is also prohibited to protest moderator actions in titles, avatars, and signatures. If you don't like something that a moderator did, PM or email the moderator and try your best to resolve the problem or difference in private.

6] Promotion of sites or products is not permitted.

Advertisements are not allowed in this venue. No blatant advertising or solicitations of or for business is prohibited.
This includes, but not limited to, personal resumes and links to products or
services with which the poster is affiliated, whether or not a fee is charged
for the product or service. Spamming, in which a user posts the same message repeatedly, is also prohibited.

7] We retain the right to remove any posts and/or Members for any reason, without prior notice.


- PLEASE READ -

Members are welcome to read posts and though we encourage your active participation in the forum, it is not required. If you do participate by posting, however, we expect that on the whole you contribute something to the forum. This means that the bulk of your posts should not be in "fun" threads (e.g. Ankap, Keep & Kill, This or That, etc.). Further, while occasionally it is appropriate to simply voice your agreement or approval, not all of your posts should be of this variety: "LOL Member213!" "I agree."
If it is evident that a member is simply posting for the sake of posting, they will be removed.


8] These Rules & Guidelines may be amended at any time. (last update September 17, 2009)

If you believe an individual is repeatedly breaking the rules, please report to admin/moderator.
See more
See less

Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Vrej1915
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    Originally posted by Eddo211 View Post
    I don't think so....he can take those Iskanders back to Russia and stick it. If he wants to show that Armenia is an ally and we are comrades then he should have brought with him attack aircraft instead of stupid mobile missiles when you as Russia has given Azerbaijani the air superiority over the conflict and then some.



    Keep us dumb and happy....
    Just for the irony:
    Lebanon is a small country, with virtually no national identity. It is the sum of 17 religious communities (among them 3 Armenian, registered as 3 different entities).
    The Lebanese army was always a parade force, with no fighting operational or tactical capacity.

    At best, it was meant to serve as an internal police force, more often as 'peacekeeper' among the various militias, during the chronic civil fights.
    In good days, it served during independence parade, once a year, in November 22, with brand new uniforms and shining swords for new, well paid officers, of middle class maronite and sunnite communities... in bad days, hiding behind sand bags, in the middle of two fighting forces, ordered to not use its small fire power...
    Since the 2006 war, the armed milicia of the most numerous religious entity, is by far more capable, than the official army of the state.

    The Lebanese National Army was always "pro-West", first in "French" hands after the independence, then US...
    Accordingly the Army was always lightly armed, just in case it dared to counter its southern border....
    Anyway, the need of an effective armed forces was never expressed by any Lebanese government, at any time...

    During the years preceding the civil war of 75, the Lebanese Air Force was equipped with 'state of the art' french jets, if I'm not wrong a squadron of 12 Mirage F1 or FIII ?? Plus it did have UK made Hawker Hunters, which by the times were used as training jets by most owners, just as our nowdays Albatros..
    It also had a bunch of choppers, French made Puma's, Alouette's, and some US made Vietnam era ones...
    The only use of this force was in 72, when the President Frangiye used some Hawker Hunter sorties, to bomb Palestinian camps in the outskirts of Beirut... just to order a halt, when the Arab League (i.E. Saudi Arabia,& Koweit) went furious...
    The Mirages never flew , as a matter of fact... most did rust in the Bunkers of the only Airbase of the state in Rayak (under Syrian control for 25 years..), and very occasionally did the Hawker Hunters take a tour for independence parade...
    The only memorable incident concerning this air force, was the sensational killing of the Prime Minister Karame, by a bomb installed under his seat (supposedly prepared by the mos-ad, and installed by the Lebaneese Forces Militia ?), which was actioned during a transport mission of the French made military transport helicopter Puma, between the Sunni hometown of Tripoli and muslim held West Beirut, while fliying the costline of Eastern Beirut (or the Christian enclave), where the Lebaneese Forces milicia was based....
    The Chopper did land "unharmed", everybody was safe and well (put aside a psychological shake and the fear of their life, something non uncommon in those days Lebanon), apart a hole in the place of the chair, where the chair of Mr Karame was.... The explosion was so well directed, that it ejected only the seat of the Prime minister, and all his body, into the Mediterranean...but the hole was not big enough, and the already corpse, or body (??) was beheaded, and the head remained in the arms of the Minister sitting just next to the Prime Minister...
    In my knowledge, this was a unique case of selective targeting, concerning a military chopper in the air ...

    (The second incident, is more from 007 series, when KGB agents, tried to pay a Lebanese pilot, before the civil war, in early 70's, to steal his Mirage from Rayak base, and fly to Baku, so they could examine it... this supposed plot never materialized, thanks to the "efficiency of the Lebanese counter intelligence", and the "patriotism of the pilot" who gave away the word to the latter..
    PS: I'm not sure of the veracity of this story, which came out lately, in the lebanese press, a couple of years ago)

    So, this to say, that the Lebanese Air Force is a virtual one, and in no ways does need state of the art, 4 rth generation jets, specially not russian made, since all the equipment is western, and they do not have the capacity to maintain them, if they did not manage, or needed to manage their cheaper, older, simpler Mirages....

    Plus, if ever 10 Mig 29 were to land in Beirut, and provided they could be of any use (threat), they would be instantly be destroyed by the Israeli Air Force, hundred times stronger , patrolling all day Lebanese skies, regardless of international norms...

    Nevertheless, Russia, did offer 10 Mig 29 free of charge to Lebanon....in 2008-2010 (the same lot that was produced for Algeria, but was returned by the latter for technical defects ??):
    Lebanon Glad about Free Russian MiG-29 Fighters, but Wants Helicopters InsteadLebanon is grateful for Russia’s MiG-29 fighter jets, which Russia promised to...


    Lebanon Glad about Free Russian MiG-29 Fighters, but Wants Helicopters Instead
    26.02.2010

    Lebanon is grateful for Russia�s MiG-29 fighter jets, which Russia promised to give to the Mideastern country as a gift. However, Lebanese officials wonder whether the country really needs them. Lebanon tries to find out if Russia could replace the fighters with something else.

    Lebanese President Michel Suleiman, who is currently visiting Russia, said that Lebanon would have to evaluate its technical opportunities to understand where the jets could be deployed and decide if Lebanese pilots and specialists would be ready to service the Russian aircraft.

    Moscow announced its intention to deliver ten fighter jets to Lebanon free of charge in December of 2008. It was said that the jets would arrive in the country in 2010. One Mig-29 costs approximately $30 million. The gift therefore totals $300 million.

    The Lebanese president stated that the Russian initiative showed a very positive influence on the morale of the Lebanese army against the background of the informal embargo in the world to deliver military hardware to Lebanon.

    �Special committees of the two countries are investigating the issues of the delivery of the planes and decide whether they are needed in Lebanon,� the Lebanese president said.

    Russia and Lebanon also try to find out an opportunity to replace the MiG fighters with something else.

    �Maybe, the Lebanese would master a different model of the Russian aircraft faster and easier,� Suleiman said.

    He added that Lebanon considered other planes or helicopters as an alternative.

    �We need combat helicopters indeed. Most likely, helicopters will be our choice,� Michel Suleiman said.

    Speaking about the issues of the regulation of the conflict in the Middle East, Suleiman said that Lebanon was expecting Russia�s assistance at this point too.

    The president of Lebanon also spoke about the disarmament of Hezbollah, a non-governmental armed organization.

    �The members of Hezbollah are our citizens. The question of arms is quite solvable. They do not carry arms openly. Of course, the arms will be left in Lebanon, for the governmental army. However, it will happen only after there is no threat to the country,� he said.

    Vremya Novostei
    Last edited by Vrej1915; 11-10-2013, 01:56 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Haykakan
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    All Vrej1915 posts is crap like this and that is why i do not bother reading his posts anymore. I think hate in Vrej and Gegeve for the Russians is deeper then their love for their own people, its like an obsession.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hakob
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    Originally posted by Vrej1915 View Post
    Մոսկվան պատրաստվում է արյուն թափել Երեւանում
    Իգոր Մուրադյան
    Կիրակի, 10 Նոյեմբերի 2013,

    Ներկայում թերեւս էքսպերիմենտ է անցկացվում: Արդյոք հնարավոր են ձերբակալություններ ռուսական դեսպանատան հրահանգով: Շանթ Հարությունյանի օրինակով կցանկանային ցույց տալ, թե ինչպես կարելի է ռուսների հրամանով Երեւանում փակել հայերի բերանը եւ նրանց ներկայացնել որպես հասարակության թափթփուկներ:
    Սակայն խնդիրն ավելի արդյունավետ լուծելու համար պետք է հայերի արյունը թափել Երեւանում: Ռուսների ողջ հույսը արյունն է: Եւ դրան աջակցելու եւ արդարացնելու է հակասոցիալական բազան (հարցման իր տոկոսներով), այն պատրաստ է դրան: Սակայն հարցն այն է, թե կհաջողվի արդյոք այս անգամ փրկվել կտրուկ շրջադարձերին: Եւ այնուամենայնիվ, ռուսները ստիպված են հեծանիվ հայտնագործել...
    - See more at: http://www.lragir.am/index/arm/0/com....LiSAGp4s.dpuf
    Ha ha ha ... Look at this idiot Muraian. According to him Shant Harutyunian's and his band's arrest was ordered by russian embassy.
    Unless I saw something else on news, Shant harutyunian with his followers were marching to presidential palace armed with clubs, molotov xxxxtails and handmade magnesium bombs to start a revolution (his own words). They started the fight themselfs with escorting police. Everything was clear on cameras. This man's actions were so erratic and extreme that all the other oppositions in Armenia have distanced themselfs from him and his followers as far as they can. Some other activists explain this with his mental instability.
    So according to mouradian it was the russians who ordered to stop him. A clear lunacy. In his article above he mumbles about how russians copy west and did not invent this and that like it is a matter to us. Further he insists that russians are going to spell blood in Armenia to etablish total conroll as colonialists.... Marazm. And he calls himself a political analist.
    Maybe he does not reflect to himself that his articles are looking more and more like soviet time propaganda articles against west. Same kind of mixing of any fact without discrimination, as long as they are as much anty-west as possible.
    I can picture how much his mouth was foaming when he wrote this.
    We need political analists who are not anti russian or anti west. Ones that can critisize russia or US based on our own benefits, not becoming propagandists for either side.
    Last edited by Hakob; 11-10-2013, 09:11 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Vrej1915
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    Մոսկվան պատրաստվում է արյուն թափել Երեւանում
    Իգոր Մուրադյան
    Կիրակի, 10 Նոյեմբերի 2013,


    Ռուսները վատ գյուտարարներ չեն եղել, սակայն միշտ ինչ որ տարօրինակ ռեժիմով՝ հայտնագործությունները, որպես կանոն, հայտնվում էին այլ երկրներում նույնանման հայտնագործություններից որոշ ժամանակ անց: Օրինակ, մինչ այժմ հասկանալի չէ՝ ով է հայտնագործել ռադիոն՝ Պոպովը, թե այնուամենայնիվ Մարկոնին: Պատմական փորձը, սակայն, մեծ բան է, եւ երեւում է ռուսները սկսել են հարմարվել արեւմտյան նոու-հաուներին, եւ ոչ թե հեծանիվ հայտնագործել:
    Նախկին դեսպան Կովալենկոն, ժամանակին տապալելով աշխատանքները նախ Վրաստանում, հետո Հայաստանում, ներկայում զբաղվում է Հայաստանի ուղղությամբ քարոզչությամբ, առաջարկում է հեծանիվ չհայտնագործել, այլ փող բաժանել հայ (եւ երեւի ոչ հայ) քարոզիչներին, ինչպես անում են արեւմտյան պետությունները:
    Ռուսները շատ են ուզում ապրել ու աշխատել ամերիկացիների պես, ոչ թե եվրոպացիների, այլ հենց ամերիկացիների պես: Եւ դա միայն ներկայիս սերունդը, իսկ ինչ ասել ռուսների ապագա սերնդի մասին, որը կրթություն է ստացել արեւմտյան համալսարաններում: Ոման մեջ «ամերիկանիզմը» ներդրվել է հարմարվողականության պատճառով, ոմանց մեջ էլ՝ թերարժեքության բարդույթից: Որքան մեծաշուք էր կայսրությունը, այնքան ցավոտ է անկումը:
    Ներկայում ակնհայտ է դառնում, որ քարոզչությամբ ռուսները չեն սահմանափակվելու: Նրանք շատ լավ են հասկանում, որ պրո-ռուսական քարոզչությունը Հայաստանում միշտ եղել է բավական ծավալուն եւ բազմազան, սակայն քիչ թե շատ մրցակցության պայմաններում ռուսական քարոզչությունն անխուսափելիորեն պարտվում է: Եւ ռուսների նպատակը հայկական ԶԼՄ-ների եւ այն ամենի լիակատար ոչնչացումն է, որոնք ինչ որ կերպ ընդունակ են պաշտպանել մեր Հայրենիքի շահերը:
    Այդ պատճառով Կովալենկոյի եւ այսպես կոչված Ռոսսոտրուդնիչեստվոյի շեֆ Կրիվոպուսկովի պասաժներն ուղղված են Հայաստանի գաղութացման դիմադրության չեզոքացմանը: Դա պետք է անել արագ ու վճռական, առավել եւս Պուտինի այցի նախաշեմին: Խնդիր է դրվել մաքրել «կանաչ ուղեգորգը» Ռուսաստանի անհաջողակ նախագահի համար:
    Սակայն սրանք դետալներ են: Ընդհանուր առմամբ, Մոսկվայում հասկանում են, որ հնարավոր չէ ազգային ընդդիմության գոյության պայմաններում հետագայում էլ ազդել Հայաստանի վրա, առավել եւս ակնհայտորեն առաջանում է գաղութացման դիմադրության շարժում:
    Հայաստանը պետք է լիովին վերահսկելի լինի, իշխանության բոլոր մակարդակներում: Հայաստանի ազգային անվտանգության ծառայությունը հայտնի ձեւով կախման մեջ է դրվել ռուսներից, հիմա եկել է ոստիկանության ժամանակը, քանի որ առաջացել է հայ հանրությանը ճնշելու խնդիրը: Այսինքն, Հայաստանը պետք է զրկվի նույնիսկ կարծիք հայտնելու իրավունքից: Այդ մասին արդեն խոսում են Ռուսաստանի պաշտոնական դեմքերը, եւ դա արվելու է ավելի համոզիչ:
    Դրա համար կա համապատասխան հակասոցիալական բազա, ի դեմս ռուսական ագենտուրայի ու կրեատուրայի: Գործակալները մարդիկ են, որոնց վճարում են: Կրեատուրան մարդիկ են, որոնք իրենք են վճարում:
    Ռուսները չեն կարող անտեսել այն հանգամանքը, որ շատ ազդեցիկ մարդիկ Հայաստանում, ինչպես նաեւ Ղարաբաղում մնացել են չհավաքագրված: Հայաստանում կան մարդիկ, որոնք տասնամյակներով աշխատում են ռուսների վրա, ընդ որում՝ այնքան ոչ պրոֆեսիոնալ ձեւով, որ հայտնի են նույնիսկ նրանց կոդային անունները: Սակայն ոչ բոլորի բախտն է բերել: Շատերը զբաղվում են այդ գործով, ակնհայտ պատրանքներ ունենալով, որ իրենք նույնպես «գործակալներ են»: Աստիճանաբար պարզվում է, որ ոչ «գործակալ» են, ոչ էլ «կրեատուրա», այլ պարզապես թափթփուկներ ու սոցիալական պեդերաստներ:
    Սակայն հայ անտաղանդ քարոզիչների հետ հույսեր չեն կապում, եւ մարտի են նետվում ռուսական ռեսուրսները: Երեւան ժամանող ռուս լրագրողներն իրենց պահում են ինչպես գաղութում, ոտքերը սրբելով հայկական ֆիզիոնոմիայի վրա, թքելով Հայաստանի ու հայերի վրա: Եթե նման բան անեին Ադրբեջանում, նրանց գլուխը կկտրեին, կփաթաթեին փայլաթիթեղի մեջ ու փոստով կուղարկեին նրանց ծնողներին: Իսկ Հայաստանում ուրախ են, որ այդ կերպ իրենց վրա ուշադրություն են դարձնում:
    Ներկայում թերեւս էքսպերիմենտ է անցկացվում: Արդյոք հնարավոր են ձերբակալություններ ռուսական դեսպանատան հրահանգով: Շանթ Հարությունյանի օրինակով կցանկանային ցույց տալ, թե ինչպես կարելի է ռուսների հրամանով Երեւանում փակել հայերի բերանը եւ նրանց ներկայացնել որպես հասարակության թափթփուկներ:
    Սակայն խնդիրն ավելի արդյունավետ լուծելու համար պետք է հայերի արյունը թափել Երեւանում: Ռուսների ողջ հույսը արյունն է: Եւ դրան աջակցելու եւ արդարացնելու է հակասոցիալական բազան (հարցման իր տոկոսներով), այն պատրաստ է դրան: Սակայն հարցն այն է, թե կհաջողվի արդյոք այս անգամ փրկվել կտրուկ շրջադարձերին: Եւ այնուամենայնիվ, ռուսները ստիպված են հեծանիվ հայտնագործել...
    - See more at: http://www.lragir.am/index/arm/0/com....LiSAGp4s.dpuf

    Leave a comment:


  • Hakob
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    I heard that. But also everybody was comparing SU25 with US groundhogs. Those we know are ground support crafts. In any case it would be easy to damage azery airforse because you could see them coming a wile longer than they could see you when you pop up from behind the mountain and over their troops.

    Leave a comment:


  • Eddo211
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    Exactly.....strategy is the key to the success of AEF

    say a band of six crack pilots flying modified SU-25s could not only provide air cover for ground troops here and there when called upon but in time reduce the operational capabilities of the Azeri airforce drastically and painfully.
    also with coordinated attack with ground forces, intel, and divergent AEF can sneek in undetected until the payload has been delivered. The best flight path between two points is not necessarily a straight line.

    Did you know an SU-25 can push Mach 1 once clean (no bombs, drop tanks, missiles hanging off the wings).

    Leave a comment:


  • Hakob
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    If your air force survives opening blows, then with skillfull pilots you can use mountains to hide your attacking aircraft untill last moment. That would be very effective air support around Artsakh and Armenia. Problem is the rest of azeriland is flat plains and unfortunately their radars will keep you lighted much easily, unless you take them out first. That means hide your aircraft untill the time is right. Maybe few days or even weeks.

    Leave a comment:


  • Eddo211
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    Originally posted by Hakob View Post
    Why cannot turkish air force get directly involved? Who is going to stop them? Nato? Any western country? Recent history shows that turkey sent it's planes several times to bomb neighbors with impunity. Iraq, Cypress, Syria. Europe, US, NATO or anybody did not do anything.
    Maybe you mean russian air base is the deterrent? So do lot of people who hate russia, but take russian cover for granted. Interestingly, though I think that russia is an ally, but i don't trust them fully. And I don't think that we should take russian military partnership for granted. I think we should rely on ourselves with worse case scenario in mind as to a high probability of turkish involvement. Otherwise we wont be able to survive worst case scenario in real.
    I don't think Turks want Azeris get stronger by helping them take Armenia.....they want to take it themselves, one day. I agree though, that danger is there and we should be prepared. Turkish Azeri relations is not as good as we may think I know we consider all of them Turks
    If Azerbaijan attacks Artsakh only then it is a good bet that the Turkish government will not get directly involved.

    When you look at the google satellite images and maps it is very easy to spot azery or our air bases. They are easy targets.
    I think both air forces will suffer fatal blows by rocketry right at the beginning of hostilities. And the main reason is the lack of operations depth for both adversaries. Both air forces are within easy reach for even short range missiles.
    Maybe something like this is calculated by our defense dept, and is one of the reasons as to why our government does not emphasize air force development as much as air defenses, MLRS systems and heavy ground equipment.
    This is good point and you are right, this is why we must have aircraft bunkers, improvised airfields even in mountainous areas......Russian aircraft are designed to operate off-airfield and even dirt runways. You can hide them if you really want it to....weather and terrain might become a challenge but you could run missions and then disappear.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hakob
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    [QUOTE=Eddo211;346117]Turkish air force cannot get directly involved in renewed war in Artsakh other than AWACS and satelite intelligence transfer.

    Why cannot turkish air force get directly involved? Who is going to stop them? Nato? Any western country? Recent history shows that turkey sent it's planes several times to bomb neighbors with impunity. Iraq, Cypress, Syria. Europe, US, NATO or anybody did not do anything.
    Maybe you mean russian air base is the deterrent? So do lot of people who hate russia, but take russian cover for granted. Interestingly, though I think that russia is an ally, but i don't trust them fully. And I don't think that we should take russian military partnership for granted. I think we should rely on ourselves with worse case scenario in mind as to a high probability of turkish involvement. Otherwise we wont be able to survive worst case scenario in real.
    When you look at the google satellite images and maps it is very easy to spot azery or our air bases. They are easy targets.
    I think both air forces will suffer fatal blows by rocketry right at the beginning of hostilities. And the main reason is the lack of operations depth for both adversaries. Both air forces are within easy reach for even short range missiles.
    Maybe something like this is calculated by our defense dept, and is one of the reasons as to why our government does not emphasize air force development as much as air defenses, MLRS systems and heavy ground equipment.
    Last edited by Hakob; 11-08-2013, 08:33 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • gegev
    replied
    Re: Is Russia an ally or foe, nowadays?

    Originally posted by Eddo211 View Post
    Not only its important as a military platform but it also opens doors to domestic contractors, engineers, young minds.....it is an industry of its own and pushes for inventions and dreams.
    AEF....Armenian Eagle Force.
    I remember under USSR we had aircraft factory subsidiary in Armenia, where we produced aircraft parts, subsystems; I guess aerials etc., as it was produced for spaceships. Let’s hope that our leadership would be smart enough to reopen the factory doors for our scientists, workers, if they are still here in Armenia. Part of the military budget can be used to produce the cheapest and advanced parts; MADE IN ARMENIA.
    Last edited by gegev; 11-08-2013, 03:06 AM.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X